The Discussion Station

The Passenger Lounge: Reading and Recreation => The Game Room => Topic started by: Evreka on July 07, 2014, 06:42:45 PM

Title: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 07, 2014, 06:42:45 PM
:harry: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II  :harry:

It was time to break off the old thread (http://forum.discussionstation.com/index.php?topic=295.0) that had grown to become twice as long as a Basilisk... :ginny:


Rules for the game

1. The person who wins/guesses the previous round correctly gets to start the next round.

2. The person starting the round chooses one subject from the Harry Potter books (the 7 books only, not J.K. Rowling's other books such as Beedle the Bard, Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, or Quidditch Through the Ages) in one of 6 categories: person, creature, spell, potion, place, and thing.  Please note that for the purposes of this game, the category of "creature" includes all non-human beings such as goblins, house-elves, and giants.

3. The category is announced and other players start asking yes/no questions to try to guess what the subject is.

4. Each player can ask only one question per post, and cannot put in two consecutive posts but is welcome to ask a new question after another player puts in a question.

5. Questions and answers must be limited to book canon only, not the movies or extra information from Pottermore or from the author's website or interviews.

6. If the subject has not been guessed after reaching 20 questions, hints are allowed to be given.

7. If for whatever reason the person answering the questions cannot or does not come back to the thread for 3 days, we can start over with a new round.  If this happens, there's no need to wait for a Moderator's 'OK' - the first person who posts in the thread after 3 days can go ahead and start a new round.


Please remember to also follow the general rules and guidelines for the Recreation Center here (http://forum.discussionstation.com/index.php?topic=366.0) that apply to all game threads.

-------------

The old thread is broken off where I've just won the round and am about to start a new one! So here we go...


Is it the Potters' cat, that Lily mentions in a letter to Sirius?? The one that nearly gets killed by baby Harry on a toy broomstick?  :crookshanks:  :harryquidditch:
Evreka - well done  :nod:

Everything seems to be about cats here at DS ... so I thought  :P
:fredgeorge:


I'm thinking of a thing....
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on July 07, 2014, 06:48:14 PM
Is this  thing used?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 07, 2014, 06:55:51 PM
I'm thinking of a .... thing....

1) Yes, it is used.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 07, 2014, 08:10:15 PM
Is it owned? (Whether by an individual, a group or an institution)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 07, 2014, 09:16:18 PM
I'm thinking of a .... thing....

1) Yes, it is used.
2) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an individual, a group or an institution)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 07, 2014, 10:04:34 PM
Is it magic?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 08, 2014, 09:53:45 AM
I'm thinking of a .... thing....

1) Yes, it is used.
2) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an individual, a group or an institution)
3) Yes, it is magical.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 08, 2014, 07:45:33 PM
is it used at Hogwarts ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 08, 2014, 09:38:19 PM
I'm thinking of a .... thing....

1) Yes, it is used.
2) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an individual, a group or an institution)
3) Yes, it is magical.
4) Yes, it is used at Hogwarts.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 09, 2014, 02:23:04 AM
is it owned by a student ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on July 09, 2014, 12:03:26 PM
Is it in one or more of the first three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 09, 2014, 12:09:37 PM
I'm thinking of a .... thing....

1) Yes, it is used.
2) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an individual, a group or an institution)
3) Yes, it is magical.
4) Yes, it is used at Hogwarts.
5) Yes, it is owned by a student.
6) Yes, it is in one or more of the first three books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on July 09, 2014, 05:09:20 PM
Is it seen?

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 09, 2014, 07:27:51 PM
Is it also in one or more of the last three book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 10, 2014, 04:11:40 AM
is the owner female ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on July 10, 2014, 08:23:41 PM
Is it used for school work?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 10, 2014, 10:00:18 PM
is it in PS/SS ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 11, 2014, 05:39:52 PM
I'm thinking of a .... thing....

1) Yes, it is used.
2) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an individual, a group or an institution)
3) Yes, it is magical.
4) Yes, it is used at Hogwarts.
5) Yes, it is owned by a student.
6) Yes, it is in one or more of the first three books.
7) Yes, it is seen.
8 ) No, it is not also in one or more of the last three books.
9) No, the owner is not female.
10) Well... no, ... as far as we know it is not used for school work.
11) Yes, it is in PS/SS.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on July 11, 2014, 05:45:18 PM
Does it belong to one of the trio?  :harry: :ron: :hermioneread:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 11, 2014, 05:48:06 PM
I'm thinking of a .... thing....

1) Yes, it is used.
2) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an individual, a group or an institution)
3) Yes, it is magical.
4) Yes, it is used at Hogwarts.
5) Yes, it is owned by a student.
6) Yes, it is in one or more of the first three books.
7) Yes, it is seen.
8 ) No, it is not also in one or more of the last three books.
9) No, the owner is not female.
10) Well... no, ... as far as we know it is not used for school work.
11) Yes, it is in PS/SS.
12) No, it does not belong to one of the trio?  :shake: :harry: :ron: :hermioneread:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on July 11, 2014, 05:55:59 PM
Does it belong to a student in Harry's year?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 11, 2014, 07:37:53 PM
Is it owned by a Gryffindor?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 11, 2014, 10:01:23 PM
I'm thinking of a .... thing....

1) Yes, it is used.
2) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an individual, a group or an institution)
3) Yes, it is magical.
4) Yes, it is used at Hogwarts.
5) Yes, it is owned by a student.
6) Yes, it is in one or more of the first three books.
7) Yes, it is seen.
8 ) No, it is not also in one or more of the last three books.
9) No, the owner is not female.
10) Well... no, ... as far as we know it is not used for school work.
11) Yes, it is in PS/SS.
12) No, it does not belong to one of the trio?  :shake: :harry: :ron: :hermioneread:
13) Yes, it does belong to a student in Harry's year.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 11, 2014, 10:42:50 PM
Evreka, you missed my last question.

Is it Neville's remembrall?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 12, 2014, 12:37:20 PM
Evreka, you missed my last question.

Is it Neville's remembrall?
Sorry 'bout that.

YES!  :yay: It is Neville's Remembrall! Well done!

10) Well... no, ... as far as we know it is not used for school work.
In theory, it could be used to check if all homework was done or similar; but although Hermione might have beem able to use a Remembrall's spinning as a reason to go through all homework and check none was forgotten; I doubt Neville was structured enough to ever know more than that he'd forgot "something" - which feels unhelpful to the teeth!   
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 12, 2014, 09:55:14 PM
Yeah, I was wondering about that "not used for school work" thing. It seemed to me the logical use for it, but couldn't recall any time Neville was seen to use it for that purpose. So I took a shot in the dark. Anyway:

I'm thinking of a spell.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 13, 2014, 04:57:24 AM
Do we see it cast?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 13, 2014, 06:44:55 AM
is the owner in Gryffindor house ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 13, 2014, 12:33:03 PM
is the owner in Gryffindor house ?
How can you own a spell? I think you missed the change of subject.

Is the spell in the first three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on July 16, 2014, 05:05:01 PM
Do we know the incantation?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 16, 2014, 07:37:07 PM
I'm thinking of a spell.

-1- We see it cast
is the owner in Gryffindor house ?
How can you own a spell? I think you missed the change of subject.
Well, I'll give Eva a break, here.
-2- The first person we see cast the spell is in Gryffindor House.
-3- The spell is in the first three books.
-4- We know the incantation.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 16, 2014, 08:08:29 PM
Is it casted in  PS/SS?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 16, 2014, 10:13:51 PM
I'm thinking of a spell.

-1- We see it cast
-2- The first person we see cast the spell is in Gryffindor House.
-3- The spell is in the first three books.
-4- We know the incantation.
-5- It is cast in PS
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 16, 2014, 10:36:01 PM
Is it Alohomora?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 17, 2014, 06:13:09 PM
Is it Petrificus Totalus?  :hermioneread:  :neville:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 17, 2014, 11:20:58 PM
I'm thinking of a spell.

-1- We see it cast
-2- The first person we see cast the spell is in Gryffindor House.
-3- The spell is in the first three books.
-4- We know the incantation.
-5- It is cast in PS
Is it Alohomora?

Yes, roonwit, it is Alohamora.

Is who, what or wherever you're thinking of magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 18, 2014, 07:22:11 PM
I am thinking of a person...

1. Yes, the person is magical.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 18, 2014, 10:21:55 PM
Are they female?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 19, 2014, 12:20:59 AM
I am thinking of a person...

1. Yes, the person is magical.
2. No, he is not female.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 19, 2014, 01:11:55 AM
Is he a student?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 19, 2014, 04:39:15 AM
is he seen ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 19, 2014, 09:33:10 AM
Does Harry ever meet or sees him?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on July 19, 2014, 11:48:10 AM
Is he in one or more of the first three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 19, 2014, 08:03:32 PM
I am thinking of a person...

1. Yes, the person is magical.
2. No, he is not female.
3. Yes, he is seen.
4. Yes, Harry does see and/or meet him.
5. No, he is not in the first three books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 19, 2014, 08:30:24 PM
is he a student ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 19, 2014, 09:26:27 PM
Is he a student?
You seem to have missed this question (really the third one).

Is he on the Dark Side?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 19, 2014, 09:56:07 PM
I am thinking of a person...

1. Yes, the person is magical.
2. No, he is not female.
3. No, he is not a student.
4. Yes, he is seen.
5. Yes, Harry does see and/or meet him.
6. No, he is not in the first three books.
7. No, he is not on the dark side, though that is a bit debatable.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 19, 2014, 10:01:32 PM
Total shot in the dark, but based on answer #7:

Is he Mundungus Fletcher?
(Maybe not on the Dark side, but certainly a shady character. ;))
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 19, 2014, 10:41:25 PM
BillieMac, Dung is mentioned in COS, so I'd say he is in the first three books....

Is he in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 20, 2014, 12:14:43 AM
I am thinking of a person...

1. Yes, the person is magical.
2. No, he is not female.
3. No, he is not a student.
4. Yes, he is seen.
5. Yes, Harry does see and/or meet him.
6. No, he is not in the first three books.
7. No, he is not on the dark side, though that is a bit debatable.
8. No, he is not Mundungus Fletcher.
9. Yes, he is in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 20, 2014, 12:50:35 AM
is he seen at Hogwarts ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 20, 2014, 07:56:21 PM
Is it Stan Shunpike?  :harryquidditch:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 20, 2014, 08:57:37 PM
I am thinking of a person...

1. Yes, the person is magical.
2. No, he is not female.
3. No, he is not a student.
4. Yes, he is seen.
5. Yes, Harry does see and/or meet him.
6. No, he is not in the first three books.
7. No, he is not on the dark side, though that is a bit debatable.
8. No, he is not Mundungus Fletcher.
9. Yes, he is in more than one book.
10. No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
11. No, it is not Stan Shunpike (He appears in the Knight Bus chapter of PoA contrary to #6).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 21, 2014, 05:43:25 AM
do we see him in London (any place) ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 21, 2014, 07:07:12 PM
Does he ever meet Voldemort?

(As for Stan Shunpike - oops!  :-[ )
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 21, 2014, 07:47:34 PM
Is he seen at the Ministry?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 21, 2014, 08:33:04 PM
I am thinking of a person...

1. Yes, the person is magical.
2. No, he is not female.
3. No, he is not a student.
4. Yes, he is seen.
5. Yes, Harry does see and/or meet him.
6. No, he is not in the first three books.
7. No, he is not on the dark side, though that is a bit debatable.
8. No, he is not Mundungus Fletcher.
9. Yes, he is in more than one book.
10. No, we do not see him anywhere in London.
11. Yes, he does meet Voldemort.
12. No, he is not seen in the Ministry.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 21, 2014, 08:37:50 PM
Does Harry see him through his connection to Voldemort?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 21, 2014, 08:58:20 PM
I am thinking of a person...

1. Yes, the person is magical.
2. No, he is not female.
3. No, he is not a student.
4. Yes, he is seen.
5. Yes, Harry does see and/or meet him.
6. No, he is not in the first three books.
7. No, he is not on the dark side, though that is a bit debatable.
8. No, he is not Mundungus Fletcher.
9. Yes, he is in more than one book.
10. No, we do not see him anywhere in London.
11. Yes, he does meet Voldemort.
12. No, he is not seen in the Ministry.
13. Yes, Harry does see him through his connection to Voldemort.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on July 21, 2014, 09:34:46 PM
A long shot here,... but is it Gregorvitch?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 21, 2014, 10:53:37 PM
A long shot here,... but is it Gregorvitch?
Yes, it is Gregorovitch. He is mentioned in GoF (as the maker of Krum's wand), and seen in DH by Harry through his link with Voldemort when Voldemort finds him. I consider it a bit debatable as to whether Gregorovitch is on the dark side, because he obtained the Elder Wand somehow and was presumably master of it (as later owners such as Dumbledore and Harry were its master) and that would be difficult to do without committing some dark acts.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on July 22, 2014, 03:09:11 PM

 I consider it a bit debatable as to whether Gregorovitch is on the dark side, because he obtained the Elder Wand somehow and was presumably master of it (as later owners such as Dumbledore and Harry were its master) and that would be difficult to do without committing some dark acts.

Difficult but not impossible - as we know how Harry became Master of the Wand.

Congrats Buckbeak  :)

While you are thinking: Is he or she or it seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 23, 2014, 07:28:17 PM
Is who what or wherever magical?

(I wonder: how many questions can be asked before Buckbeak 26 gets back, without muddying the waters?)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on July 23, 2014, 09:42:13 PM
1.Yes, She is seen.
2.Yes,She is magical.

Sorry all, I have been rather busy with work.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 24, 2014, 04:51:31 PM
is she a student ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on July 24, 2014, 06:26:42 PM
1.Yes, She is seen.
2.Yes,She is magical.
3.Yes, she is a student.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 24, 2014, 06:42:05 PM
is she in Gryffindor ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 24, 2014, 06:44:56 PM
Is she in the same school year as Harry?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 24, 2014, 10:29:12 PM
is she in the D.A. ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on July 25, 2014, 10:08:37 AM


I did forget this, but I am thinking of a person


1.Yes, She is seen.
2.Yes,She is magical.
3.Yes, she is a student.
4.No, she isn't in Gryffindor.
5. She isn't in the same school year as Harry.
6. She is in the D.A.  :da:

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on July 25, 2014, 02:11:08 PM
Is it Cho Chang?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 25, 2014, 07:06:20 PM
Is it Marietta Edgecombe?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on July 25, 2014, 09:21:49 PM
 I am thinking of a person


1.Yes, She is seen.
2.Yes,She is magical.
3.Yes, she is a student.
4.No, she isn't in Gryffindor.
5. She isn't in the same school year as Harry.
6. She is in the D.A.  :da:
7.It is not Cho Chang.
9. No, it is not Marietta Edgecombe. (The Sneak) :umbridge:

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 25, 2014, 09:38:43 PM
Is it Luna Lovegood?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on July 25, 2014, 09:45:43 PM
Yep its Luna, your turn Billie.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 26, 2014, 07:53:11 PM
Okay,

I'm thinking of a thing.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on July 26, 2014, 08:20:12 PM
The inevitable question: Is it magical  :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 26, 2014, 08:29:49 PM
Is it in the first three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 26, 2014, 09:05:58 PM
is it bigger than a Quaffle ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on July 27, 2014, 01:04:39 PM
Do the trio see this thing? :shake:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 27, 2014, 09:10:42 PM
Is it in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 28, 2014, 06:43:53 AM
is it owned by someone specific ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 28, 2014, 07:39:03 PM
I'm thinking of a thing:

-1- It is magical :)
-2- It is not in the first three books
-3- It is bigger than a quaffle
-4- The Trio see this thing (but why that particular emoticon?)
-5- It is not in more than one book
-6- It is owned by someone specific
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 28, 2014, 09:41:38 PM
Is it in books four or five?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on July 29, 2014, 05:58:56 AM
Does a professor Own it?

I had never seen the emoticon before so I wondered what it did, and how did you get my clues so easy?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 29, 2014, 09:58:40 PM
Is it owned by any of the trio?  :trio:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on July 30, 2014, 05:37:55 AM
is it owned by a female ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on July 30, 2014, 07:45:21 PM
I'm thinking of a thing:

-1- It is magical :)
-2- It is not in the first three books
-3- It is bigger than a quaffle
-4- The Trio see this thing (but why that particular emoticon?)
-5- It is not in more than one book
-6- It is owned by someone specific
-7- It is not in books four or five
-8- A professor does not own it
-9- It is not owned by any of the Trio
10- It is not owned by a female (yet)

The girls, Buckbeak 26. Your answers had eliminated the Gryffindors and the only other two Ravenclaw girls in the DA, leaving Luna and Hannah (who was going to be my next guess).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 30, 2014, 09:52:33 PM
Is it the Vannishing Cabinet that Draco buys in Borgin & Burkes in HBP?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 01, 2014, 12:04:53 AM
Is it the Vannishing Cabinet that Draco buys in Borgin & Burkes in HBP?
Draco doesn't exactly buy it in HBP, and it is where Harry hid in CoS so it is not just in the last two books.

Is the thing in book six?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 01, 2014, 04:33:31 AM
is it used ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on August 01, 2014, 10:01:13 AM
If the owner is male, is it a student?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 01, 2014, 08:53:02 PM
Is it the Vannishing Cabinet that Draco buys in Borgin & Burkes in HBP?
Draco doesn't exactly buy it in HBP, and it is where Harry hid in CoS so it is not just in the last two books.
True...  :headbang:

Is it owned by someone on the Good side?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 01, 2014, 11:55:39 PM
I'm thinking of a thing:

-1- It is magical
-2- It is not in the first three books
-3- It is bigger than a quaffle
-4- The Trio see this thing
-5- It is not in more than one book
-6- It is owned by someone specific
-7- It is not in books four or five
-8- A professor does not own it
-9- It is not owned by any of the Trio
10- It is not owned by a female (yet)
11- It is not the Vanishing Cabinet
12- It is not in book six
13- Well, it's not used when we see it, but we can presume it's used
14- The owner is not a student
15- It is owned by someone (mostly) on the good side
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 02, 2014, 05:17:17 AM
Is it seen before the trio leaves for their camping trip?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 02, 2014, 09:28:53 PM
'm thinking of a thing:

-1- It is magical
-2- It is not in the first three books
-3- It is bigger than a quaffle
-4- The Trio see this thing
-5- It is not in more than one book
-6- It is owned by someone specific
-7- It is not in books four or five
-8- A professor does not own it
-9- It is not owned by any of the Trio
10- It is not owned by a female (yet)
11- It is not the Vanishing Cabinet
12- It is not in book six
13- Well, it's not used when we see it, but we can presume it's used
14- The owner is not a student
15- It is owned by someone (mostly) on the good side
16- It is not seen before the Trio leaves for their camping trip
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on August 02, 2014, 09:34:43 PM
Is it seen at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 02, 2014, 09:48:35 PM
Is it owned by Xeno?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 02, 2014, 10:38:30 PM
I'm thinking of a thing:

-1- It is magical
-2- It is not in the first three books
-3- It is bigger than a quaffle
-4- The Trio see this thing
-5- It is not in more than one book
-6- It is owned by someone specific
-7- It is not in books four or five
-8- A professor does not own it
-9- It is not owned by any of the Trio
10- It is not owned by a female (yet)
11- It is not the Vanishing Cabinet
12- It is not in book six
13- Well, it's not used when we see it, but we can presume it's used
14- The owner is not a student
15- It is owned by someone (mostly) on the good side
16- It is not seen before the Trio leaves for their camping trip
17- It is not seen at Hogwarts
18- It is owned by Xeno

I say "mostly" on the good side, because he is on the good side, but his time of weakness, (perfectly understandable, imo,) has put some people off him.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 03, 2014, 03:47:14 PM
Is it the headdress Xeno Lovegood made in imitation of Rowena Rawenclaw's diadem  :ravenclawc: ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 03, 2014, 04:52:29 PM
Is it the printing press for The Quibbler?  :lunaquibbler:

15- It is owned by someone (mostly) on the good side
18- It is owned by Xeno

I say "mostly" on the good side, because he is on the good side, but his time of weakness, (perfectly understandable, imo,) has put some people off him.
That's why I guessed it could be Xeno's. :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 04, 2014, 04:10:30 PM
Is it the bust of Rowena Rawenclaw  :ravenclawc:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 04, 2014, 09:11:12 PM
I'm thinking of a thing:

-1- It is magical
-2- It is not in the first three books
-3- It is bigger than a quaffle
-4- The Trio see this thing
-5- It is not in more than one book
-6- It is owned by someone specific
-7- It is not in books four or five
-8- A professor does not own it
-9- It is not owned by any of the Trio
10- It is not owned by a female (yet)
11- It is not the Vanishing Cabinet
12- It is not in book six
13- Well, it's not used when we see it, but we can presume it's used
14- The owner is not a student
15- It is owned by someone (mostly) on the good side
16- It is not seen before the Trio leaves for their camping trip
17- It is not seen at Hogwarts
18- It is owned by Xeno
19- It is not the headdress that Xeno made
20- It is not the printing press for The Quibbler
22- It is not the bust of Rowena Ravenclaw

Hint: It is outside the house.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 05, 2014, 05:21:53 AM
is it the wizened stump of a Snargeluff ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 05, 2014, 01:06:47 PM
Is it the Erumpent Horn (although I assume it exploded, so Luna could not receive it later)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 06, 2014, 07:30:25 PM
I'm thinking of a thing:

-1- It is magical
-2- It is not in the first three books
-3- It is bigger than a quaffle
-4- The Trio see this thing
-5- It is not in more than one book
-6- It is owned by someone specific
-7- It is not in books four or five
-8- A professor does not own it
-9- It is not owned by any of the Trio
10- It is not owned by a female (yet)
11- It is not the Vanishing Cabinet
12- It is not in book six
13- Well, it's not used when we see it, but we can presume it's used
14- The owner is not a student
15- It is owned by someone (mostly) on the good side
16- It is not seen before the Trio leaves for their camping trip
17- It is not seen at Hogwarts
18- It is owned by Xeno
19- It is not the headdress that Xeno made
20- It is not the printing press for The Quibbler
22- It is not the bust of Rowena Ravenclaw
Hint: It is outside the house.
23- It is not the wizened stump of a snargeluff
24- It is not the Erumpent Horn (That was inside the house)
Hint: It  is food related
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 06, 2014, 10:18:59 PM
is it the bush covered with the orange fruits ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 08, 2014, 10:14:01 PM
While the fruits described don't float float on air, which is what you'd expect of dirigible plums, that is the bush I was thinking of.
So Eva Hedwig is the winner of this round.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 09, 2014, 06:48:31 AM
thanks Billie. I like Xeno  :)



I am thinking of a thing ....
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 09, 2014, 09:24:48 PM
Does it have magical abilities?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on August 09, 2014, 10:12:51 PM
Do we see this thing being used?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 09, 2014, 10:22:17 PM
Is this thing owned by a group, individual or institution?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 10, 2014, 06:40:15 AM
I am thinking of a thing ....

1) it doesn't have magical abilities
2) yes, we see it beeing used
3) it's owned   

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 10, 2014, 04:57:14 PM
Is it owned by someone with magical abilities (ie a witch or wizard)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 10, 2014, 07:00:25 PM
I am thinking of a thing ....

1) it doesn't have magical abilities
2) yes, we see it beeing used
3) it's owned   
4) yes it is owned by someone with magical abilities (ie a witch or wizard)  :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 10, 2014, 08:05:13 PM
Is it owned by a witch?  :mcgonagall2:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 10, 2014, 08:42:46 PM
I am thinking of a thing ....

1) it doesn't have magical abilities
2) yes, we see it beeing used
3) it's owned   
4) yes it is owned by someone with magical abilities (ie a witch or wizard)
5) no, it's not owmed by a witch
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 10, 2014, 09:23:51 PM
Is it owned by one of the trio?  :harryronbb:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 10, 2014, 09:25:15 PM
I am thinking of a thing ....

1) it doesn't have magical abilities
2) yes, we see it beeing used
3) it's owned   
4) yes it is owned by someone with magical abilities (ie a witch or wizard)
5) no, it's not owmed by a witch
6) no, its not owned by one of the trio
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 10, 2014, 09:26:03 PM
Is it owned by a student?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 10, 2014, 09:37:05 PM
I am thinking of a thing ....

1) it doesn't have magical abilities
2) yes, we see it beeing used
3) it's owned   
4) yes it is owned by someone with magical abilities (ie a witch or wizard)
5) no, it's not owmed by a witch
6) no, its not owned by one of the trio
7) o, its not owned by a student
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 11, 2014, 10:44:00 AM
Is it seen at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 11, 2014, 07:56:53 PM
Do we see it used by anyone other than the owner?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 11, 2014, 11:32:16 PM
Is it in the first three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 12, 2014, 06:00:41 AM
I am thinking of a thing ....

1) it doesn't have magical abilities
2) yes, we see it beeing used
3) it's owned   
4) yes it is owned by someone with magical abilities (ie a witch or wizard)
5) no, it's not owmed by a witch
6) no, its not owned by one of the trio
7) o, its not owned by a student
8  yes, it is seen at Hogwarts
9) we only see it used by the owner
10) it's not in one of the first three books
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 12, 2014, 09:30:37 PM
Is it owned by Albus?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 13, 2014, 02:57:24 AM
I am thinking of a thing ....

1) it doesn't have magical abilities
2) yes, we see it beeing used
3) it's owned   
4) yes it is owned by someone with magical abilities (ie a witch or wizard)
5) no, it's not owmed by a witch
6) no, its not owned by one of the trio
7) o, its not owned by a student
8  yes, it is seen at Hogwarts
9) we only see it used by the owner
10) it's not in one of the first three books

11) no, its not owned by Albus
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 13, 2014, 01:31:34 PM
Is the owner a Hogwarts professor?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 13, 2014, 06:04:41 PM
I am thinking of a thing ....

1) it doesn't have magical abilities
2) yes, we see it beeing used
3) it's owned   
4) yes it is owned by someone with magical abilities (ie a witch or wizard)
5) no, it's not owmed by a witch
6) no, its not owned by one of the trio
7) o, its not owned by a student
8  yes, it is seen at Hogwarts
9) we only see it used by the owner
10) it's not in one of the first three books

11) no, its not owned by Albus
12) yes, the owner is a Hogwarts Professor
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 13, 2014, 07:23:58 PM
Is it in the last two books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 13, 2014, 08:45:51 PM
Is it owned by Snape?   :snape:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 14, 2014, 05:05:06 AM
I am thinking of a thing ....

1) it doesn't have magical abilities
2) yes, we see it beeing used
3) it's owned   
4) yes it is owned by someone with magical abilities (ie a witch or wizard)
5) no, it's not owmed by a witch
6) no, its not owned by one of the trio
7) o, its not owned by a student
8  yes, it is seen at Hogwarts
9) we only see it used by the owner
10) it's not in one of the first three books

11) no, its not owned by Albus
12) yes, the owner is a Hogwarts Professor
13) it is in one of the last two books
14) no, nothing to do with dear Snape  :snape:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 14, 2014, 01:09:06 PM
Is it used for school work (eg teaching)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 14, 2014, 03:43:07 PM
Is it in book 6?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 14, 2014, 06:35:04 PM
Is Professor Slughorn the owner?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 14, 2014, 06:36:12 PM
I am thinking of a thing ....

1) it doesn't have magical abilities
2) yes, we see it beeing used
3) it's owned   
4) yes it is owned by someone with magical abilities (ie a witch or wizard)
5) no, it's not owmed by a witch
6) no, its not owned by one of the trio
7) o, its not owned by a student
8  yes, it is seen at Hogwarts
9) we only see it used by the owner
10) it's not in one of the first three books

11) no, its not owned by Albus
12) yes, the owner is a Hogwarts Professor
13) it is in one of the last two books
14) no, nothing to do with dear Snape
15) it is in book 6
16) it is not used for school work or teaching
17) yes, the owner is Prof. Slughorn
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 14, 2014, 06:41:32 PM
Is it some item of food or drink?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 14, 2014, 07:12:57 PM
Is it the cabinet bag of Potion ingredients that he has in his room, where Harry got the Bezoar from?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 14, 2014, 07:22:51 PM
Is it the cabinet of Potion ingredients that he has in his room, where Harry got the Bezoar from?

I don't want to critise, but I would assume the room and the furniture - although inhabited by Slughorn - belongs to Hogwarts ... ???

Is it one of the glasses of Mead Slughorn serves to Harry and Ron after Ron swallowed the antidote to the love potion?

P.S. I mean the Mead itself, not the glasses - the glassware probably belongs to Hogwarts School as well ...
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 14, 2014, 07:34:45 PM
Is it the cabinet of Potion ingredients that he has in his room, where Harry got the Bezoar from?
I don't want to critise, but I would assume the room and the furniture - although inhabited by Slughorn - belongs to Hogwarts ... ???
It is a potion kit (a bag, or in a bag) so not a cabinet (though I think it was in the film), and will be, I think, Slughorn's property.
Quote
‘I’ve got the necessary here in my bag, it’s not a difficult antidote …’
Ron burst through the door into Slughorn’s overheated, crowded study, tripped over a tasselled footstool, regained his balance by seizing Harry around the neck and muttered, ‘She didn’t see that, did she?’
‘She’s not here yet,’ said Harry, watching Slughorn opening his potion kit and adding a few pinches of this and that to a small crystal bottle.
...
Harry leapt over a low table and sprinted towards Slughorn’s open potion kit, pulling out jars and pouches, while the terrible sound of Ron’s gargling breath filled the room. Then he found it – the shrivelled kidney-like stone Slughorn had taken from him in Potions.
P.S. I mean the Mead itself, not the glasses - the glassware probably belongs to Hogwarts School as well ...
The glasses could be Slughorn's but they could also be supplied by the school.

Is it an item of clothing?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 14, 2014, 07:49:15 PM
Is it the cabinet of Potion ingredients that he has in his room, where Harry got the Bezoar from?
I don't want to critise, but I would assume the room and the furniture - although inhabited by Slughorn - belongs to Hogwarts ... ???
It is a potion kit (a bag, or in a bag) so not a cabinet (though I think it was in the film), and will be, I think, Slughorn's property.
Quote
‘I’ve got the necessary here in my bag, it’s not a difficult antidote …’
Ron burst through the door into Slughorn’s overheated, crowded study, tripped over a tasselled footstool, regained his balance by seizing Harry around the neck and muttered, ‘She didn’t see that, did she?’
‘She’s not here yet,’ said Harry, watching Slughorn opening his potion kit and adding a few pinches of this and that to a small crystal bottle.
...
Harry leapt over a low table and sprinted towards Slughorn’s open potion kit, pulling out jars and pouches, while the terrible sound of Ron’s gargling breath filled the room. Then he found it – the shrivelled kidney-like stone Slughorn had taken from him in Potions.
Thanks, roonwit, for clearing that up. It was a cabinet in the movie and I didn't remember it was changed from the book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 14, 2014, 10:09:13 PM
I am thinking of a thing ....

1) it doesn't have magical abilities
2) yes, we see it beeing used
3) it's owned   
4) yes it is owned by someone with magical abilities (ie a witch or wizard)
5) no, it's not owmed by a witch
6) no, its not owned by one of the trio
7) o, its not owned by a student
8  yes, it is seen at Hogwarts
9) we only see it used by the owner
10) it's not in one of the first three books

11) no, its not owned by Albus
12) yes, the owner is a Hogwarts Professor
13) it is in one of the last two books
14) no, nothing to do with dear Snape
15) it is in book 6
16) it is not used for school work or teaching
17) yes, the owner is Prof. Slughorn
18) no, it is no item of food or drink
19) no,  its not a bag where he keeps ingredients
20) no,  its no clothing

21) no, its not one of the glasses of mead he serves to Harry and Ron

hint: we see "it" after christmas

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 14, 2014, 11:25:52 PM
Is it a memory?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 14, 2014, 11:33:13 PM
I am thinking of a thing ....

1) it doesn't have magical abilities
2) yes, we see it beeing used
3) it's owned   
4) yes it is owned by someone with magical abilities (ie a witch or wizard)
5) no, it's not owmed by a witch
6) no, its not owned by one of the trio
7) o, its not owned by a student
8  yes, it is seen at Hogwarts
9) we only see it used by the owner
10) it's not in one of the first three books

11) no, its not owned by Albus
12) yes, the owner is a Hogwarts Professor
13) it is in one of the last two books
14) no, nothing to do with dear Snape
15) it is in book 6
16) it is not used for school work or teaching
17) yes, the owner is Prof. Slughorn
18) no, it is no item of food or drink
19) no,  its not a bag where he keeps ingredients
20) no,  its no clothing

21) no, its not one of the glasses of mead he serves to Harry and Ron
22) its, no memory

hint: we see "it" after christmas

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 15, 2014, 02:23:42 PM
Is it one of the bottles Slughorn uses to store the venom he managed to procure from Aragog?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 15, 2014, 04:04:22 PM
  Is it one of the bottles Slughorn uses to store the venom he managed to procure from Aragog? 


Yes, it is, ocngrats siena   :harryronbb:




while you are thinking...    is whatever in more than one book ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 15, 2014, 05:56:51 PM
 :yay:

I haven't won for a long time  ;)

I am thinking of ... a Place.

1. Yes, it is in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 15, 2014, 06:22:14 PM
:)


Is this place in the magic world ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 15, 2014, 06:57:52 PM
Does Harry ever go there?  :harry:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 15, 2014, 07:40:23 PM
I am thinking of ... a Place.

1. Yes, it is in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in the magical world.
3. No, Harry never goes there.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 15, 2014, 08:18:06 PM
is it seen ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 15, 2014, 09:19:48 PM
Does Voldemort/Tom Riddle at some point during his life, go there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 15, 2014, 10:17:36 PM
is this place in one of the first three books ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 16, 2014, 12:16:41 PM
I am thinking of ... a Place.

1. Yes, it is in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in the magical world.
3. No, Harry never goes there.
4. No, it is not seen.
5. No, Tom Riddle/Voldemort never goes there during his lifetime.
6. Yes, the place is in one of the first three books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on August 17, 2014, 08:48:50 AM
Is it Smeltings?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 17, 2014, 01:57:51 PM
I am thinking of ... a Place.

1. Yes, it is in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in the magical world.
3. No, Harry never goes there.
4. No, it is not seen.
5. No, Tom Riddle/Voldemort never goes there during his lifetime.
6. Yes, the place is in one of the first three books.
6. No, it is not Smeltings.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 17, 2014, 08:08:23 PM
Is it a school?  :hmm:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 17, 2014, 09:13:31 PM
Is it one of the places the flying car is seen from in CoS?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 18, 2014, 05:38:53 AM
is it mentioned out loud ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 18, 2014, 10:30:07 AM

I am thinking of ... a Place.

1. Yes, it is in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in the magical world.
3. No, Harry never goes there.
4. No, it is not seen.
5. No, Tom Riddle/Voldemort never goes there during his lifetime.
6. Yes, the place is in one of the first three books.
6. No, it is not Smeltings.
7. No, it is not a school.
8. No, it is not one of the places the flying car is seen from in CoS.
9. Yes, it is mentioned out loud.

P.S. Sorry - shouldn't have italicised Smeltings; it probably made you think it could be a different school, Evreka ..
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 18, 2014, 09:33:56 PM
Is it Majorca? (sp?)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 18, 2014, 10:01:46 PM
is it mentioned by a female ?


(don't think its Majorca Billie, its in more than one book)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 19, 2014, 12:32:39 PM

I am thinking of ... a Place.

1. Yes, it is in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in the magical world.
3. No, Harry never goes there.
4. No, it is not seen.
5. No, Tom Riddle/Voldemort never goes there during his lifetime.
6. Yes, the place is in one of the first three books.
6. No, it is not Smeltings.
7. No, it is not a school.
8. No, it is not one of the places the flying car is seen from in CoS.
9. Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
10. No, it is not Mallorca.
11. No, it is not mentioned by a female.

P.S. Sorry - shouldn't have italicised Smeltings; it probably made you think it could be a different school, Evreka ..
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on August 19, 2014, 02:08:48 PM
Is it mentioned by one of the Trio?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 19, 2014, 07:08:52 PM
does a wizard mentions it ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 19, 2014, 08:23:02 PM
Is it in the first book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 19, 2014, 08:27:09 PM
I am thinking of ... a Place.

1. Yes, it is in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in the magical world.
3. No, Harry never goes there.
4. No, it is not seen.
5. No, Tom Riddle/Voldemort never goes there during his lifetime.
6. Yes, the place is in one of the first three books.
6. No, it is not Smeltings.
7. No, it is not a school.
8. No, it is not one of the places the flying car is seen from in CoS.
9. Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
10. No, it is not Mallorca.
11. No, it is not mentioned by a female.
12. Yes, it is mentioned by one of the trio.
13. Yes, a wizard mentions it.
14. Yes, it is in the first book.

P.S. Sorry - shouldn't have italicised Smeltings; it probably made you think it could be a different school, Evreka ..
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 19, 2014, 09:08:12 PM
Is it Brazil?

It's "mentioned" by the snake in PS/SS and Harry in COS...  :hmm:

P.S. Sorry - shouldn't have italicised Smeltings; it probably made you think it could be a different school, Evreka ..
It did, but at the same time I couldn't think of a Muggle school that was mentioned in more than one book, so it was a long shot anyway. :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 19, 2014, 09:34:26 PM
nice guess, Evreka,  it could be Brazil, it's mentioned in GoF also at the QWC  :P


but while sinea hasn't confirmed one or the other way,....



is it an open place ?

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 20, 2014, 12:18:57 PM
Yes, it is Brazil.

It is mentioned in writing in PS on the sign near the cage in the zoo and also out loud by Harry when talking to the Boa Constrictor in the same book. In CoS, it is mentioned out loud both by Harry and Ron, when they talk about Harry's ability to speak to snakes. In GoF, it is mentioned out loud by Ron, who talks about Bill's former penfriend.

Well done, Evreka  8)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 20, 2014, 07:53:01 PM
What  a fun round!  :thumbup: Thanks, siena!


I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 21, 2014, 06:43:04 PM
What  a fun round!  :thumbup: Thanks, siena!



I am glad you enjoyed it  :)


Is it magical ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 21, 2014, 09:12:31 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 22, 2014, 05:35:01 PM
is it owned by someone specific ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 22, 2014, 10:55:07 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is owned by someone specific.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 22, 2014, 11:43:42 PM
Is the owner male?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on August 23, 2014, 12:20:41 AM
Is this thing used at anytime in the first 3 books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 23, 2014, 11:18:45 AM
Is it used?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 23, 2014, 11:47:29 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is owned by someone specific.
3) No, the owner is not male.
4) No, this thing is not used at any time during the first three books.
5) Yes, it is used.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on August 23, 2014, 03:20:01 PM
Do we see who owns this thing?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 23, 2014, 09:46:11 PM
Is this thing seen and not just mentioned?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 23, 2014, 10:20:30 PM
Is it used in books 4 or 5?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 23, 2014, 10:37:58 PM
is the owner a student ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 24, 2014, 08:55:52 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is owned by someone specific.
3) No, the owner is not male.
4) No, this thing is not used at any time during the first three books.
5) Yes, it is used.
6) Yes, we do see the person who owns this thing.
7) No, this thing is not seen.
8 ) No, it is not used in books 4 or 5.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 24, 2014, 09:36:27 PM
Is it used in book 6?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 25, 2014, 07:12:14 AM
is it bigger than a quaffle ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 25, 2014, 07:58:33 PM
Is it mentioned at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 25, 2014, 08:10:51 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is owned by someone specific.
3) No, the owner is not male.
4) No, this thing is not used at any time during the first three books.
5) Yes, it is used.
6) Yes, we do see the person who owns this thing.
7) No, this thing is not seen.
8 ) No, it is not used in books 4 or 5.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) No, it is not used in book 6.
11) Yes, it is bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is mentioned at Hogwarts.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on August 25, 2014, 08:17:05 PM
Is it mentioned by one of the Trio?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 25, 2014, 08:18:17 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is owned by someone specific.
3) No, the owner is not male.
4) No, this thing is not used at any time during the first three books.
5) Yes, it is used.
6) Yes, we do see the person who owns this thing.
7) No, this thing is not seen.
8 ) No, it is not used in books 4 or 5.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) No, it is not used in book 6.
11) Yes, it is bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is mentioned at Hogwarts.
13) No, it is not mentioned by any of the trio.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 25, 2014, 11:50:46 PM
is it mentioned out loud ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 26, 2014, 12:48:13 PM
Is the owner a Hogwarts teacher?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 26, 2014, 07:50:14 PM
is the owner on "the good side" ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 27, 2014, 08:16:51 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is owned by someone specific.
3) No, the owner is not male.
4) No, this thing is not used at any time during the first three books.
5) Yes, it is used.
6) Yes, we do see the person who owns this thing.
7) No, this thing is not seen.
8 ) No, it is not used in books 4 or 5.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) No, it is not used in book 6.
11) Yes, it is bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is mentioned at Hogwarts.
13) No, it is not mentioned by any of the trio.
14) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
15) Yes, the owner is a Hogwarts teacher.
16) Well, I may well be wrong, but I don't think it is explicitly stated which side the owner is on? However, we can make the assumption that they are on the good side.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 27, 2014, 08:20:45 PM
does Sybill owns it ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 27, 2014, 08:42:29 PM

I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is owned by someone specific.
3) No, the owner is not male.
4) No, this thing is not used at any time during the first three books.
5) Yes, it is used.
6) Yes, we do see the person who owns this thing.
7) No, this thing is not seen.
8 ) No, it is not used in books 4 or 5.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) No, it is not used in book 6.
11) Yes, it is bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is mentioned at Hogwarts.
13) No, it is not mentioned by any of the trio.
14) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
15) Yes, the owner is a Hogwarts teacher.
16) Well, I may well be wrong, but I don't think it is explicitly stated which side the owner is on? However, we can make the assumption that they are on the good side.
17) No, Sybill does not own it.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 28, 2014, 04:11:08 AM
does Mc Gonagall owns it ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 28, 2014, 07:11:49 PM

I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is owned by someone specific.
3) No, the owner is not male.
4) No, this thing is not used at any time during the first three books.
5) Yes, it is used.
6) Yes, we do see the person who owns this thing.
7) No, this thing is not seen.
8 ) No, it is not used in books 4 or 5.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) No, it is not used in book 6.
11) Yes, it is bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is mentioned at Hogwarts.
13) No, it is not mentioned by any of the trio.
14) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
15) Yes, the owner is a Hogwarts teacher.
16) Well, I may well be wrong, but I don't think it is explicitly stated which side the owner is on? However, we can make the assumption that they are on the good side.
17) No, Sybill does not own it.
18) No, McGonagall does not own it.  (See 16)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 28, 2014, 08:21:26 PM
does one of the trio mentions it ?




Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 28, 2014, 08:40:10 PM

I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is owned by someone specific.
3) No, the owner is not male.
4) No, this thing is not used at any time during the first three books.
5) Yes, it is used.
6) Yes, we do see the person who owns this thing.
7) No, this thing is not seen.
8 ) No, it is not used in books 4 or 5.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) No, it is not used in book 6.
11) Yes, it is bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is mentioned at Hogwarts.
13) No, it is not mentioned by any of the trio.
14) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
15) Yes, the owner is a Hogwarts teacher.
16) Well, I may well be wrong, but I don't think it is explicitly stated which side the owner is on? However, we can make the assumption that they are on the good side.
17) No, Sybill does not own it.
18) No, McGonagall does not own it.  (See 16)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 28, 2014, 11:51:06 PM
Is it owned by Pomona Sprout?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 29, 2014, 05:26:11 AM
ups    :ashamed:


is it mentioned before the trio enters into the shrieking shack ( speaking of DH) ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 29, 2014, 02:08:45 PM
Is it owned by Pomona Sprout?

I dare say Professor Sprout is on the good side - she immediately agrees with McGonagall to try and hold off Voldemort as long as possible in DH ..

Does it belong to Professor Vector or Professor Sinistra or Professor Grubbly-Plank?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on August 29, 2014, 05:13:46 PM
Is it a kind of broomstick?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 29, 2014, 06:41:26 PM
Is it owned by Pomona Sprout?
I dare say Professor Sprout is on the good side - she immediately agrees with McGonagall to try and hold off Voldemort as long as possible in DH ..

Does it belong to Professor Vector or Professor Sinistra or Professor Grubbly-Plank?
Yes, but we are running out of female teachers. I don't believe any of your list are mentioned in DH, nor is Madam Hooch.

Is it owned by Charity Burbage?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 29, 2014, 08:08:48 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is owned by someone specific.
3) No, the owner is not male.
4) No, this thing is not used at any time during the first three books.
5) Yes, it is used.
6) Yes, we do see the person who owns this thing.
7) No, this thing is not seen.
8 ) No, it is not used in books 4 or 5.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) No, it is not used in book 6.
11) Yes, it is bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is mentioned at Hogwarts.
13) No, it is not mentioned by any of the trio.
14) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
15) Yes, the owner is a Hogwarts teacher.
16) Well, I may well be wrong, but I don't think it is explicitly stated which side the owner is on? However, we can make the assumption that they are on the good side.
17) No, Sybill does not own it.
18) No, McGonagall does not own it.  (See 16)
19) No, it is not owned by Pomona Sprout
20) Yes, it is mentioned [a good deal] before the trio enters into the shrieking shack in DH.

Hint:
Oh dear, I seem to have a knack for choosing things that are used in uncommon ways....  ::) I think you are once again being deceived by what you think you know, as opposed to what you really know....

21) No, it does not belong to any of Professor Vector or Professor Sinistra or Professor Grubbly-Plank.
22) Yes, it is a kind of broomstick.
23) No, it is not owned by Charity Burbage.


I dare say Professor Sprout is on the good side - she immediately agrees with McGonagall to try and hold off Voldemort as long as possible in DH ..
So would I. :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 29, 2014, 11:31:59 PM
Is it used in the books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 30, 2014, 04:22:21 AM
is it mentioned out loud by another teacher ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 30, 2014, 01:14:25 PM
Is is Madame Hooch's Silver Arrow ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 30, 2014, 03:55:49 PM
Is is Madame Hooch's Silver Arrow ?
:yay: It is, yes!  Congratulations, siena!

:broomstick:                :broomstick:                :broomstick:

Some comments:
4) No, this thing is not used at any time during the first three books.
5) Yes, it is used.

In POA, Madam Hooch tells us that she once had a Silver Arrow on which she learnt to ride a broomstick. Hence it was definitely used, but at a time far pre-dating Harry's first year at Hogwarts. Consequently, it was not used (presumably) at any time during the first three books.

If you'd asked if it was IN one of the first three books, I'd said Yes.

16) Well, I may well be wrong, but I don't think it is explicitly stated which side the owner is on? However, we can make the assumption that they are on the good side.
I can't remember any place where her "side" is mentioned, but as she is a teacher and seems to be concerned about Harry's health, and acts as a shaperon in POA, I think we can assume she is on the good side?

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 30, 2014, 05:30:22 PM
20) Yes, it is mentioned [a good deal] before the trio enters into the shrieking shack in DH.



This is a cunning interpretation  :P - you had a choice to answer Yes, it is obviously mentioned (way before, years before really   ;)) the trio enters the Shrieking Shack in DH.

I suppose you could have answered No (it is not mentioned in DH at all of course  ;) )

But I do respect your choice, the way we answer/ask/interpret questions is what makes the game so fascinating  8)


I am thinking of ... a Spell.


Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 30, 2014, 05:43:13 PM
Do we see it cast?

20) Yes, it is mentioned [a good deal] before the trio enters into the shrieking shack in DH.
This is a cunning interpretation  :P - you had a choice to answer Yes, it is obviously mentioned (way before, years before really   ;)) the trio enters the Shrieking Shack in DH.

I suppose you could have answered No (it is not mentioned in DH at all of course  ;) )
:what: I don't understand your comment, I'm affraid.


Ah, wait.... I read the question : "is it mentioned before the trio enters into the shrieking shack ( speaking of DH) ?" As being really:

"is it mentioned before the trio enters into the shrieking shack ( Oh! And please note that I mean the Shrieking Schack scene in DH) ?" Not as: "is it, within DH, mentioned before the trio enters into the shrieking shack?"

And then, since we know it is mentioned, a NO would have meant it had to be mentioned in DH, in one of the last few chapters from the moment the trio entered the Shrieking Schack. That's the only time in the HP series that is NOT before the breakpoint indicated.

So it was a YES, and I made sure to include the bolded part to give a hint that you were, actually, not even in the right book. *shrug*

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 30, 2014, 05:53:40 PM
I'm sorry I think I just complicated things  ???

I guess - for some reason - we thought that the thing must be mentioned in DH, although, when reading through your answers, there is no indication whatsoever that this is the case.



Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 30, 2014, 07:10:49 PM
Do we see it cast?
I think you missed my question to your game.

And a new one: Do we know its incantation?


I'm sorry I think I just complicated things  ???

I guess - for some reason - we thought that the thing must be mentioned in DH, although, when reading through your answers, there is no indication whatsoever that this is the case.
Well, these things happen. No problem. :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 31, 2014, 05:18:31 AM
is it a defensive spell ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 31, 2014, 11:20:05 AM

I am thinking of a Spell.

1. Yes, we see it being cast.
2. Yes, we do know the incantation.
3. No, it is not a defensive spell.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Hermione P on August 31, 2014, 11:36:31 AM
Has it been used by any Order member?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on August 31, 2014, 04:30:31 PM

I am thinking of a Spell.

1. Yes, we see it being cast.
2. Yes, we do know the incantation.
3. No, it is not a defensive spell.
4. Yes, it has been used by an Order member
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 31, 2014, 09:54:40 PM
Is it in the first three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 31, 2014, 09:59:19 PM
Does it change your appearance in any way?  :7potters:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 01, 2014, 03:09:42 PM
I am thinking of a Spell.

1. Yes, we see it being cast.
2. Yes, we do know the incantation.
3. No, it is not a defensive spell.
4. Yes, it has been used by an Order member.
5. No, it is not in the first three books.
6. No, it does not change your appearance.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 01, 2014, 09:28:49 PM
Has it been used by any of the trio as well?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on September 01, 2014, 09:29:20 PM
Do we see it being cast in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on September 01, 2014, 10:22:19 PM
Is the spell taught to the students at Hogwarts by a teacher?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 01, 2014, 11:55:46 PM
Is it in the fourth or fifth book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 02, 2014, 01:13:53 PM
I am thinking of a Spell.

1. Yes, we see it being cast.
2. Yes, we do know the incantation.
3. No, it is not a defensive spell.
4. Yes, it has been used by an Order member.
5. No, it is not in the first three books.
6. No, it does not change your appearance.
7. Yes, it has been used by one or more of the trio as well.
8. Yes, we see it being cast in more than one book.
9. Yes, I do suppose that the spell is taught to the students at Hogwarts by a teacher, although there is no evidence for this.
10. Yes, it is in the fourth or fifth book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 02, 2014, 04:49:02 PM
is it in the forth book ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 02, 2014, 08:36:59 PM
Is it a Hex/Jinx/Curse?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 03, 2014, 06:22:45 AM
does Hermione cast it ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 03, 2014, 12:11:18 PM
I am thinking of a Spell.

1. Yes, we see it being cast.
2. Yes, we do know the incantation.
3. No, it is not a defensive spell.
4. Yes, it has been used by an Order member.
5. No, it is not in the first three books.
6. No, it does not change your appearance.
7. Yes, it has been used by one or more of the trio as well.
8. Yes, we see it being cast in more than one book.
9. Yes, I do suppose that the spell is taught to the students at Hogwarts by a teacher, although there is no evidence for this.
10. Yes, it is in the fourth or fifth book.
11. Yes, it is in the fourth book.
12. No, it is not a hex, jinx or curse.
13. No, Hermione doesn't cast it.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 03, 2014, 04:32:41 PM
does Harry cast it ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 03, 2014, 05:33:10 PM
Is it ever used against humans (as far as we know)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 03, 2014, 07:12:31 PM
I am thinking of a Spell.

1. Yes, we see it being cast.
2. Yes, we do know the incantation.
3. No, it is not a defensive spell.
4. Yes, it has been used by an Order member.
5. No, it is not in the first three books.
6. No, it does not change your appearance.
7. Yes, it has been used by one or more of the trio as well.
8. Yes, we see it being cast in more than one book.
9. Yes, I do suppose that the spell is taught to the students at Hogwarts by a teacher, although there is no evidence for this.
10. Yes, it is in the fourth or fifth book.
11. Yes, it is in the fourth book.
12. No, it is not a hex, jinx or curse.
13. No, Hermione doesn't cast it.
14. Yes, Harry does cast it.
15. No, it isn't used against humans as far as far as we know.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 03, 2014, 08:14:13 PM
Is it used during a Tri-Wizard Task?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 04, 2014, 06:40:57 AM
does Harry cast it more than once ? (speaking of GoF)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 04, 2014, 05:36:45 PM
I am thinking of a Spell.

1. Yes, we see it being cast.
2. Yes, we do know the incantation.
3. No, it is not a defensive spell.
4. Yes, it has been used by an Order member.
5. No, it is not in the first three books.
6. No, it does not change your appearance.
7. Yes, it has been used by one or more of the trio as well.
8. Yes, we see it being cast in more than one book.
9. Yes, I do suppose that the spell is taught to the students at Hogwarts by a teacher, although there is no evidence for this.
10. Yes, it is in the fourth or fifth book.
11. Yes, it is in the fourth book.
12. No, it is not a hex, jinx or curse.
13. No, Hermione doesn't cast it.
14. Yes, Harry does cast it.
15. No, it isn't used against humans as far as far as we know.
16. No, it is not used during a Triwizard task.
17. No, Harry does not cast it more than once in GoF.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 04, 2014, 05:48:33 PM
does Harry use it before christmas ? (speaking of GoF)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 04, 2014, 08:15:21 PM
Is it Diffindo which rips Cedric's bag?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 04, 2014, 08:52:32 PM
Is it Diffindo which rips Cedric's bag?
Hermione does use Diffindo in DH after the death eater attack in the cafe, and Ron might consider it being used against humans (accidentally) given that he got a deep cut from it.

Is it a defensive spell (as its main purpose)?
Is it a household (eg. cleaning) spell?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 04, 2014, 09:28:44 PM
Is it a defensive spell (as its main purpose)?
Pst, check out Q 3....

On Diffindo, ouch, I forgot about that....

Is the spell used to move objects?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 05, 2014, 12:18:52 PM
Yes, it is Diffindo.

I have to apologise - I overlooked  :ashamed: that Hermione does indeed use the spell in DH to remove Ron's bandages after the Death Eater attack in the cafe.

Harry does use the spell to tear Credric's bag in GoF (as Evreka said). He also used it in HBP to swap the covers of his two Potions books.  He also used it to try to free Mrs Cattermole from the magical chair in the Ministry courtroom in DH.  Furthermore I suppose that Ron used the spell in GoF to remove the lace on his dress robes, but we can't be sure.

I think we had a discussion before how most spells could be used defensively. But Diffindo definately isn't a defensive spell as such, it's a Severing Charm. I do assume that it was taught (probably by Flitwick) at some point, but again we can't be sure. As far as we know, it has never been used against humans.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 05, 2014, 08:31:40 PM
Woohoo! That was an unusually difficult spell to ferret out! Thanks for a fun round! :)

I have to apologise - I overlooked  :ashamed: that Hermione does indeed use the spell in DH to remove Ron's bandages after the Death Eater attack in the cafe.
Yeah, well, we all miss things every now and again.

OK, I'm thinking of a creature....
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on September 05, 2014, 08:38:47 PM
Is the creature male?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on September 05, 2014, 09:07:49 PM
Is the creature magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 05, 2014, 09:34:49 PM
Is it in the first four books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 05, 2014, 09:44:39 PM
OK, I'm thinking of a creature....

1) As far as I know, we do not know whether it is male.
2) Yes, the creature is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on September 05, 2014, 10:58:04 PM
Is it found in the Forbidden Forest?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on September 06, 2014, 12:10:39 AM
Does it have exactly four legs?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 06, 2014, 12:33:49 AM
Is it used in one of Hagrid's lessons?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 06, 2014, 01:38:45 AM
is it seen ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 06, 2014, 12:20:07 PM
OMG - I was just advised of another mistake I made (thank you, nellythemarrow    :) : Of course the spell Diffindo was not used by an Order member (as far as we know  ;))
So my answer 4. was inaccurate too  :-[

I mistakenly thought DA member ( I don't know why ...  :what:)

Sorry.


Is it a Flobberworm ?


Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 06, 2014, 12:44:26 PM
is it in the first two books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 06, 2014, 01:51:02 PM
OK, I'm thinking of a creature....

1) As far as I know, we do not know whether it is male.
2) Yes, the creature is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Well, yes, I guess... it is possible that it could be found in the Forbidden Forest. (This might be debatable.)
5) No, it does not have exactly four legs.
6) No, it is not used in one of Hagrid's lessons.
7) Yes, it is seen.
8 ) No, it is not a Flobberworm.
9) Well, I am tempted to say no, but ... I guess... it is possible that it might be in one or more of the first two books... (This might be debatable.) .... (Sorry!  :( )
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 06, 2014, 04:16:08 PM
Is it in the third book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 06, 2014, 04:44:10 PM
OK, I'm thinking of a creature....

1) As far as I know, we do not know whether it is male.
2) Yes, the creature is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Well, yes, I guess... it is possible that it could be found in the Forbidden Forest. (This might be debatable.)
5) No, it does not have exactly four legs.
6) No, it is not used in one of Hagrid's lessons.
7) Yes, it is seen.
8 ) No, it is not a Flobberworm.
9) Well, I am tempted to say no, but ... I guess... it is possible that it might be in one or more of the first two books... (This might be debatable.) .... (Sorry!  :( )
10) No, it is not in the third book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 06, 2014, 08:42:17 PM
does it have feathers ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 06, 2014, 08:43:29 PM
OK, I'm thinking of a creature....

1) As far as I know, we do not know whether it is male.
2) Yes, the creature is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Well, yes, I guess... it is possible that it could be found in the Forbidden Forest. (This might be debatable.)
5) No, it does not have exactly four legs.
6) No, it is not used in one of Hagrid's lessons.
7) Yes, it is seen.
8 ) No, it is not a Flobberworm.
9) Well, I am tempted to say no, but ... I guess... it is possible that it might be in one or more of the first two books... (This might be debatable.) .... (Sorry!  :( )
10) No, it is not in the third book.
11) No, it does not have feathers.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on September 06, 2014, 10:05:22 PM
Is it seen in the environs of Hogsmeade?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 06, 2014, 10:44:05 PM
Does it have exactly two legs?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 07, 2014, 10:34:34 AM
OK, I'm thinking of a creature....

1) As far as I know, we do not know whether it is male.
2) Yes, the creature is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Well, yes, I guess... it is possible that it could be found in the Forbidden Forest. (This might be debatable.)
5) No, it does not have exactly four legs.
6) No, it is not used in one of Hagrid's lessons.
7) Yes, it is seen.
8 ) No, it is not a Flobberworm.
9) Well, I am tempted to say no, but ... I guess... it is possible that it might be in one or more of the first two books... (This might be debatable.) .... (Sorry!  :( )
10) No, it is not in the third book.
11) No, it does not have feathers.
12) No, it is not seen in the environments of Hogsmeade.
13) No, it does not have exactly two legs.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 07, 2014, 01:59:14 PM
Is it seen in PS?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 07, 2014, 03:14:59 PM
OK, I'm thinking of a creature....

1) As far as I know, we do not know whether it is male.
2) Yes, the creature is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Well, yes, I guess... it is possible that it could be found in the Forbidden Forest. (This might be debatable.)
5) No, it does not have exactly four legs.
6) No, it is not used in one of Hagrid's lessons.
7) Yes, it is seen.
8 ) No, it is not a Flobberworm.
9) Well, I am tempted to say no, but ... I guess... it is possible that it might be in one or more of the first two books... (This might be debatable.) .... (Sorry!  :( )
10) No, it is not in the third book.
11) No, it does not have feathers.
12) No, it is not seen in the environments of Hogsmeade.
13) No, it does not have exactly two legs.
14) No, it is not seen in PS/SS.

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 07, 2014, 03:19:22 PM
Quickly edited your post there, didn't you, eh  ;)

Is it seen in GoF?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 07, 2014, 03:29:18 PM
OK, I'm thinking of a creature....

1) As far as I know, we do not know whether it is male.
2) Yes, the creature is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Well, yes, I guess... it is possible that it could be found in the Forbidden Forest. (This might be debatable.)
5) No, it does not have exactly four legs.
6) No, it is not used in one of Hagrid's lessons.
7) Yes, it is seen.
8 ) No, it is not a Flobberworm.
9) Well, I am tempted to say no, but ... I guess... it is possible that it might be in one or more of the first two books... (This might be debatable.) .... (Sorry!  :( )
10) No, it is not in the third book.
11) No, it does not have feathers.
12) No, it is not seen in the environments of Hogsmeade.
13) No, it does not have exactly two legs.
14) No, it is not seen in PS/SS.
15) Yes, it is seen in GOF.

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 07, 2014, 04:12:01 PM
Does it have legs?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 07, 2014, 05:21:12 PM
OK, I'm thinking of a creature....

1) As far as I know, we do not know whether it is male.
2) Yes, the creature is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Well, yes, I guess... it is possible that it could be found in the Forbidden Forest. (This might be debatable.)
5) No, it does not have exactly four legs.
6) No, it is not used in one of Hagrid's lessons.
7) Yes, it is seen.
8 ) No, it is not a Flobberworm.
9) Well, I am tempted to say no, but ... I guess... it is possible that it might be in one or more of the first two books... (This might be debatable.) .... (Sorry!  :( )
10) No, it is not in the third book.
11) No, it does not have feathers.
12) No, it is not seen in the environments of Hogsmeade.
13) No, it does not have exactly two legs.
14) No, it is not seen in PS/SS.
15) Yes, it is seen in GOF.
16) Yes, it does have legs.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 07, 2014, 08:22:00 PM
Is it the gigantic spider in the maze in the third task of the triwizard tournament?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 07, 2014, 08:51:14 PM
Is it the gigantic spider in the maze in the third task of the triwizard tournament?
:owlso: Congratulations, we've got a winner!   :stars:

:aragog:                   :aragog:                   :aragog:                   :aragog:                   :aragog:

Some comments
4) Well, yes, I guess... it is possible that it could be found in the Forbidden Forest. (This might be debatable.)
We're never told where this creature comes from. It may be one of the Acromantulas from the Forbidden Forest but we do not know this for sure, as far as I remember anyway?

9) Well, I am tempted to say no, but ... I guess... it is possible that it might be in one or more of the first two books... (This might be debatable.) .... (Sorry!  :( )
If we agree that it really is an Acromantula, we could have seen this exact individual in the Forbidden Forest in COS, but there is no way to say so for sure.

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 08, 2014, 09:28:23 PM
I am thinking of a person ...
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 09, 2014, 06:34:51 PM
are the magic ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 09, 2014, 07:49:51 PM
Do we know their name?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 09, 2014, 08:02:58 PM
I am thinking of a person ...

1. No, the person is not magical.
2. Yes, we know their name.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 09, 2014, 08:05:30 PM
Is it someone male?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on September 09, 2014, 08:27:25 PM
Are they seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 10, 2014, 12:38:17 AM
I am thinking of a person ...

1. No, the person is not magical.
2. Yes, we know their name.
3. Yes, he is someone male.
4. No, he is not seen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 10, 2014, 07:00:38 AM
is he mentioned out loud ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 10, 2014, 11:57:57 AM
Is he in one or more of the first three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 10, 2014, 07:08:16 PM
Does he live anywhere in Little Whinging?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 10, 2014, 10:45:39 PM
I am thinking of a person ...

1. No, the person is not magical.
2. Yes, we know their name.
3. Yes, he is someone male.
4. No, he is not seen.
5. Yes, he is mentioned out loud.
6. Yes, he is in one or more of the first three books.
7. No, he does not live anywhere in Little Whinging.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 10, 2014, 11:24:51 PM
is he in Cos ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 11, 2014, 08:25:00 PM
Is it Tom Riddle Sr?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 11, 2014, 10:38:25 PM
I am thinking of a person ...

1. No, the person is not magical.
2. Yes, we know their name.
3. Yes, he is someone male.
4. No, he is not seen.
5. Yes, he is mentioned out loud.
6. Yes, he is in one or more of the first three books.
7. No, he does not live anywhere in Little Whinging.
8. Yes, he is in CoS.
9. No, it is not Tom Riddle Sr.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 11, 2014, 11:46:29 PM
is he mentioned at Hogwarts ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on September 12, 2014, 07:48:29 AM
Is he mentioned in any of the last 3 books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 12, 2014, 01:58:05 PM
Is it Angus Fleet?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 12, 2014, 08:23:39 PM
Is it Angus Fleet?
Yes, it is.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 12, 2014, 08:54:07 PM
Is it Angus Fleet?
Yes, it is.
Calling myself a HP fan and all that ...  :ashamed: ... Who is he?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 12, 2014, 08:57:39 PM
Is it Angus Fleet?
Yes, it is.
Calling myself a HP fan and all that ...  :ashamed: ... Who is he?
Mr Angus Fleet, of Peebles was one of the muggles who saw the flying Ford Anglia, as read out from the Evening Prophet by Snape.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 12, 2014, 08:58:45 PM
Is it Angus Fleet?
Yes, it is.
Calling myself a HP fan and all that ...  :ashamed: ... Who is he?
Mr Angus Fleet, of Peebles was one of the muggles who saw the flying Ford Anglia, as read out from the Evening Prophet by Snape.
Oh! I see, thanks for explaining!  :thumbup: I'd forgotten their names.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 14, 2014, 06:45:48 AM
great guess siena  :)



while you are thinking .... is whatever/whomever in more than one book ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 14, 2014, 01:48:38 PM
great guess siena  :)

Thank you  :)

I am thinking of ... a Spell.

and since I messed up last time so badly  :( I'll give you hint now: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 14, 2014, 03:33:07 PM
Is it in one of the first three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 14, 2014, 09:40:20 PM
Is it cast by someone studying or teaching at Hogwarts while Harry is there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 15, 2014, 04:24:07 AM
is it a defensive spell ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: siena on September 15, 2014, 01:25:11 PM
I am thinking of ... a Spell.

... and since I messed up last time so badly  I'll give you hint now: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on September 15, 2014, 01:58:09 PM
Is it cast in DH?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 16, 2014, 07:06:35 AM
do we see it beeing cast ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 16, 2014, 08:15:50 AM
siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on September 17, 2014, 07:32:11 PM
Is it cast by a DE?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 18, 2014, 09:20:36 AM
siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 18, 2014, 06:00:49 PM
is it cast by a family member of a student ?  (speaking of Harry's years at Hogwarts)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 18, 2014, 08:57:03 PM
siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
8. No, it is not cast a family member of a student (or we have no indication that it is)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 18, 2014, 10:14:46 PM
is it cast in our arround London ?  ( open space or inside a space)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 19, 2014, 12:04:23 AM
Is it in books 4 or 5?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 19, 2014, 05:45:55 AM
 siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
8. No, it is not cast a family member of a student (or we have no indication that it is)
9. Where it is cast is not mentioned
10. Yes, it is in book 4 or 5.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 19, 2014, 06:44:23 PM
Is it in book 4?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on September 19, 2014, 09:43:34 PM
Is it mentioned at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 19, 2014, 10:38:38 PM
 siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
8. No, it is not cast a family member of a student (or we have no indication that it is)
9. Where it is cast is not mentioned
10. Yes, it is in book 4 or 5.
11. No, it is not in book 4.
12. No, it is not mentioned at Hogwarts.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 20, 2014, 11:31:02 AM
Is it mentioned before Harry catches the Hogwarts Express in OotP?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on September 20, 2014, 10:31:53 PM
Is it mentioned in the Muggle world?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 21, 2014, 06:29:29 AM
 siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
8. No, it is not cast a family member of a student (or we have no indication that it is)
9. Where it is cast is not mentioned
10. Yes, it is in book 4 or 5.
11. No, it is not in book 4.
12. No, it is not mentioned at Hogwarts.
13. No, it is not mentioned before Harry catches the Hogwarts Express.
14. No, it is not mentioned in the Muggle world.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 21, 2014, 05:06:07 PM
Is it mentioned before Harry reaches Hogwarts on the Knight Bus (after Christmas in OotP)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 21, 2014, 07:14:46 PM
does a female cast it ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 21, 2014, 09:23:27 PM
 siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
8. No, it is not cast a family member of a student (or we have no indication that it is)
9. Where it is cast is not mentioned
10. Yes, it is in book 4 or 5.
11. No, it is not in book 4.
12. No, it is not mentioned at Hogwarts.
13. No, it is not mentioned before Harry catches the Hogwarts Express.
14. No, it is not mentioned in the Muggle world.
15. Yes, it is mentioned before Harry reaches Hogwarts on the Knight Bus.
16. There is no mention of who cast it.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 21, 2014, 10:02:03 PM
Is it mentioned during or before the visit to Hogsmeade during which the DA was planned?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 21, 2014, 10:15:51 PM
 siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
8. No, it is not cast a family member of a student (or we have no indication that it is)
9. Where it is cast is not mentioned
10. Yes, it is in book 4 or 5.
11. No, it is not in book 4.
12. No, it is not mentioned at Hogwarts.
13. No, it is not mentioned before Harry catches the Hogwarts Express.
14. No, it is not mentioned in the Muggle world.
15. Yes, it is mentioned before Harry reaches Hogwarts on the Knight Bus.
16. There is no mention of who cast it.
17. No, it is not mentioned before or during the visit to Hogsmeade during which DA was planned.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on September 21, 2014, 11:10:01 PM
Is it mentioned during Christmas time at 12 Grimauld Place?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 22, 2014, 12:03:57 AM
Do we see the consequences of the spell at St.Mungo's?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 22, 2014, 03:55:21 AM
 siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
8. No, it is not cast a family member of a student (or we have no indication that it is)
9. Where it is cast is not mentioned
10. Yes, it is in book 4 or 5.
11. No, it is not in book 4.
12. No, it is not mentioned at Hogwarts.
13. No, it is not mentioned before Harry catches the Hogwarts Express.
14. No, it is not mentioned in the Muggle world.
15. Yes, it is mentioned before Harry reaches Hogwarts on the Knight Bus.
16. There is no mention of who cast it.
17. No, it is not mentioned before or during the visit to Hogsmeade during which DA was planned.
18. No, it is not mentioned during Christmas time at Grimmauld Place
19. Yes, we do see the consequences of the spell at St Mungo's.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 23, 2014, 07:30:40 AM
does Arthur Weasly mentions it ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 23, 2014, 08:45:05 AM
 siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
8. No, it is not cast a family member of a student (or we have no indication that it is)
9. Where it is cast is not mentioned
10. Yes, it is in book 4 or 5.
11. No, it is not in book 4.
12. No, it is not mentioned at Hogwarts.
13. No, it is not mentioned before Harry catches the Hogwarts Express.
14. No, it is not mentioned in the Muggle world.
15. Yes, it is mentioned before Harry reaches Hogwarts on the Knight Bus.
16. There is no mention of who cast it.
17. No, it is not mentioned before or during the visit to Hogsmeade during which DA was planned.
18. No, it is not mentioned during Christmas time at Grimmauld Place
19. Yes, we do see the consequences of the spell at St Mungo's.
20. No, Arthur Weasley does not mention it.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 23, 2014, 08:59:18 PM
do we see the consecuencies of the spell downstairs in the welcome lounge ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 23, 2014, 10:46:54 PM
 siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
8. No, it is not cast a family member of a student (or we have no indication that it is)
9. Where it is cast is not mentioned
10. Yes, it is in book 4 or 5.
11. No, it is not in book 4.
12. No, it is not mentioned at Hogwarts.
13. No, it is not mentioned before Harry catches the Hogwarts Express.
14. No, it is not mentioned in the Muggle world.
15. Yes, it is mentioned before Harry reaches Hogwarts on the Knight Bus.
16. There is no mention of who cast it.
17. No, it is not mentioned before or during the visit to Hogsmeade during which DA was planned.
18. No, it is not mentioned during Christmas time at Grimmauld Place
19. Yes, we do see the consequences of the spell at St Mungo's.
20. No, Arthur Weasley does not mention it.
21. Yes, we do see the consequences of it downstairs in the welcome lounge.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 23, 2014, 11:12:55 PM
Do we see the consequences on the visit a few hours after Arthur is attacked?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 23, 2014, 11:23:55 PM
is it the spell who got the satsuma jammed up the left nostril of the witch who shunted Harry aside ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 23, 2014, 11:54:57 PM
 siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
8. No, it is not cast a family member of a student (or we have no indication that it is)
9. Where it is cast is not mentioned
10. Yes, it is in book 4 or 5.
11. No, it is not in book 4.
12. No, it is not mentioned at Hogwarts.
13. No, it is not mentioned before Harry catches the Hogwarts Express.
14. No, it is not mentioned in the Muggle world.
15. Yes, it is mentioned before Harry reaches Hogwarts on the Knight Bus.
16. There is no mention of who cast it.
17. No, it is not mentioned before or during the visit to Hogsmeade during which DA was planned.
18. No, it is not mentioned during Christmas time at Grimmauld Place
19. Yes, we do see the consequences of the spell at St Mungo's.
20. No, Arthur Weasley does not mention it.
21. Yes, we do see the consequences of it downstairs in the welcome lounge.
22. Yes, we do see the consequences on the first visit
23. No, it is not the spell that saw satsuma jammed up the nostril.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on September 24, 2014, 03:29:02 AM
Is it the "Stitches" on the dressing over Arthur's wound from Nagini's bite?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 24, 2014, 05:56:57 AM
 siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
8. No, it is not cast a family member of a student (or we have no indication that it is)
9. Where it is cast is not mentioned
10. Yes, it is in book 4 or 5.
11. No, it is not in book 4.
12. No, it is not mentioned at Hogwarts.
13. No, it is not mentioned before Harry catches the Hogwarts Express.
14. No, it is not mentioned in the Muggle world.
15. Yes, it is mentioned before Harry reaches Hogwarts on the Knight Bus.
16. There is no mention of who cast it.
17. No, it is not mentioned before or during the visit to Hogsmeade during which DA was planned.
18. No, it is not mentioned during Christmas time at Grimmauld Place
19. Yes, we do see the consequences of the spell at St Mungo's.
20. No, Arthur Weasley does not mention it.
21. Yes, we do see the consequences of it downstairs in the welcome lounge.
22. Yes, we do see the consequences on the first visit
23. No, it is not the spell that saw satsuma jammed up the nostril.
24. No, it is not the "stitches" on the dressing
I would give a clue but you are so close!!
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 24, 2014, 07:12:54 PM
Is it any of the elephant trunks, extra hands in the chest, or the witch making a high-pitched whistle as steam comes out of her mouth?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on September 24, 2014, 07:15:09 PM
Or is it the spell that caused the little girl, (the one who's about two years old), to float like a helium balloon?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 24, 2014, 10:31:59 PM
 siena has asked the Moderators to take over this round so here we go.....

She is thinking of ... a Spell.

... hint: We do not know the incantation.

1. No, it is not in more than one book.
2. No, it is not in any of the first three books.
3. No, it is not cast by anyone studying or teaching  at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
4. No, it is not a defensive spell.
5. No, it is not cast in DH.
6. No, we do not see it cast.
7. No, it was not cast by a Death Eater
8. No, it is not cast a family member of a student (or we have no indication that it is)
9. Where it is cast is not mentioned
10. Yes, it is in book 4 or 5.
11. No, it is not in book 4.
12. No, it is not mentioned at Hogwarts.
13. No, it is not mentioned before Harry catches the Hogwarts Express.
14. No, it is not mentioned in the Muggle world.
15. Yes, it is mentioned before Harry reaches Hogwarts on the Knight Bus.
16. There is no mention of who cast it.
17. No, it is not mentioned before or during the visit to Hogsmeade during which DA was planned.
18. No, it is not mentioned during Christmas time at Grimmauld Place
19. Yes, we do see the consequences of the spell at St Mungo's.
20. No, Arthur Weasley does not mention it.
21. Yes, we do see the consequences of it downstairs in the welcome lounge.
22. Yes, we do see the consequences on the first visit
23. No, it is not the spell that saw satsuma jammed up the nostril.
24. No, it is not the "stitches" on the dressing
I would give a clue but you are so close!!
25. No, it is not the elephant trunks, the extra hands or the steam whistling witch.

BillieMac, you are correct.  :thumbup: well done, it was the little girl floating.

Over to you...

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on September 24, 2014, 10:55:41 PM
 :yay:

Thank you, RiverSpirit. I'm thinking of a spell, too.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 24, 2014, 11:43:40 PM
Is it in the first three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 25, 2014, 06:42:33 AM
do we see it beeing cast ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on September 25, 2014, 08:48:04 AM
Is it cast by a student?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 25, 2014, 06:32:56 PM
Congrats, BillieMac!  :thumbup:

Do we know the incantation?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 26, 2014, 07:40:57 AM
is it in more than one book ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on September 26, 2014, 10:43:41 PM
I'm thinking of a spell

-1- It is not in the first three books (iIrc)
-2- We do not see it being cast
-3- It is cast by a student
-3- We do not know the incantation
-4- It is in more than one book
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on September 27, 2014, 01:59:43 AM
Is it in any of the last 3 books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 27, 2014, 12:46:22 PM
-1- It is not in the first three books (iIrc)
:what: What does iIrc mean?  :crabbegoyle:

Does it change your appearance in any way?  :7potters:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 27, 2014, 08:58:41 PM
is it the same person who casts ist in the different books ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on September 29, 2014, 11:31:15 PM
I'm thinking of a spell

-1- It is not in the first three books (iIrc)
-2- We do not see it being cast
-3- It is cast by a student
-4- We do not know the incantation
-5- It is in more than one book
-6- It is in one of the last three books
-7- It does not change your appearance in any way.
-8- It is presumed to be the same person who casts it.

Evreka, iIrc means "if I recall correctly". One of those English language abbreviations.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 30, 2014, 05:48:06 AM
is the person who casts it in Gryffindor house  ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 30, 2014, 07:42:13 PM
Is it a Hex/Jinx/Curse? 
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 30, 2014, 08:07:23 PM
Is it in OotP?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on October 01, 2014, 01:35:53 AM
Is the student who cast it female?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 01, 2014, 07:38:56 PM
Corrections and clarifications:
There are actually two examples of this spell, one slightly modified, which requires a change to Answers 3 & 8.

I'm thinking of a spell

-1- It is not in the first three books. (iIrc)
-2- We do not see it being cast.
-3- It is cast by a student in one example.
-4- We do not know the incantation.
-5- It is in more than one book.
-6- It is in one of the last three books.
-7- It does not change your appearance in any way.
-8- It is not the same person who casts it in the different books.
-9- One person who casts it is in Gryffindor House; the other's House is not mentioned.
10- It is not a Hex/Jinx/Curse.
11- It is not in OotP.
12- The student who casts it is female.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 01, 2014, 07:41:34 PM
Does Hermione cast it?  :hermioneread:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 01, 2014, 10:57:25 PM
I'm thinking of a spell:
(There are two examples of this spell, one slightly modified.)

-1- It is not in the first three books. (iIrc)
-2- We do not see it being cast.
-3- It is cast by a student in one example.
-4- We do not know the incantation.
-5- It is in more than one book.
-6- It is in one of the last three books.
-7- It does not change your appearance in any way.
-8- It is not the same person who casts it in the different books.
-9- One person who casts it is in Gryffindor House; the other's House is not mentioned.
10- It is not a Hex/Jinx/Curse.
11- It is not in OotP.
12- The student who casts it is female.
13- Hermione casts it.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 02, 2014, 09:00:19 PM
Is it ever cast at a person ? (Ie the target being a person)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 02, 2014, 10:16:24 PM
does Hermione cast it in DH ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 03, 2014, 12:33:42 AM
I'm thinking of a spell:
(There are two examples of this spell, one slightly modified.)

-1- It is not in the first three books. (iIrc)
-2- We do not see it being cast.
-3- It is cast by a student in one example.
-4- We do not know the incantation.
-5- It is in more than one book.
-6- It is in one of the last three books.
-7- It does not change your appearance in any way.
-8- It is not the same person who casts it in the different books.
-9- One person who casts it is in Gryffindor House; the other's House is not mentioned.
10- It is not a Hex/Jinx/Curse.
11- It is not in OotP.
12- The student who casts it is female.
13- Hermione casts it.
14- It is not ever cast at a person.
15- Hermione casts it in DH. (But remember Answer 2.)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 03, 2014, 03:14:49 AM
is it one of the spells Hermione uses in DH to protect their camping sites during their trips after they escaped from the MoM ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 03, 2014, 03:39:59 AM
I'm thinking of a spell:
(There are two examples of this spell, one slightly modified.)

-1- It is not in the first three books. (iIrc)
-2- We do not see it being cast.
-3- It is cast by a student in one example.
-4- We do not know the incantation.
-5- It is in more than one book.
-6- It is in one of the last three books.
-7- It does not change your appearance in any way.
-8- It is not the same person who casts it in the different books.
-9- One person who casts it is in Gryffindor House; the other's House is not mentioned.
10- It is not a Hex/Jinx/Curse.
11- It is not in OotP.
12- The student who casts it is female.
13- Hermione casts it.
14- It is not ever cast at a person.
15- Hermione casts it in DH. (But remember Answer 2.)
16- It is not one of the spells Hermione uses in DH to protect their camping sites. (But you're on the right track)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 03, 2014, 03:55:49 AM
does Hermione use the spell during the time of their camping trip ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 03, 2014, 07:08:31 PM
Was it used while Harry was unconscious after Nagini's attack on Christmas Eve before he wakes up in the Forest?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 04, 2014, 04:16:06 AM
I'm thinking of a spell:
(There are two examples of this spell, one slightly modified.)

-1- It is not in the first three books. (iIrc)
-2- We do not see it being cast.
-3- It is cast by a student in one example.
-4- We do not know the incantation.
-5- It is in more than one book.
-6- It is in one of the last three books.
-7- It does not change your appearance in any way.
-8- It is not the same person who casts it in the different books.
-9- One person who casts it is in Gryffindor House; the other's House is not mentioned.
10- It is not a Hex/Jinx/Curse.
11- It is not in OotP.
12- The student who casts it is female.
13- Hermione casts it.
14- It is not ever cast at a person.
15- Hermione casts it in DH. (But remember Answer 2.)
16- It is not one of the spells Hermione uses in DH to protect their camping sites. (But you're on the right track)
17- Hermione does not use this spell during the time of their camping trip. (The first hint will relate to this.)
18- It was not used while Harry was unconscious after Nagini's attack. (The first hint will relate to this.)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 04, 2014, 08:23:41 AM
does Hermione use the spell in DH at Hogwarts ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 04, 2014, 08:05:30 PM
I'm thinking of a spell:
(There are two examples of this spell, one slightly modified.)

-1- It is not in the first three books. (iIrc)
-2- We do not see it being cast.
-3- It is cast by a student in one example.
-4- We do not know the incantation.
-5- It is in more than one book.
-6- It is in one of the last three books.
-7- It does not change your appearance in any way.
-8- It is not the same person who casts it in the different books.
-9- One person who casts it is in Gryffindor House; the other's House is not mentioned.
10- It is not a Hex/Jinx/Curse.
11- It is not in OotP.
12- The student who casts it is female.
13- Hermione casts it.
14- It is not ever cast at a person.
15- Hermione casts it in DH. (But remember Answer 2.)
16- It is not one of the spells Hermione uses in DH to protect their camping sites. (But you're on the right track)
17- Hermione does not use this spell during the time of their camping trip. (The first hint will relate to this.)
18- It was not used while Harry was unconscious after Nagini's attack. (The first hint will relate to this.)
19- Hermione does not use this spell at Hogwarts
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 04, 2014, 08:49:24 PM
Does Hermione use it anywhere in London?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 05, 2014, 03:05:25 AM
I'm thinking of a spell:
(There are two examples of this spell, one slightly modified.)

-1- It is not in the first three books. (iIrc)
-2- We do not see it being cast.
-3- It is cast by a student in one example.
-4- We do not know the incantation.
-5- It is in more than one book.
-6- It is in one of the last three books.
-7- It does not change your appearance in any way.
-8- It is not the same person who casts it in the different books.
-9- One person who casts it is in Gryffindor House; the other's House is not mentioned.
10- It is not a Hex/Jinx/Curse.
11- It is not in OotP.
12- The student who casts it is female.
13- Hermione casts it.
14- It is not ever cast at a person.
15- Hermione casts it in DH. (But remember Answer 2.)
16- It is not one of the spells Hermione uses in DH to protect their camping sites. (But you're on the right track)
17- Hermione does not use this spell during the time of their camping trip. (The first hint will relate to this.)
18- It was not used while Harry was unconscious after Nagini's attack. (The first hint will relate to this.)
19- Hermione does not use this spell at Hogwarts.
20- Canon does not state where Hermione uses this spell; it's just clearly not at Hogwarts.
Hint- Hermione uses the spell in DH in preparation for the camping trip, and the other person to cast it did so for recreational purposes. Both results of the spell are seen in DH.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 05, 2014, 02:12:38 PM
Ah! Is it the Spell that makes something's inside much larger than it's outside?

 :-\ Although I think that's been used at least thrice...
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 05, 2014, 04:56:07 PM
Yes, Evreka, it is the Extendability Charm, the "slightly modified" version being the Invisible Extendability Charm.

You may be thinking of the three times the results of it were used- in GoF and DH, but I figure the charm was only put on the tent once. And for all we know, the charm could have been used everywhere in the WW Harry's been. The Leaky Cauldron, for example, could have started out the size of a kiosk.

Is who, what or wherever magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 05, 2014, 05:21:59 PM
Yes, Evreka, it is the Extendability Charm, the "slightly modified" version being the Invisible Extendability Charm.

You may be thinking of the three times the results of it were used- in GoF and DH, but I figure the charm was only put on the tent once. And for all we know, the charm could have been used everywhere in the WW Harry's been.
I am fairly sure Arthur used an undetectable Extendability Charm on the inside of the Ford Anglia in COS, which made it possible to get everyone and everything loaded into it.

Quote from: COS, Chapter 5
Harry couldn't see how eight people, six large trunks, two owls, and a rat were going to fit into one small Ford Anglia. He had reckoned, of course, without the special features that Mr. Weasley had added.
"Not a word to Molly," he whispered to Harry as he opened the trunk and showed him how it had been magically expanded so that the luggage fitted easily.
When at last they were all in the car, Mrs. Weasley ... said, "Muggles do know more than we give them credit for, don't they?" ... "I mean, you'd never know it was this roomy from the outside, would you?"
If this was not an undetectable extension Charm, how come Molly didn't notice it?  :-\

Then the tent in GOF and Hermione's bag. Makes (at least) three mentioned times, I think....

Anyway...

I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical. :)

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 05, 2014, 08:54:11 PM
You're absolutely right; I'd completely forgotten about the invisible extendability charm on the car!  :headbang:

Anyway, is it seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 05, 2014, 09:56:16 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical. :)
2) Yes, it is seen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 06, 2014, 12:32:59 AM
Is it owned? (Whether by an an individual, group or institution.)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 06, 2014, 04:26:41 AM
is it bigger than a Quaffle ?




I am sure this extension charm was also used on the car of the MoM, Harry, Hermione and the Weasleys were using in PoA
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 06, 2014, 05:29:35 AM
Do we see it being used?

Okay, here's the official statement:
I got Answer 1 wrong on my turn.  :-[  The spell was indeed used in the first three books; CoS and PoA  to be precise.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 06, 2014, 04:50:10 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is seen.
3) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an an individual, group or institution.)
4) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
5) Yes, we do see it being used. :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 06, 2014, 07:26:46 PM
is it seen in more than one books  ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 07, 2014, 06:47:50 AM
Is it owned by an individual?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 07, 2014, 08:04:07 PM
is it used ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 08, 2014, 08:18:22 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is seen.
3) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an an individual, group or institution.)
4) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
5) Yes, we do see it being used. :)
6) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
7) Yes, it is owned by an individual.

is it used ?
Check out 5... or did you mean it in some other way?  :mcgonagall2:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 09, 2014, 02:21:21 AM
No, she just missed the answer. We've all done that more than once.

Is the owner male?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 09, 2014, 07:52:39 AM
is the owner a student ?




thx Billie,  you are right    :ashamed:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 10, 2014, 08:47:39 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is seen.
3) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an an individual, group or institution.)
4) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
5) Yes, we do see it being used. :)
6) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
7) Yes, it is owned by an individual.
8 ) Yes, the owner is male.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 10, 2014, 10:07:44 PM
Do we see it at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 10, 2014, 10:23:10 PM
is the owner an Ordermember ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 11, 2014, 06:38:22 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is seen.
3) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an an individual, group or institution.)
4) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
5) Yes, we do see it being used. :)
6) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
7) Yes, it is owned by an individual.
8 ) Yes, the owner is male.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) Yes, we do see it at Hogwarts.
11) Yes, it is owned by an Ordermember.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 11, 2014, 08:50:56 AM
Is it in one or more of the last three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 12, 2014, 09:38:55 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is seen.
3) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an an individual, group or institution.)
4) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
5) Yes, we do see it being used. :)
6) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
7) Yes, it is owned by an individual.
8 ) Yes, the owner is male.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) Yes, we do see it at Hogwarts.
11) Yes, it is owned by an Ordermember.
12) Yes, it is in one or more of the last three books.

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on October 12, 2014, 01:17:12 PM
Is it seen in Order of the Phoenix?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 12, 2014, 03:00:12 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is seen.
3) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an an individual, group or institution.)
4) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
5) Yes, we do see it being used. :)
6) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
7) Yes, it is owned by an individual.
8 ) Yes, the owner is male.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) Yes, we do see it at Hogwarts.
11) Yes, it is owned by an Ordermember.
12) Yes, it is in one or more of the last three books.
13) Yes, it is seen in OOP.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 12, 2014, 07:27:30 PM
is it also seen in GoF?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 12, 2014, 09:10:14 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is seen.
3) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an an individual, group or institution.)
4) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
5) Yes, we do see it being used. :)
6) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
7) Yes, it is owned by an individual.
8 ) Yes, the owner is male.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) Yes, we do see it at Hogwarts.
11) Yes, it is owned by an Ordermember.
12) Yes, it is in one or more of the last three books.
13) Yes, it is seen in OOP.
14) Yes, it is also seen in GOF.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on October 13, 2014, 02:56:21 AM
Does Professor Dumbledore own it?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 13, 2014, 05:03:00 AM
do we see it at GP 12 ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 13, 2014, 09:47:39 AM
Is it owned by Mad Eye Moody and used by both him and Barty Crouch Jr.?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 13, 2014, 08:06:51 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) Yes, it is seen.
3) Yes, it is owned. (Whether by an an individual, group or institution.)
4) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
5) Yes, we do see it being used. :)
6) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
7) Yes, it is owned by an individual.
8 ) Yes, the owner is male.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) Yes, we do see it at Hogwarts.
11) Yes, it is owned by an Ordermember.
12) Yes, it is in one or more of the last three books.
13) Yes, it is seen in OOP.
14) Yes, it is also seen in GOF.
15) No, Professor Dumbledore does not own it.
16) Yes, we do see it at GP 12.
17) Yes, it is owned by Mad Eye Moody and used by both him and Barty Crouch Jr.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 13, 2014, 08:48:14 PM
is it Mad Eye's eye ?  :madeye:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 13, 2014, 09:34:01 PM
is it Mad Eye's eye ?  :madeye:

 :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:      :madeye:

It is indeed! Congratulations, Eva Hedwig!
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 14, 2014, 06:01:17 AM
thanks, Evreka, nice riddle  :madeye:


I am thinking of a person
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 14, 2014, 06:15:37 AM
Is this person male?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 14, 2014, 07:37:00 AM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on October 14, 2014, 06:23:09 PM
Do we see this person in any of the first 3 books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 14, 2014, 07:10:18 PM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books


( I know I shouldn't have replied like this, just a yes or no, but it would be misleading if I only confirmed about the books or if he is seen  :hmm:)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 14, 2014, 07:26:41 PM
Is he in more than one book?

Do we see this person in any of the first 3 books?
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books

( I know I shouldn't have replied like this, just a yes or no, but it would be misleading if I only confirmed about the books or if he is seen  :hmm:)
Yes, but if you take the entire sentence and turn it into "reply form" you get:No, we do not see this person in any of the first three books. which isn't misleading at all. Someone would have come by, seen it and gone  :mcgonagall2: . And then fired off Is he seen at all? or Is he in the first three books?

Congrats to the new user title, Eva Hedwig, by the way! :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 14, 2014, 07:36:22 PM
Is he magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 14, 2014, 07:57:28 PM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical

thanks Evreka for the congratulation  :)

I pondered some minutes about how to respond only one answer, but it didn't seemed fitting. If I replied as you suggested that people would have supposed that he is seen.  ...
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 15, 2014, 04:59:42 AM
Is he mentioned out loud?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 15, 2014, 07:13:40 AM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
59 yes, he is mentioned out loud
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 15, 2014, 08:04:58 AM
Is he mentioned in PS?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 15, 2014, 08:04:29 PM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 15, 2014, 08:42:30 PM
Is he mentioned in POA?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 16, 2014, 05:16:43 PM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 16, 2014, 05:23:08 PM
Is he mentioned in Diagon Alley?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 16, 2014, 05:37:33 PM
Is he mentioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 17, 2014, 06:06:08 AM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
8 ) he is not mentioned in Diagon Alley
9) he is not metioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 17, 2014, 07:54:08 AM
Is he mentioned at the Burrow?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 17, 2014, 05:11:03 PM
Do we know his name?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 17, 2014, 08:21:25 PM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
8 ) he is not mentioned in Diagon Alley
9) he is not metioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary
10) he is not mentioned at the burrow

11) no, we don't know his name
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on October 18, 2014, 04:43:37 AM
Did he attend Hogwarts at the time Harry and the others were there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 18, 2014, 09:19:50 AM
Is he associated to the Dark side somehow?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 18, 2014, 06:34:09 PM
Moving along from my last question (question eight):
Is he mentioned in Knockturn Alley?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 18, 2014, 06:53:55 PM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
8 ) he is not mentioned in Diagon Alley
9) he is not metioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary
10) he is not mentioned at the burrow

11) no, we don't know his name
12) no, he did not attened Hogwarts at the time Harry and the others where there
13) no, he is not associated to the Dark side somehow
14) no, he is not mentioned at Knockturn Alley
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 18, 2014, 07:41:30 PM
Is he Olive Hornby's brother?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 18, 2014, 07:48:16 PM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
8 ) he is not mentioned in Diagon Alley
9) he is not metioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary
10) he is not mentioned at the burrow

11) no, we don't know his name
12) no, he did not attened Hogwarts at the time Harry and the others where there
13) no, he is not associated to the Dark side somehow
14) no, he is not mentioned at Knockturn Alley
15) no, he is not Olive Hornby's brother
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 18, 2014, 08:18:58 PM
Is he mentioned in a classroom lesson?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 18, 2014, 08:49:55 PM
is he mentioned by one or more of the trio? :harry: :ron: :hermioneread:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 19, 2014, 05:46:27 AM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
8 ) he is not mentioned in Diagon Alley
9) he is not metioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary
10) he is not mentioned at the burrow

11) no, we don't know his name
12) no, he did not attened Hogwarts at the time Harry and the others where there
13) no, he is not associated to the Dark side somehow
14) no, he is not mentioned at Knockturn Alley
15) no, he is not Olive Hornby's brother
16) no, he is not mentioned in a classroom lesson
17)) no, he is not mentioned by one or more of the trio
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 19, 2014, 08:40:27 AM
Is he mentioned at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 19, 2014, 06:55:23 PM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
8 ) he is not mentioned in Diagon Alley
9) he is not metioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary
10) he is not mentioned at the burrow

11) no, we don't know his name
12) no, he did not attened Hogwarts at the time Harry and the others where there
13) no, he is not associated to the Dark side somehow
14) no, he is not mentioned at Knockturn Alley
15) no, he is not Olive Hornby's brother
16) no, he is not mentioned in a classroom lesson
17)) no, he is not mentioned by one or more of the trio
18) yes, he is mentioned at Hogwarts
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on October 19, 2014, 08:02:44 PM
Is he related to someone who's a student at Hogwarts in CoS?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 19, 2014, 08:31:24 PM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
8 ) he is not mentioned in Diagon Alley
9) he is not metioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary
10) he is not mentioned at the burrow

11) no, we don't know his name
12) no, he did not attened Hogwarts at the time Harry and the others where there
13) no, he is not associated to the Dark side somehow
14) no, he is not mentioned at Knockturn Alley
15) no, he is not Olive Hornby's brother
16) no, he is not mentioned in a classroom lesson
17)) no, he is not mentioned by one or more of the trio
18) yes, he is mentioned at Hogwarts
19) no, he is not related to who's a student at Hogwarts in CoS


Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 19, 2014, 08:53:35 PM
Is it the ugly old Armenian warlock who saved a village from werewolves and had all his memories robbed from him by the Charming, Smiling, blibbering idiot called Lockhart?  :mcgonagall2:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 20, 2014, 06:28:56 AM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
8 ) he is not mentioned in Diagon Alley
9) he is not metioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary
10) he is not mentioned at the burrow

11) no, we don't know his name
12) no, he did not attened Hogwarts at the time Harry and the others where there
13) no, he is not associated to the Dark side somehow
14) no, he is not mentioned at Knockturn Alley
15) no, he is not Olive Hornby's brother
16) no, he is not mentioned in a classroom lesson
17)) no, he is not mentioned by one or more of the trio
18) yes, he is mentioned at Hogwarts
19) no, he is not related to who's a student at Hogwarts in CoS
20) no, Lockhart doesn't mention him
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 20, 2014, 08:15:22 AM
Is he mentioned by a student?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 20, 2014, 06:36:01 PM
Is he mentioned more than once?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 21, 2014, 06:55:44 AM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
8 ) he is not mentioned in Diagon Alley
9) he is not metioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary
10) he is not mentioned at the burrow

11) no, we don't know his name
12) no, he did not attened Hogwarts at the time Harry and the others where there
13) no, he is not associated to the Dark side somehow
14) no, he is not mentioned at Knockturn Alley
15) no, he is not Olive Hornby's brother
16) no, he is not mentioned in a classroom lesson
17)) no, he is not mentioned by one or more of the trio
18) yes, he is mentioned at Hogwarts
19) no, he is not related to who's a student at Hogwarts in CoS
20) no, Lockhart doesn't mention him

21) a student doesn't mention him
22) he is not mentioned more than once

hint: he is mentioned outside the castle
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on October 21, 2014, 01:57:13 PM
Is it Arragog the Accromantula that befriended Hagrid?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 21, 2014, 06:39:49 PM
Is he mentioned by Hagrid?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 21, 2014, 07:03:03 PM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
8 ) he is not mentioned in Diagon Alley
9) he is not metioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary
10) he is not mentioned at the burrow

11) no, we don't know his name
12) no, he did not attened Hogwarts at the time Harry and the others where there
13) no, he is not associated to the Dark side somehow
14) no, he is not mentioned at Knockturn Alley
15) no, he is not Olive Hornby's brother
16) no, he is not mentioned in a classroom lesson
17)) no, he is not mentioned by one or more of the trio
18) yes, he is mentioned at Hogwarts
19) no, he is not related to who's a student at Hogwarts in CoS
20) no, Lockhart doesn't mention him

21) a student doesn't mention him
22) he is not mentioned more than once
23) it's not Aragog, its a person
24) Hagrid doesnt mention him

hint: he is mentioned outside the castle
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 21, 2014, 07:46:19 PM
Is he mentioned by a Professor?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 21, 2014, 08:01:52 PM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
8 ) he is not mentioned in Diagon Alley
9) he is not metioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary
10) he is not mentioned at the burrow

11) no, we don't know his name
12) no, he did not attened Hogwarts at the time Harry and the others where there
13) no, he is not associated to the Dark side somehow
14) no, he is not mentioned at Knockturn Alley
15) no, he is not Olive Hornby's brother
16) no, he is not mentioned in a classroom lesson
17)) no, he is not mentioned by one or more of the trio
18) yes, he is mentioned at Hogwarts
19) no, he is not related to who's a student at Hogwarts in CoS
20) no, Lockhart doesn't mention him

21) a student doesn't mention him
22) he is not mentioned more than once
23) it's not Aragog, its a person
24) Hagrid doesnt mention him
25) he is not mentioned by a professor

hint: he is mentioned outside the castle
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 21, 2014, 08:21:41 PM
Is he mentioned in present time (1992-93)? (As opposed to in one way or another 50 years ago?)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 21, 2014, 10:39:45 PM
I am thinking of a person

1) yes, this person is male
2) the person is not seen, but yeah he's in one of the first three books
3) he is only in one book
4) yes, he is magical
5) yes, he is mentioned out loud
6) no, he is not mentioned in PS
7) no, he is not mentioned in PoA
8 ) he is not mentioned in Diagon Alley
9) he is not metioned during the time Harry falls into the Diary
10) he is not mentioned at the burrow

11) no, we don't know his name
12) no, he did not attened Hogwarts at the time Harry and the others where there
13) no, he is not associated to the Dark side somehow
14) no, he is not mentioned at Knockturn Alley
15) no, he is not Olive Hornby's brother
16) no, he is not mentioned in a classroom lesson
17)) no, he is not mentioned by one or more of the trio
18) yes, he is mentioned at Hogwarts
19) no, he is not related to who's a student at Hogwarts in CoS
20) no, Lockhart doesn't mention him

21) a student doesn't mention him
22) he is not mentioned more than once
23) it's not Aragog, its a person
24) Hagrid doesnt mention him
25) he is not mentioned by a professor
26) he is mentioned in present time, if I understood the question right ? but yes it is in reference to a time about 50 years ago

hint: he is mentioned outside the castle
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 22, 2014, 08:54:27 PM
Is it the traveller who gave Aragog's egg to Hagrid?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 24, 2014, 07:39:48 AM
Is it the traveller who gave Aragog's egg to Hagrid? 

yes, indeed, congrats Evreka  :)   your turn




while you are thinking, is whatevre/whomever in more than one book ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 24, 2014, 08:13:30 AM
Congratulations, Evreka.  :bravo: :aragog:

Is who, what or wherever magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 24, 2014, 08:17:25 PM
That was challenging and fun, Eva Hedwig!!!  :thumbup:

I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, whatevre/whomever is in more than one book.
2) Yes, it is magical.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 25, 2014, 02:35:51 AM
Is it owned?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 25, 2014, 08:26:11 AM
That was challenging and fun, Eva Hedwig!!!  :thumbup:

I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, whatever/whomever is in more than one book.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is owned.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 25, 2014, 08:40:49 AM
Is it seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 25, 2014, 01:01:15 PM
That was challenging and fun, Eva Hedwig!!!  :thumbup:

I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, whatever/whomever is in more than one book.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is owned.
4) Yes, it is seen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 25, 2014, 01:29:34 PM
is it used ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 25, 2014, 07:42:24 PM
Is the owner female?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on October 25, 2014, 09:21:27 PM
Is this thing seen in one or more of the last 3 books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 26, 2014, 08:31:39 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, whatever/whomever is in more than one book.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is owned.
4) Yes, it is seen.
5) Yes, it is used.
6) No, the owner is not female.
7) No, as far as I remember this thing is not seen in one or more of the last 3 books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 27, 2014, 11:05:26 PM
Do we ever see it in the muggle world?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 28, 2014, 06:15:25 PM
is the owner a student ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 28, 2014, 08:28:31 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, whatever/whomever is in more than one book.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is owned.
4) Yes, it is seen.
5) Yes, it is used.
6) No, the owner is not female.
7) No, as far as I remember this thing is not seen in one or more of the last 3 books.
8 ) Yes, we do see it in the Muggle world.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 29, 2014, 05:15:53 PM
is the owner a family member of a student while Harry is at Hogwarts ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 29, 2014, 05:20:34 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, whatever/whomever is in more than one book.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is owned.
4) Yes, it is seen.
5) Yes, it is used.
6) No, the owner is not female.
7) No, as far as I remember this thing is not seen in one or more of the last 3 books.
8 ) Yes, we do see it in the Muggle world.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) Yes, the owner is a family member of a student while Harry is at Hogwarts.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 29, 2014, 06:39:49 PM
Is the owner Mr. Weasley?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 29, 2014, 06:40:47 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, whatever/whomever is in more than one book.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is owned.
4) Yes, it is seen.
5) Yes, it is used.
6) No, the owner is not female.
7) No, as far as I remember this thing is not seen in one or more of the last 3 books.
8 ) Yes, we do see it in the Muggle world.
9) No, the owner is not a student.
10) Yes, the owner is a family member of a student while Harry is at Hogwarts.
11) Yes, the owner is Mr. Weasley.  :mollyarthur:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on October 29, 2014, 07:33:19 PM
Is it the Ford Anglia?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 29, 2014, 08:53:43 PM
Is it the Ford Anglia?
:yay:  :owlso: That was impressively quick! Congratulations, ss19! Your turn!
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 30, 2014, 05:57:30 AM
wow this was a short round, congrats ss19  :)


while you are thinking: is whatever/whomever in more than one book ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 30, 2014, 06:23:35 AM
Congrats from me, too, ss19, and is who/ what/ wherever magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on October 30, 2014, 06:32:28 PM
Thank you, Evreka, Eva Hedwig, and BillieMac! :)


I'm thinking of a person.

1. No, they're not in more than one book.
2. Yes, they're magical.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 30, 2014, 06:48:55 PM
Are they female?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 30, 2014, 09:22:57 PM
Are they seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on October 31, 2014, 12:35:01 AM
I'm thinking of a person.

1. No, they're not in more than one book.
2. Yes, they're magical.
3. No, he's not female.
4. Yes, he's seen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on October 31, 2014, 02:02:32 AM
Hi ss19, glad to see you're the leader good round last round. :)

Is he seen in one of the last 4 books? :pawprint: :reading:  :bear:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 31, 2014, 06:33:25 AM
Is he seen at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on October 31, 2014, 07:24:41 AM
is he a student ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on October 31, 2014, 02:35:17 PM
Thank you, Buckbeak 26! :)

I'm thinking of a person.

1. No, they're not in more than one book.
2. Yes, they're magical.
3. No, he's not female.
4. Yes, he's seen.
5. Yes, he is seen in one of the last 4 books.
6. Yes, he is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, he's not a student.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on October 31, 2014, 04:50:53 PM
Is he in GoF?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 31, 2014, 08:16:52 PM
Do we know his name?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 01, 2014, 01:16:44 AM
is he on the good side ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 01, 2014, 03:13:24 AM
I'm thinking of a person.

1. No, they're not in more than one book.
2. Yes, they're magical.
3. No, he's not female.
4. Yes, he's seen.
5. Yes, he is seen in one of the last 4 books.
6. Yes, he is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, he's not a student.
8. Yes, he is in GoF.
9. Yes, we know his name.
10. Yes, I think we can probably say that he's on the good side.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on November 01, 2014, 03:19:37 AM
Is he also seen at the QWC?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 01, 2014, 05:04:01 PM
does he speak to Harry ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 02, 2014, 03:30:57 AM
I'm thinking of a person.

1. No, they're not in more than one book.
2. Yes, they're magical.
3. No, he's not female.
4. Yes, he's seen.
5. Yes, he is seen in one of the last 4 books.
6. Yes, he is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, he's not a student.
8. Yes, he is in GoF.
9. Yes, we know his name.
10. Yes, I think we can probably say that he's on the good side.
11. Yes, he's also seen at the Quidditch World Cup.
12. Yes, he speaks to Harry.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 02, 2014, 06:37:50 AM
does he works in the MoM ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 02, 2014, 08:39:52 AM
This is a long shot here but could it be Ludo Bagman?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 02, 2014, 06:27:39 PM
Is it Mr Crouch Sr?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 02, 2014, 07:03:44 PM
I'm thinking of a person.

1. No, they're not in more than one book.
2. Yes, they're magical.
3. No, he's not female.
4. Yes, he's seen.
5. Yes, he is seen in one of the last 4 books.
6. Yes, he is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, he's not a student.
8. Yes, he is in GoF.
9. Yes, we know his name.
10. Yes, I think we can probably say that he's on the good side.
11. Yes, he's also seen at the Quidditch World Cup.
12. Yes, he speaks to Harry.
13. Yes, he works in the Ministry of Magic.
14. No, it's not Ludo Bagman.
15. No, it's not Mr. Crouch Sr.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 02, 2014, 08:13:43 PM
Is he also seen in the Pensieve?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 02, 2014, 09:47:47 PM
Crouch Jr.?   :doctor10:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 02, 2014, 09:52:43 PM
I'm thinking of a person.

1. No, they're not in more than one book.
2. Yes, they're magical.
3. No, he's not female.
4. Yes, he's seen.
5. Yes, he is seen in one of the last 4 books.
6. Yes, he is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, he's not a student.
8. Yes, he is in GoF.
9. Yes, we know his name.
10. Yes, I think we can probably say that he's on the good side.
11. Yes, he's also seen at the Quidditch World Cup.
12. Yes, he speaks to Harry.
13. Yes, he works in the Ministry of Magic.
14. No, it's not Ludo Bagman.
15. No, it's not Mr. Crouch Sr.
16. No, he's not seen in the Pensieve.
17. No, it's not Mr. Crouch Jr.  :doctor10:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 02, 2014, 11:02:43 PM
Is he in the group that fired stunning spells over the trio after the dark mark was cast at the Quidditch World Cup?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 03, 2014, 01:25:20 AM
I'm thinking of a person.

1. No, they're not in more than one book.
2. Yes, they're magical.
3. No, he's not female.
4. Yes, he's seen.
5. Yes, he is seen in one of the last 4 books.
6. Yes, he is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, he's not a student.
8. Yes, he is in GoF.
9. Yes, we know his name.
10. Yes, I think we can probably say that he's on the good side.
11. Yes, he's also seen at the Quidditch World Cup.
12. Yes, he speaks to Harry.
13. Yes, he works in the Ministry of Magic.
14. No, it's not Ludo Bagman.
15. No, it's not Mr. Crouch Sr.
16. No, he's not seen in the Pensieve.
17. No, it's not Mr. Crouch Jr.  :doctor10:
18. Yes, he's in the group that fired stunning spells over the trio after the dark mark was cast at the Quidditch World Cup.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 03, 2014, 01:30:02 AM
Is it Cedric's father Amos Diggory?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 03, 2014, 02:10:28 AM
Is it Cedric's father Amos Diggory?

Yes, it is Cedric's father Amos Diggory!  Excellent job, Buckbeak 26!  :thumbup: He was seen at Hogwarts when the families of the champions were invited to school for the Third Task.  We don't actually see him fight on the good side during the battle in DH, but I would assume he'd be on the good side after his son was killed by the bad side.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 03, 2014, 05:36:52 PM
well done, Buckbeak26  :)



while you are thinking, is whatever/whomever in more than one book ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 04, 2014, 03:05:47 AM
I'm thinking of a Person:



1. Yes, this person is in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 04, 2014, 03:58:04 PM
are they magical ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 04, 2014, 07:41:32 PM
I'm thinking of a Person:

1. Yes, this person is in more than one book.
2. Yes they are magical.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on November 04, 2014, 11:36:08 PM
Is the person male?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 04, 2014, 11:43:45 PM
Is this person seen at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 05, 2014, 12:24:07 AM
I'm thinking of a Person:

1. Yes, this person is in more than one book.
2. Yes they are magical.
3.yes, the person is male
4. yes, he is seen at Hogwarts :)


Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on November 05, 2014, 06:52:26 AM
Is he a student?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 05, 2014, 07:06:09 AM
is this person seen in one or more of the last two books ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 05, 2014, 02:20:20 PM
I'm thinking of a Person:

1. Yes, this person is in more than one book.
2. Yes they are magical.
3.yes, the person is male
4. yes, he is seen at Hogwarts :)
5.No, he is not a student
6. Yes, he is seen in one or more of the last 2 books.


Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 05, 2014, 04:22:52 PM
is he on the "good side" ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 05, 2014, 08:21:22 PM

I'm thinking of a Person:

1. Yes, this person is in more than one book.
2. Yes they are magical.
3.yes, the person is male
4. yes, he is seen at Hogwarts :)
5.No, he is not a student
6. Yes, he is seen in one or more of the last 2 books.
7. yes, you could say he is on the good side



Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 05, 2014, 09:31:09 PM
Is he a Professor?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 06, 2014, 04:39:59 AM
is he seen at Hogwarts in DH ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 06, 2014, 02:12:52 PM
I'm thinking of a Person:

1. Yes, this person is in more than one book.
2. Yes they are magical.
3.yes, the person is male
4. yes, he is seen at Hogwarts :)
5.No, he is not a student
6. Yes, he is seen in one or more of the last 2 books.
7. yes, you could say he is on the good side.
8. Yes, he is a Professor/ Teacher
9.Yes,he is at Hogwarts during DH. :mcgonagall2: :tardis: :doctor11: :K-9:



Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on November 06, 2014, 06:32:07 PM
Is he Horace Slughorn?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 06, 2014, 06:47:27 PM
Is he Severus Snape?  :snape:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 06, 2014, 07:09:12 PM
Is it Filius Flitwick?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 06, 2014, 08:31:38 PM
I'm thinking of a Person:

1. Yes, this person is in more than one book.
2. Yes they are magical.
3.yes, the person is male
4. yes, he is seen at Hogwarts :)
5.No, he is not a student
6. Yes, he is seen in one or more of the last 2 books.
7. yes, you could say he is on the good side.
8. Yes, he is a Professor/ Teacher
9.Yes,he is at Hogwarts during DH. :mcgonagall2: :tardis: :doctor11: :K-9:
10. No it is not Horace Slughorn
11.No, it is not Filius Flitwick


Is he Severus Snape?  :snape:

12. Yes ss19, it is your favorite character (and mine too) Mr. Severus Snape. :snape:

Congratulations it is now your turn, I knew that you would like this. :)




Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 07, 2014, 03:37:47 AM
ahhh Professor Snape  :snape:   congrats ss19  :)



while you are thinking... is whatever/whomver in more than one book ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 07, 2014, 02:49:54 PM
Thank you, Buckbeak 26 and Eva Hedwig!  :snape:


I am thinking of a creature.

1. Yes, it is in more than one book.

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on November 07, 2014, 06:23:12 PM
Congratulations from me, too, ss19.

Is it magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 07, 2014, 06:49:39 PM
does it have legs ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 07, 2014, 08:03:35 PM
Is it an individual creature as opposed to a species?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 07, 2014, 08:18:28 PM
do we know its name ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on November 07, 2014, 09:29:34 PM
Is it a pet?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 07, 2014, 10:39:10 PM
Thank you, BillieMac! :)

I am thinking of a creature.

1. Yes, it is in more than one book.
2. It's debatable, but I would maybe say that it is magical in a way.  No, I don't think it's magical.
3. Yes, it has legs.
4. Yes, it is an individual creature rather than a species.
5. Yes, we know its name.
6. Yes, it is a pet.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on November 07, 2014, 10:51:46 PM
Does it belong to Hagrid?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 07, 2014, 11:19:37 PM
Sorry, I changed my mind on Question #2 (after debating with myself  ;D)...

I am thinking of a creature.

1. Yes, it is in more than one book.
2. It's debatable, but I would maybe say that it is magical in a way.  No, I don't think it's magical.
3. Yes, it has legs.
4. Yes, it is an individual creature rather than a species.
5. Yes, we know its name.
6. Yes, it is a pet.
7. No, it does not belong to Hagrid.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on November 07, 2014, 11:57:16 PM
Is it a mammal?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 08, 2014, 06:51:49 AM
is it seen ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 08, 2014, 07:18:44 AM
Is it Mrs Norris?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 08, 2014, 10:09:43 AM
Is it Crookshanks?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 08, 2014, 12:00:21 PM
Is it a cat (or cat-like animal such as a kneazle or part-kneazle)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 08, 2014, 02:44:34 PM
Is it Mrs Norris?

Yes, it is Mrs. Norris.  How did everyone narrow it down so quickly? :o

Re Question 2, at first I said it might be magical because some fans have the theory that she's part kneazle, plus I wasn't sure if cats in general might be considered magical in the wizarding world.  But then I did some Googling and found that JKR has said on her website that Mrs. Norris is an ordinary cat, so I decided to change my answer.
 :crookshanks:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 08, 2014, 03:28:24 PM
Yes, it is Mrs. Norris.  How did everyone narrow it down so quickly? :o

Re Question 2, at first I said it might be magical because some fans have the theory that she's part kneazle, plus I wasn't sure if cats in general might be considered magical in the wizarding world.  But then I did some Googling and found that JKR has said on her website that Mrs. Norris is an ordinary cat, so I decided to change my answer.
 :crookshanks:
It was question 2 that pointed us in the right direction, as cats are the most ambiguously magical creatures in the books (probably followed by owls).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 08, 2014, 05:40:37 PM
Also, there aren't many debatable non-magical pets that we see in more than one book. :)

I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on November 08, 2014, 06:27:04 PM
Is it magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 08, 2014, 06:27:55 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.  :shake:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 08, 2014, 07:24:46 PM
Is it in any of the first four books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 08, 2014, 08:05:32 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books. :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 08, 2014, 11:38:41 PM
It was question 2 that pointed us in the right direction, as cats are the most ambiguously magical creatures in the books (probably followed by owls).
Also, there aren't many debatable non-magical pets that we see in more than one book. :)

Ah, I see.  That makes sense.  Thank you both!


For the new round, is it seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: BillieMac on November 09, 2014, 12:09:48 AM
Is it owned?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 09, 2014, 06:44:22 AM
is it bigger than a Quaffle  ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 09, 2014, 08:27:02 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 09, 2014, 08:53:26 AM
Is it in one or more of the first two books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 09, 2014, 09:08:31 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 10, 2014, 04:08:33 PM
is it in PoA ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 10, 2014, 07:06:38 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) No, it is not in POA.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 11, 2014, 06:42:59 AM
is it mentioned out loud ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 11, 2014, 02:02:50 PM
Is it mentioned at the Quidditch World Cup in GOF?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 11, 2014, 04:02:38 PM
is the owner female ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 11, 2014, 09:26:13 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) No, it is not in POA.
8 ) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
9) No, it is not mentioned at the Quidditch World Cup in GOF.
10) No, the owner is not female.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 11, 2014, 09:51:44 PM
Is it connected to the triwizard tournament in any way?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 12, 2014, 06:08:10 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) No, it is not in POA.
8 ) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
9) No, it is not mentioned at the Quidditch World Cup in GOF.
10) No, the owner is not female.
11) No, it is not connected to the triwizard tournament in any way.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 13, 2014, 01:44:07 AM
is it mentioned out loud at Hogwarts in GoF ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 13, 2014, 08:49:33 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) No, it is not in POA.
8 ) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
9) No, it is not mentioned at the Quidditch World Cup in GOF.
10) No, the owner is not female.
11) No, it is not connected to the triwizard tournament in any way.
12) No, it is not mentioned out loud at Hogwarts in GOF.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 13, 2014, 10:28:35 PM
Do we see the owner with this thing? (I mean does J.K. Rowling mention in GOF someone with this thing.)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 15, 2014, 06:54:12 AM
is it mentioned out loud in a muggle place ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 15, 2014, 05:21:18 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) No, it is not in POA.
8 ) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
9) No, it is not mentioned at the Quidditch World Cup in GOF.
10) No, the owner is not female.
11) No, it is not connected to the triwizard tournament in any way.
12) No, it is not mentioned out loud at Hogwarts in GOF.
13) No, the narrator does not mention in GOF that someone owns this thing. That's what you meant,  Buckbeak 26?
14) Yes, it is mentioned out loud in a Muggle place.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 17, 2014, 08:36:48 PM
Is it mentioned in or around Little Hangleton (eg. Riddle House, graveyard, The Hanged Man)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 17, 2014, 09:00:27 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) No, it is not in POA.
8 ) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
9) No, it is not mentioned at the Quidditch World Cup in GOF.
10) No, the owner is not female.
11) No, it is not connected to the triwizard tournament in any way.
12) No, it is not mentioned out loud at Hogwarts in GOF.
13) No, the narrator does not mention in GOF that someone owns this thing. That's what you meant,  Buckbeak 26?
14) Yes, it is mentioned out loud in a Muggle place.
15) No, it is not mentioned in or around Little Hangleton (eg. Riddle House, graveyard, The Hanged Man).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 18, 2014, 12:34:43 AM
Okay rephrase my question to this:

Do the trio talk about this thing as they go throughout the school year in between the 3 tasks?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 18, 2014, 06:14:39 AM
is it mentioned loud  in our arround Privet Drive ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 18, 2014, 08:19:19 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) No, it is not in POA.
8 ) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
9) No, it is not mentioned at the Quidditch World Cup in GOF.
10) No, the owner is not female.
11) No, it is not connected to the triwizard tournament in any way.
12) No, it is not mentioned out loud at Hogwarts in GOF.
13) No, the narrator does not mention in GOF that someone owns this thing.
14) Yes, it is mentioned out loud in a Muggle place.
15) No, it is not mentioned in or around Little Hangleton (eg. Riddle House, graveyard, The Hanged Man).
16) No, the trio does not talk about this thing as they go throughout the school year in between the 3 tasks, see 12).
17) Yes, it is mentioned out loud  in or around Privet Drive.  :nod:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 19, 2014, 05:27:24 AM
does a Dursley owns it ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 19, 2014, 08:27:57 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) No, it is not in POA.
8 ) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
9) No, it is not mentioned at the Quidditch World Cup in GOF.
10) No, the owner is not female.
11) No, it is not connected to the triwizard tournament in any way.
12) No, it is not mentioned out loud at Hogwarts in GOF.
13) No, the narrator does not mention in GOF that someone owns this thing.
14) Yes, it is mentioned out loud in a Muggle place.
15) No, it is not mentioned in or around Little Hangleton (eg. Riddle House, graveyard, The Hanged Man).
16) No, the trio does not talk about this thing as they go throughout the school year in between the 3 tasks, see 12).
17) Yes, it is mentioned out loud  in or around Privet Drive.  :nod:
18) No, none of the Dursleys owns it.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 19, 2014, 09:51:56 PM
does a Weasley owns it ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 19, 2014, 10:21:18 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) No, it is not in POA.
8 ) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
9) No, it is not mentioned at the Quidditch World Cup in GOF.
10) No, the owner is not female.
11) No, it is not connected to the triwizard tournament in any way.
12) No, it is not mentioned out loud at Hogwarts in GOF.
13) No, the narrator does not mention in GOF that someone owns this thing.
14) Yes, it is mentioned out loud in a Muggle place.
15) No, it is not mentioned in or around Little Hangleton (eg. Riddle House, graveyard, The Hanged Man).
16) No, the trio does not talk about this thing as they go throughout the school year in between the 3 tasks, see 12).
17) Yes, it is mentioned out loud  in or around Privet Drive.  :nod:
18) No, none of the Dursleys owns it.
19) Yes, a Weasley owns it. :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 19, 2014, 11:46:04 PM
is it Arthur ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 20, 2014, 09:11:51 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) No, it is not in POA.
8 ) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
9) No, it is not mentioned at the Quidditch World Cup in GOF.
10) No, the owner is not female.
11) No, it is not connected to the triwizard tournament in any way.
12) No, it is not mentioned out loud at Hogwarts in GOF.
13) No, the narrator does not mention in GOF that someone owns this thing.
14) Yes, it is mentioned out loud in a Muggle place.
15) No, it is not mentioned in or around Little Hangleton (eg. Riddle House, graveyard, The Hanged Man).
16) No, the trio does not talk about this thing as they go throughout the school year in between the 3 tasks, see 12).
17) Yes, it is mentioned out loud  in or around Privet Drive.  :nod:
18) No, none of the Dursleys owns it.
19) Yes, a Weasley owns it. :)
20) Yes, Arthur owns it.

Hint: While the Dursleys do not own this thing, they are bound to own similar things, sort of.  ;)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 22, 2014, 02:48:22 AM
is it Arthur's large collection of batteries ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 22, 2014, 07:52:48 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical. 
2) Yes, it is in one or more of the first four books.
3) No, this is not seen.
4) Yes, it is owned.
5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) No, it is not in POA.
8 ) Yes, it is mentioned out loud.
9) No, it is not mentioned at the Quidditch World Cup in GOF.
10) No, the owner is not female.
11) No, it is not connected to the triwizard tournament in any way.
12) No, it is not mentioned out loud at Hogwarts in GOF.
13) No, the narrator does not mention in GOF that someone owns this thing.
14) Yes, it is mentioned out loud in a Muggle place.
15) No, it is not mentioned in or around Little Hangleton (eg. Riddle House, graveyard, The Hanged Man).
16) No, the trio does not talk about this thing as they go throughout the school year in between the 3 tasks, see 12).
17) Yes, it is mentioned out loud  in or around Privet Drive.  :nod:
18) No, none of the Dursleys owns it.
19) Yes, a Weasley owns it. :)
20) Yes, Arthur owns it.

Hint: While the Dursleys do not own this thing, they are bound to own similar things, sort of.  ;)

21) Weeell, no, it is not Arthur's large collection of batteries.... But this is so close it's burning!

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 22, 2014, 05:19:50 PM
it can't be the plugs ? because the Dursleys have them also ....  :what:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 22, 2014, 06:17:22 PM
it can't be the plugs ? because the Dursleys have them also ....  :what:
The Dursleys have plugs, certainly, (as I am sure, they also have batteries), but they don't have Arthur's collection of plugs.

 :stars: :flower: We've got a winner! Your turn!

5) Well, no, I would say that it is not bigger than a Quaffle but this might be debatable. I think it is probably safe to say no with a good margin (see 3).
An individual plug is certainly less, but we have no idea how many plugs he have collected, so....?

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 23, 2014, 05:12:28 PM
thank you Evreka for the fun round :)



I am thinking of a thing  ....
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 23, 2014, 09:28:08 PM
Is it magical?  :rubberduck:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 23, 2014, 10:58:17 PM
I am thinking of a thing  ....


1) it is not magical
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 24, 2014, 09:27:44 PM
Is it seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 25, 2014, 04:28:02 PM
I am thinking of a thing  ....


1) it is not magical
2) yes, it is seen
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 25, 2014, 09:15:24 PM
Is it owned?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 26, 2014, 01:18:03 AM
I am thinking of a thing  ....


1) it is not magical
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is owned
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 27, 2014, 07:05:36 PM
Is it owned by someone magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 28, 2014, 05:24:49 AM
I am thinking of a thing  ....


1) it is not magical
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is owned
49 yes, it is owned by someone magical
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 28, 2014, 08:27:18 PM
Is it owned by one of the trio?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 29, 2014, 06:58:51 AM
I am thinking of a thing  ....


1) it is not magical
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is owned
4)  yes, it is owned by someone magical
5) no its not owned by one of the trio
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 29, 2014, 11:40:39 AM
Is it seen at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 29, 2014, 04:43:56 PM
I am thinking of a thing  ....


1) it is not magical
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is owned
4)  yes, it is owned by someone magical
5) no its not owned by one of the trio
6) no, its not seen at Hogwarts
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 29, 2014, 11:18:06 PM
Is it seen in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on November 30, 2014, 04:01:01 AM
Is it seen in any of the first 3 books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ginginkat on December 01, 2014, 02:31:27 AM
Does a female own it?

 :train:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 01, 2014, 06:01:38 PM
I am thinking of a thing  ....


1) it is not magical
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is owned
4)  yes, it is owned by someone magical
5) no its not owned by one of the trio
6) no, its not seen at Hogwarts
7) no, it's not seen in more than one book
8- yes, it is seen in any of the first three books
9) no, a female doesnt own it
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 01, 2014, 07:44:47 PM
Is it owned by a Weasley?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 01, 2014, 08:28:12 PM
Is it seen in POA?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 02, 2014, 05:28:07 AM
I am thinking of a thing  ....


1) it is not magical
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is owned
4)  yes, it is owned by someone magical
5) no its not owned by one of the trio
6) no, its not seen at Hogwarts
7) no, it's not seen in more than one book
8- yes, it is seen in any of the first three books
9) no, a female doesnt own it
10) no, a Weasly doesnt own it

11) no, its not seen in PoA
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 02, 2014, 06:35:13 PM
Is it seen in book 2?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 02, 2014, 10:36:33 PM
Is it seen in one or more of Diagon Alley and Knockturn Alley?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 03, 2014, 06:39:24 AM
I am thinking of a thing  ....


1) it is not magical
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is owned
4)  yes, it is owned by someone magical
5) no its not owned by one of the trio
6) no, its not seen at Hogwarts
7) no, it's not seen in more than one book
8- yes, it is seen in any of the first three books
9) no, a female doesnt own it
10) no, a Weasly doesnt own it

11) no, its not seen in PoA
12) yes,  it is seen i book 2
13) yes, it st seen in one or more of Diagon Alley and Knockturn Alley
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 03, 2014, 07:59:21 PM
Is it seen outdoors?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 03, 2014, 10:15:01 PM
Is it seen in Knockturn Alley?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 03, 2014, 11:20:33 PM
I am thinking of a thing  ....


1) it is not magical
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is owned
4)  yes, it is owned by someone magical
5) no its not owned by one of the trio
6) no, its not seen at Hogwarts
7) no, it's not seen in more than one book
8- yes, it is seen in any of the first three books
9) no, a female doesnt own it
10) no, a Weasly doesnt own it

11) no, its not seen in PoA
12) yes,  it is seen i book 2
13) yes, it st seen in one or more of Diagon Alley and Knockturn Alley
14)  no, its not seen outdoors
15) yes, it is seen in Knockturn Alley :P
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 04, 2014, 10:03:08 PM
Is it owned by a Malfoy?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 05, 2014, 05:54:39 AM
I am thinking of a thing  ....


1) it is not magical
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is owned
4)  yes, it is owned by someone magical
5) no its not owned by one of the trio
6) no, its not seen at Hogwarts
7) no, it's not seen in more than one book
8- yes, it is seen in any of the first three books
9) no, a female doesnt own it
10) no, a Weasly doesnt own it

11) no, its not seen in PoA
12) yes,  it is seen i book 2
13) yes, it st seen in one or more of Diagon Alley and Knockturn Alley
14)  no, its not seen outdoors
15) yes, it is seen in Knockturn Alley
16) no, a Malfoy doesn't own it
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on December 05, 2014, 02:46:10 PM
Is it seen in  Borgin and Burke's?  :hagrid: :harryronbb:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 05, 2014, 05:33:26 PM
I am thinking of a thing  ....


1) it is not magical
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is owned
4)  yes, it is owned by someone magical
5) no its not owned by one of the trio
6) no, its not seen at Hogwarts
7) no, it's not seen in more than one book
8- yes, it is seen in any of the first three books
9) no, a female doesnt own it
10) no, a Weasly doesnt own it

11) no, its not seen in PoA
12) yes,  it is seen i book 2
13) yes, it st seen in one or more of Diagon Alley and Knockturn Alley
14)  no, its not seen outdoors
15) yes, it is seen in Knockturn Alley
16) no, a Malfoy doesn't own it
17, yes, it's seen in  Borgin and Burke's
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 05, 2014, 06:57:24 PM
Is it the pince-nez Mr Borgin uses?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 06, 2014, 05:51:32 AM
Is it the pince-nez Mr Borgin uses? 

indeed, it is, well guessed Evreka  8)



while you are thinking, is whatever/whomever in more than one book ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 07, 2014, 02:57:05 PM
Yay... It took some thinking to find something non-magical in that shop! :D Good game, Eva Hedwig!

I'm thinking of a creature....

1) No, it is not in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Buckbeak 26 on December 08, 2014, 06:36:12 PM
Does the trio see this creature?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 08, 2014, 10:06:04 PM
I'm thinking of a creature....

1) No, it is not in more than one book.
2) Yes, the trio does see this creature. :trio:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 08, 2014, 10:14:06 PM
Is it in the first three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 09, 2014, 05:57:40 AM
can it fly ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 09, 2014, 10:35:55 AM
Does it have exactly four legs?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 09, 2014, 08:02:09 PM
I'm thinking of a creature....

1) No, it is not in more than one book.
2) Yes, the trio does see this creature. :trio:
3) No, it is not in the first three books.
4) Yes, it can fly.
5) No, it does not have exactly four legs.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 10, 2014, 06:53:31 AM
does it have a name ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 10, 2014, 10:38:45 AM
Is it in books 4 or 5?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 10, 2014, 07:47:07 PM
I'm thinking of a creature....

1) No, it is not in more than one book.
2) Yes, the trio does see this creature. :trio:
3) No, it is not in the first three books.
4) Yes, it can fly.
5) No, it does not have exactly four legs.
6) No, it does not have a name.
7) Yes, it is in books 4 or 5.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 11, 2014, 03:59:20 AM
is it in GoF ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 11, 2014, 10:53:47 AM
Is it a bird?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 11, 2014, 07:22:32 PM
I'm thinking of a creature....

1) No, it is not in more than one book.
2) Yes, the trio does see this creature. :trio:
3) No, it is not in the first three books.
4) Yes, it can fly.
5) No, it does not have exactly four legs.
6) No, it does not have a name.
7) Yes, it is in books 4 or 5.
8 ) No, it is not in GOF.
9) No, it is not a bird.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 11, 2014, 09:09:16 PM
does the trio see this creature in the MoM ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 12, 2014, 12:01:55 AM
Is it seen at Grimmauld Place?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 12, 2014, 04:18:31 PM
I'm thinking of a creature....

1) No, it is not in more than one book.
2) Yes, the trio does see this creature. :trio:
3) No, it is not in the first three books.
4) Yes, it can fly.
5) No, it does not have exactly four legs.
6) No, it does not have a name.
7) Yes, it is in books 4 or 5.
8 ) No, it is not in GOF.
9) No, it is not a bird.
10) No, it is not seen at the MoM.
11) Yes, it is seen at Grimmauld Place.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 17, 2014, 12:05:55 AM
is it seen before end of august ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 17, 2014, 12:13:41 AM
Is it a doxy (despite it having four legs)? I don't think the number of legs on a doxy is given in the main Harry Potter series but it is given in Fantastic Beasts.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 17, 2014, 12:16:56 AM
is it in the room where the locket is found ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 17, 2014, 10:40:50 PM
Is it a doxy (despite it having four legs)? I don't think the number of legs on a doxy is given in the main Harry Potter series but it is given in Fantastic Beasts.
Yes, it is a doxy, and the reason I said no to four legs is because OOP, (pp. 103-104 - according to my Kindle) says this:
Quote
Harry had been spraying only a few seconds when a fully-grown Doxy came soaring out of a fold in the material, shiny beetle-like wings whirring, tiny needle-sharp teeth bared, its fairy-like body covered with thick black hair and its four tiny fists clenched with fury.
(My bold). As far as I am aware you don't have fists on your legs??  :what: So that would mean that it has four arms, right? That's how I understood it anyway. If it has four legs and four arms I wasn't aware of that?

Congrats, roonwit! Your turn!  :thumbup:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 20, 2014, 07:17:33 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 21, 2014, 02:10:52 PM
Does it have any magical abilities?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 21, 2014, 03:27:56 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 22, 2014, 09:14:21 AM
Is it seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 22, 2014, 11:02:00 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 23, 2014, 04:09:06 AM
is it owned by someone specific ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 23, 2014, 09:05:35 PM
Is it seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 23, 2014, 10:02:40 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 24, 2014, 11:42:58 PM
is it used ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 25, 2014, 05:26:06 PM
Is it seen at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 25, 2014, 09:10:49 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
5. No, it is not used.
6. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 25, 2014, 09:31:43 PM
is it seen in a classroom ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 26, 2014, 08:45:56 PM
Is it always in the same place?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 26, 2014, 11:31:15 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
5. No, it is not used.
6. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, it is not seen in a classroom.
8. Yes, it is always in the same place.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 27, 2014, 06:35:11 AM
is it seen inside the castle ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 27, 2014, 12:20:33 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
5. No, it is not used.
6. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, it is not seen in a classroom.
8. Yes, it is always in the same place.
9. Yes, it is seen inside the castle.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 27, 2014, 01:35:40 PM
Is it seen in the great hall?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 27, 2014, 08:48:28 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
5. No, it is not used.
6. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, it is not seen in a classroom.
8. Yes, it is always in the same place.
9. Yes, it is seen inside the castle.
10. No, it is not seen in the great hall.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 27, 2014, 09:36:24 PM
Is it seen in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 28, 2014, 07:59:32 AM
is it seen in a common room ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on December 28, 2014, 11:14:46 AM
Is it seen in the Room of Requirement?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 28, 2014, 03:22:30 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
5. No, it is not used.
6. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, it is not seen in a classroom.
8. Yes, it is always in the same place.
9. Yes, it is seen inside the castle.
10. No, it is not seen in the great hall.
11. Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
12. No, it is not seen in a common room.
13. Yes, it is seen in the Room of Requirement.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 28, 2014, 07:43:24 PM
Is it seen in the RoR where everything is hidden?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 29, 2014, 12:37:13 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
5. No, it is not used.
6. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, it is not seen in a classroom.
8. Yes, it is always in the same place.
9. Yes, it is seen inside the castle.
10. No, it is not seen in the great hall.
11. Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
12. No, it is not seen in a common room.
13. Yes, it is seen in the Room of Requirement.
14. Yes, it is seen in the RoR where everything is hidden.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 29, 2014, 05:15:08 PM
is this thing seen near the diadem of Ravenclaw ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 29, 2014, 09:44:33 PM
Is it the cupboard in which the book gets hidden? :reading:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 29, 2014, 10:11:36 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
5. No, it is not used.
6. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, it is not seen in a classroom.
8. Yes, it is always in the same place.
9. Yes, it is seen inside the castle.
10. No, it is not seen in the great hall.
11. Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
12. No, it is not seen in a common room.
13. Yes, it is seen in the Room of Requirement.
14. Yes, it is seen in the RoR where everything is hidden.
15. No, it is not seen near the diadem of Ravenclaw.
16. No, it is not in the cupboard in which the book gets hidden.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 30, 2014, 04:23:00 AM
is it the bird's cage ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 30, 2014, 07:30:34 AM
Is it Trelawney's empty bottles?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 30, 2014, 08:14:26 AM
is it bigger than a quaffle ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 30, 2014, 10:45:07 AM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
5. No, it is not used.
6. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, it is not seen in a classroom.
8. Yes, it is always in the same place.
9. Yes, it is seen inside the castle.
10. No, it is not seen in the great hall.
11. Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
12. No, it is not seen in a common room.
13. Yes, it is seen in the Room of Requirement.
14. Yes, it is seen in the RoR where everything is hidden.
15. No, it is not seen near the diadem of Ravenclaw.
16. No, it is not in the cupboard in which the book gets hidden.
17. No, it is not the bird cage.
18. No, it is not Trelawney's empty bottles.
19. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 30, 2014, 10:08:44 PM
Is it the chairs?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 30, 2014, 10:35:27 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
5. No, it is not used.
6. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, it is not seen in a classroom.
8. Yes, it is always in the same place.
9. Yes, it is seen inside the castle.
10. No, it is not seen in the great hall.
11. Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
12. No, it is not seen in a common room.
13. Yes, it is seen in the Room of Requirement.
14. Yes, it is seen in the RoR where everything is hidden.
15. No, it is not seen near the diadem of Ravenclaw.
16. No, it is not in the cupboard in which the book gets hidden.
17. No, it is not the bird cage.
18. No, it is not Trelawney's empty bottles.
19. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
20. No, it is not the chairs.
Hint: Remember it is seen in more that one book. Also "near" can be a matter of interpretation.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 31, 2014, 11:50:58 AM
Is it the pock-marked stone warlock?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 31, 2014, 07:59:03 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
5. No, it is not used.
6. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, it is not seen in a classroom.
8. Yes, it is always in the same place.
9. Yes, it is seen inside the castle.
10. No, it is not seen in the great hall.
11. Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
12. No, it is not seen in a common room.
13. Yes, it is seen in the Room of Requirement.
14. Yes, it is seen in the RoR where everything is hidden.
15. No, it is not seen near the diadem of Ravenclaw.
16. No, it is not in the cupboard in which the book gets hidden.
17. No, it is not the bird cage.
18. No, it is not Trelawney's empty bottles.
19. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
20. No, it is not the chairs.
Hint: Remember it is seen in more that one book. Also "near" can be a matter of interpretation.
21. No, it is not the pock-marked stone warlock (found "nearby" to and ended under the tiara so 15 would have been yes).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 01, 2015, 03:21:08 PM
Is it seen in DH before Crabbe uses Fiendfyre?

Happy New Year, by the way! :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 01, 2015, 07:48:36 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
5. No, it is not used.
6. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, it is not seen in a classroom.
8. Yes, it is always in the same place.
9. Yes, it is seen inside the castle.
10. No, it is not seen in the great hall.
11. Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
12. No, it is not seen in a common room.
13. Yes, it is seen in the Room of Requirement.
14. Yes, it is seen in the RoR where everything is hidden.
15. No, it is not seen near the diadem of Ravenclaw.
16. No, it is not in the cupboard in which the book gets hidden.
17. No, it is not the bird cage.
18. No, it is not Trelawney's empty bottles.
19. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
20. No, it is not the chairs.
Hint: Remember it is seen in more that one book. Also "near" can be a matter of interpretation.
21. No, it is not the pock-marked stone warlock (found "nearby" to and ended under the tiara so 15 would have been yes).
22. Yes, in DH it is seen before Crabbe uses Fiendfyre.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 02, 2015, 03:21:58 PM
Is it, in DH, seen before Crabbe. Goyle and Malfoy try to corner Harry?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 02, 2015, 11:59:36 PM
I am thinking of a thing.

1. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. No, it is not owned by someone specific.
4. No, it is not seen in a place where there are more Muggles than magical folks.
5. No, it is not used.
6. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
7. No, it is not seen in a classroom.
8. Yes, it is always in the same place.
9. Yes, it is seen inside the castle.
10. No, it is not seen in the great hall.
11. Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
12. No, it is not seen in a common room.
13. Yes, it is seen in the Room of Requirement.
14. Yes, it is seen in the RoR where everything is hidden.
15. No, it is not seen near the diadem of Ravenclaw.
16. No, it is not in the cupboard in which the book gets hidden.
17. No, it is not the bird cage.
18. No, it is not Trelawney's empty bottles.
19. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
20. No, it is not the chairs.
Hint: Remember it is seen in more that one book. Also "near" can be a matter of interpretation.
21. No, it is not the pock-marked stone warlock (found "nearby" to and ended under the tiara so 15 would have been yes).
22. Yes, in DH it is seen before Crabbe uses Fiendfyre.
23. Yes, in DH it is seen before Crabbe, Goyle and Malfoy try to corner Harry.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 03, 2015, 03:02:45 PM
Is it the stuffed troll?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 03, 2015, 03:11:23 PM
Is it the stuffed troll?
Yes it is. I decided it was far enough away from the diadem not to count as "near", particularly as Harry needed to search for the diadem/HBP book cupboard from the vanishing cabinet corner when he returned in DH.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 03, 2015, 08:36:24 PM
Is it the stuffed troll?
Yes it is. I decided it was far enough away from the diadem not to count as "near", particularly as Harry needed to search for the diadem/HBP book cupboard from the vanishing cabinet corner when he returned in DH.
I agree that it isn't near it.   :) Thanks for a fun round!  :thumbup:


I'm thinking of a person....
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 04, 2015, 01:33:20 AM
is the person magical ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 04, 2015, 10:31:04 AM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are magical.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 04, 2015, 04:21:55 PM
Is the person in any of the first three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 04, 2015, 06:37:01 PM
is the person a witch ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 04, 2015, 10:53:49 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are magical.
2) No, they are not in any of the first three books.
3) No, they are not a witch.    :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 05, 2015, 08:03:44 AM
are they seen ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 05, 2015, 05:40:31 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are magical.
2) No, they are not in any of the first three books.
3) No, they are not a witch.    :)
4) Yes, he is seen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 05, 2015, 10:05:21 PM
Is he in any of books four or five?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 06, 2015, 05:13:05 AM
is he seen at Hogwarts ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on January 06, 2015, 07:39:57 AM
Is he a student?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 06, 2015, 10:00:42 AM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are magical.
2) No, they are not in any of the first three books.
3) No, they are not a witch.    :)
4) Yes, he is seen.
5) Yes he is in books 4 and/or book 5.
6) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
7) No, he is not a student.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 06, 2015, 08:20:11 PM
Is he in book 4?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 06, 2015, 08:33:05 PM
do we see him in any place in London ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 06, 2015, 09:21:02 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are magical.
2) No, they are not in any of the first three books.
3) No, they are not a witch.    :)
4) Yes, he is seen.
5) Yes he is in books 4 and/or book 5.
6) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
7) No, he is not a student.
8 ) Yes, we see him in GOF.
9) No, we do not see him anywhere in London.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 06, 2015, 09:58:18 PM
Is he seen at the Quidditch World Cup?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 06, 2015, 10:49:40 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are magical.
2) No, they are not in any of the first three books.
3) No, they are not a witch.    :)
4) Yes, he is seen.
5) Yes he is in books 4 and/or book 5.
6) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
7) No, he is not a student.
8 ) Yes, we see him in GOF.
9) No, we do not see him anywhere in London.
10) Yes, he is seen at the Quidditch World Cup.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 07, 2015, 04:33:58 AM
is he seen during the Quidditch Match between Bulgaria and Irleland  ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 07, 2015, 08:42:51 AM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are magical.
2) No, they are not in any of the first three books.
3) No, they are not a witch.    :)
4) Yes, he is seen.
5) Yes he is in books 4 and/or book 5.
6) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
7) No, he is not a student.
8 ) Yes, we see him in GOF.
9) No, we do not see him anywhere in London.
10) Yes, he is seen at the Quidditch World Cup.
11) No, he is not seen during the Quidditch Match between Bulgaria and Irleland.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 07, 2015, 04:57:25 PM
is he seen during the time the trio goes for water ?  (the time they leave the tent and come back again)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 08, 2015, 01:39:04 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are magical.
2) No, they are not in any of the first three books.
3) No, they are not a witch.    :)
4) Yes, he is seen.
5) Yes he is in books 4 and/or book 5.
6) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
7) No, he is not a student.
8 ) Yes, we see him in GOF.
9) No, we do not see him anywhere in London.
10) Yes, he is seen at the Quidditch World Cup.
11) No, he is not seen during the Quidditch Match between Bulgaria and Irleland.
12) Yes, he is seen while they are away from the tent to go for water.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 09, 2015, 04:35:57 PM
is he seen at the place where they take water ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 10, 2015, 07:43:53 AM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are magical.
2) No, they are not in any of the first three books.
3) No, they are not a witch.    :)
4) Yes, he is seen.
5) Yes he is in books 4 and/or book 5.
6) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
7) No, he is not a student.
8 ) Yes, we see him in GOF.
9) No, we do not see him anywhere in London.
10) Yes, he is seen at the Quidditch World Cup.
11) No, he is not seen during the Quidditch Match between Bulgaria and Irleland.
12) Yes, he is seen while they are away from the tent to go for water.
13) Yes, he is seen at the place where they take water.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 13, 2015, 09:47:35 PM
Is it the Ministry Wizard trying to persuade Archie to wear trousers?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 14, 2015, 09:16:38 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are magical.
2) No, they are not in any of the first three books.
3) No, they are not a witch.    :)
4) Yes, he is seen.
5) Yes he is in books 4 and/or book 5.
6) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
7) No, he is not a student.
8 ) Yes, we see him in GOF.
9) No, we do not see him anywhere in London.
10) Yes, he is seen at the Quidditch World Cup.
11) No, he is not seen during the Quidditch Match between Bulgaria and Irleland.
12) Yes, he is seen while they are away from the tent to go for water.
13) Yes, he is seen at the place where they take water.
14) No, it is not the Ministry Wizard trying to persuade Archie to wear trousers.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 19, 2015, 07:11:00 AM
is it Archie himself ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 19, 2015, 06:01:47 PM
is it Archie himself ?
Yes! It is Archie himself!  :stars: Your turn!
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 19, 2015, 08:10:11 PM
thx Evreka, I love Archie, he is fun  ;D


I am thinking of a thing ....
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 19, 2015, 09:03:23 PM
Does it have magical powers?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 19, 2015, 11:27:14 PM
I am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 22, 2015, 10:07:52 PM
Is it seen?  :madeye:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 22, 2015, 10:30:18 PM
Is it in the first four books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 23, 2015, 01:52:47 AM
I am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 23, 2015, 07:45:01 PM
Is it in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 23, 2015, 08:18:56 PM
Is it in the first two books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 24, 2015, 05:12:04 PM
I am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 24, 2015, 10:54:07 PM
Is it in Book 3?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 25, 2015, 02:47:39 AM
I am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 25, 2015, 05:24:23 AM
Is it owned?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 25, 2015, 08:04:49 AM
I am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 25, 2015, 12:31:54 PM
Is it owned by a student who is studying at Hogwarts during the PoA year?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 25, 2015, 09:38:49 PM
Is it owned by either a Muggle or a Squib?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 25, 2015, 10:51:19 PM
Is it owned by either a Muggle or a Squid?
As the Giant Squid doesn't own anything as far as we know, can we assume you meant a Squib?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 26, 2015, 03:14:48 AM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 26, 2015, 07:05:02 PM
Is it owned by either a Muggle or a Squid?
As the Giant Squid doesn't own anything as far as we know, can we assume you meant a Squib?
:lol:  :lol: ROFL, Yes, I did mean Squib. 

Is it seen at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 26, 2015, 09:15:15 PM
Is it seen at a magical location outside Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 27, 2015, 06:55:37 AM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 27, 2015, 06:32:43 PM
Is it owned by a witch?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 27, 2015, 08:46:11 PM
Do we see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 28, 2015, 04:59:14 AM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
12) no,  its not owned by a witch
13) yes, we do see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 28, 2015, 05:03:13 AM
Is it bigger than a Quaffle?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 28, 2015, 06:49:48 AM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
12) no,  its not owned by a witch
13) yes, we do see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA
14) no, I dont think its bigger than a Quaffle
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on January 28, 2015, 03:50:36 PM
Is it owned by a Hogwarts professor?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 28, 2015, 05:34:24 PM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
12) no,  its not owned by a witch
13) yes, we do see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA
14) no, I dont think its bigger than a Quaffle
15) yes, it is owned by a Hogwarts Professor
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 28, 2015, 08:08:10 PM
Is it owned by a Professor that the trio has had classes for in any of the first TWO books (before POA)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 28, 2015, 09:39:13 PM
Is it seen in a classroom?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 29, 2015, 07:52:57 AM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
12) no,  its not owned by a witch
13) yes, we do see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA
14) no, I dont think its bigger than a Quaffle
15) yes, it is owned by a Hogwarts Professor
16)  no, it is not owned by a Professor that the trio has had classes for in any of the first TWO books (before POA)
17) no, it is not seen in a classroom
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 29, 2015, 06:30:05 PM
Is it owned by Lupin?  :lupin:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 29, 2015, 09:19:59 PM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
12) no,  its not owned by a witch
13) yes, we do see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA
14) no, I dont think its bigger than a Quaffle
15) yes, it is owned by a Hogwarts Professor
16)  no, it is not owned by a Professor that the trio has had classes for in any of the first TWO books (before POA)
17) no, it is not seen in a classroom
18) yes, it is owned by Lupin
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 30, 2015, 09:34:10 PM
Is it food or drink, including any wrappers or containers?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 31, 2015, 07:18:57 PM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
12) no,  its not owned by a witch
13) yes, we do see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA
14) no, I dont think its bigger than a Quaffle
15) yes, it is owned by a Hogwarts Professor
16)  no, it is not owned by a Professor that the trio has had classes for in any of the first TWO books (before POA)
17) no, it is not seen in a classroom
18) yes, it is owned by Lupin
19) yes,Is it food or drink, including any wrappers or containers
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 31, 2015, 07:32:07 PM
Is it the choccolate he offers Harry on the Hogwarts Express to Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on January 31, 2015, 11:20:43 PM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
12) no,  its not owned by a witch
13) yes, we do see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA
14) no, I dont think its bigger than a Quaffle
15) yes, it is owned by a Hogwarts Professor
16)  no, it is not owned by a Professor that the trio has had classes for in any of the first TWO books (before POA)
17) no, it is not seen in a classroom
18) yes, it is owned by Lupin
19) yes,Is it food or drink, including any wrappers or containers
20) no its not chocolate
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 01, 2015, 06:03:09 AM
Is it the Butterbeer he shares with Harry in school at some point?  :harryronbb:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 01, 2015, 07:20:01 PM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
12) no,  its not owned by a witch
13) yes, we do see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA
14) no, I dont think its bigger than a Quaffle
15) yes, it is owned by a Hogwarts Professor
16)  no, it is not owned by a Professor that the trio has had classes for in any of the first TWO books (before POA)
17) no, it is not seen in a classroom
18) yes, it is owned by Lupin
19) yes,Is it food or drink, including any wrappers or containers
20) no its not chocolate

21) its not the butterbeer

hint: its no food or drink
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 01, 2015, 11:52:42 PM
Is it seen on Harry's visit to Lupin's office on Halloween when Ron and Hermione are in Hogsmeade?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 02, 2015, 07:11:08 AM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
12) no,  its not owned by a witch
13) yes, we do see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA
14) no, I dont think its bigger than a Quaffle
15) yes, it is owned by a Hogwarts Professor
16)  no, it is not owned by a Professor that the trio has had classes for in any of the first TWO books (before POA)
17) no, it is not seen in a classroom
18) yes, it is owned by Lupin
19) yes,Is it food or drink, including any wrappers or containers
20) no its not chocolate

21) its not the butterbeer
22) yes, it is seen on Harry's visit to Lupin's office on Halloween when Ron and Hermione are in Hogsmeade

hint: its no food or drink
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 02, 2015, 07:19:41 PM
Is it the chipped mug that Harry drinks tea from?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 02, 2015, 08:22:41 PM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
12) no,  its not owned by a witch
13) yes, we do see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA
14) no, I dont think its bigger than a Quaffle
15) yes, it is owned by a Hogwarts Professor
16)  no, it is not owned by a Professor that the trio has had classes for in any of the first TWO books (before POA)
17) no, it is not seen in a classroom
18) yes, it is owned by Lupin
19) yes,Is it food or drink, including any wrappers or containers
20) no its not chocolate

21) its not the butterbeer
22) yes, it is seen on Harry's visit to Lupin's office on Halloween when Ron and Hermione are in Hogsmeade
23) no,  it's not the chipped mug that Harry drinks tea from

hint: its no food or drink
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 02, 2015, 09:09:58 PM
Is it seen when Lupin is alone with Harry?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 02, 2015, 09:20:22 PM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
12) no,  its not owned by a witch
13) yes, we do see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA
14) no, I dont think its bigger than a Quaffle
15) yes, it is owned by a Hogwarts Professor
16)  no, it is not owned by a Professor that the trio has had classes for in any of the first TWO books (before POA)
17) no, it is not seen in a classroom
18) yes, it is owned by Lupin
19) yes,Is it food or drink, including any wrappers or containers
20) no its not chocolate

21) its not the butterbeer
22) yes, it is seen on Harry's visit to Lupin's office on Halloween when Ron and Hermione are in Hogsmeade
23) no,  it's not the chipped mug that Harry drinks tea from
24) yes, it is seen when Harry and Lupin are alone together, but it might have been seen by another person also, during the time they share togehter (dont know how to answer this propperly)

hint: its no food or drink
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 02, 2015, 11:19:00 PM
Does it contain tea?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 03, 2015, 05:39:07 AM
I  am thinking of a thing

1) no, it has no magical power
2) yes, it is seen
3) yes, it is in the first four books
4) no,its not in more than one book
5) no, its not in the first two books
6) yes, it is in book 3
7) yes, it is owned
8-) its not owned by a student studying at Hogwarts in PoA
9) its not owned by a muggle or squib
10) yes, it is seen at Hogwarts

11) no it's not seen outside Hogwarts
12) no,  its not owned by a witch
13) yes, we do see it at or before the Christmas meal of 13 in PoA
14) no, I dont think its bigger than a Quaffle
15) yes, it is owned by a Hogwarts Professor
16)  no, it is not owned by a Professor that the trio has had classes for in any of the first TWO books (before POA)
17) no, it is not seen in a classroom
18) yes, it is owned by Lupin
19) yes,Is it food or drink, including any wrappers or containers
20) no its not chocolate

21) its not the butterbeer
22) yes, it is seen on Harry's visit to Lupin's office on Halloween when Ron and Hermione are in Hogsmeade
23) no,  it's not the chipped mug that Harry drinks tea from
24) yes, it is seen when Harry and Lupin are alone together, but it might have been seen by another person also, during the time they share togehter (dont know how to answer this propperly)
25) yes, it does contain tea

hint: its no food or drink
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 03, 2015, 08:21:16 PM
Is it the kettle he boils tea in?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 03, 2015, 09:32:06 PM
Is it the dusty tin of tea?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 04, 2015, 06:31:24 AM
Is it the kettle he boils tea in?


yes, it is,  your turn Evreka :)

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 04, 2015, 08:24:46 PM
 :stars:  Great round, Eva Hedwig!

I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 05, 2015, 07:26:25 AM
is it magical ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 06, 2015, 04:38:41 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 06, 2015, 07:35:01 PM
Is it in the first four books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 06, 2015, 08:37:12 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on February 06, 2015, 09:56:42 PM
Does it belong to someone specific?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 07, 2015, 12:28:32 AM
Is it in book 5?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 07, 2015, 06:40:44 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
4) Yes, it is in OOP.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 08, 2015, 02:54:12 AM
is it used ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 08, 2015, 08:10:53 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
4) Yes, it is in OOP.
5) well, yes, you could say that it is used ...
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 08, 2015, 01:50:47 PM
Is it in OotP before the point that Harry enters Hogwarts castle?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 08, 2015, 07:35:46 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
4) Yes, it is in OOP.
5) Well, yes, you could say that it is used ...
6) Yes, it is in OotP before the point that Harry enters Hogwarts castle.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 09, 2015, 08:44:00 AM
is the owner female ?

  ( I think that we can agree that someone is the onwer of a thing if it is described as "his" or "her" within a context. )
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 09, 2015, 01:13:39 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
4) Yes, it is in OOP.
5) Well, yes, you could say that it is used ...
6) Yes, it is in OotP before the point that Harry enters Hogwarts castle.
7) Well.... no, if we claim the owner to be specific, see 3), then the owner is not female...  ::)


( I think that we can agree that someone is the onwer of a thing if it is described as "his" or "her" within a context. )
I think we are in agreement over this? For this particular thing it is still debatable. And why and how I can't explain without giving it away.

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 09, 2015, 06:36:10 PM
Is it in 12 Grimmauld Place?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 09, 2015, 09:06:44 PM
is it seen ?





ok, once the thing is known to all, we can argue about the "owner's issue"  8)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on February 10, 2015, 07:56:34 PM
Is it bigger than a Quaffle?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 10, 2015, 08:19:09 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
4) Yes, it is in OOP.
5) Well, yes, you could say that it is used ...
6) Yes, it is in OotP before the point that Harry enters Hogwarts castle.
7) Well.... no, if we claim the owner to be specific, see 3), then the owner is not female...  ::)
8 ) Well, yes in a way, I think it is likely to have been at 12 Grimmauld Place at some point...  ::)  [Sorry, I wasn't considering these questions ahead of time....]
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle, at least not in all directions.


( I think that we can agree that someone is the onwer of a thing if it is described as "his" or "her" within a context. )
I think we are in agreement over this? For this particular thing it is still debatable. And why and how I can't explain without giving it away.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 11, 2015, 12:30:58 AM
Is the debatable owner a member of the Order of the Phoenix in Book 5?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 11, 2015, 07:22:40 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
4) Yes, it is in OOP.
5) Well, yes, you could say that it is used ...
6) Yes, it is in OotP before the point that Harry enters Hogwarts castle.
7) Well.... no, if we claim the owner to be specific, see 3), then the owner is not female...  ::)
8 ) Well, yes in a way, I think it is likely to have been at 12 Grimmauld Place at some point...  ::)  [Sorry, I wasn't considering these questions ahead of time....]
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle, at least not in all directions.
11) No, the debatable owner is not a member of the Order of the Phoenix in OOP.


( I think that we can agree that someone is the onwer of a thing if it is described as "his" or "her" within a context. )
I think we are in agreement over this? For this particular thing it is still debatable. And why and how I can't explain without giving it away.

OK, this has become so obscure that I think I better give an early hint: This is not a unique thing.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 13, 2015, 05:46:00 PM
has this thing something written on it ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 13, 2015, 09:28:38 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
4) Yes, it is in OOP.
5) Well, yes, you could say that it is used ...
6) Yes, it is in OotP before the point that Harry enters Hogwarts castle.
7) Well.... no, if we claim the owner to be specific, see 3), then the owner is not female...  ::)
8 ) Well, yes in a way, I think it is likely to have been at 12 Grimmauld Place at some point...  ::)  [Sorry, I wasn't considering these questions ahead of time....]
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle, at least not in all directions.
11) No, the debatable owner is not a member of the Order of the Phoenix in OOP.


( I think that we can agree that someone is the onwer of a thing if it is described as "his" or "her" within a context. )
I think we are in agreement over this? For this particular thing it is still debatable. And why and how I can't explain without giving it away.

OK, this has become so obscure that I think I better give an early hint: This is not a unique thing.

12) Yes, this thing has something written on it.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 14, 2015, 04:57:11 PM
Is the object a book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 14, 2015, 06:15:17 PM
is it seen at Hogwarts ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 14, 2015, 07:01:07 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
4) Yes, it is in OOP.
5) Well, yes, you could say that it is used ...
6) Yes, it is in OotP before the point that Harry enters Hogwarts castle.
7) Well.... no, if we claim the owner to be specific, see 3), then the owner is not female...  ::)
8 ) Well, yes in a way, I think it is likely to have been at 12 Grimmauld Place at some point...  ::) There are indices for this in the story, but as far as I am aware of, it is never stated as a fact. [Sorry, I wasn't considering these questions ahead of time....]
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle, at least not in all directions.
11) No, the debatable owner is not a member of the Order of the Phoenix in OOP.


( I think that we can agree that someone is the onwer of a thing if it is described as "his" or "her" within a context. )
I think we are in agreement over this? For this particular thing it is still debatable. And why and how I can't explain without giving it away.

OK, this has become so obscure that I think I better give an early hint: This is not a unique thing.

12) Yes, this thing has something written on it.
13) No, the object is not a book.
14) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.

Please revisit Answer 8.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 15, 2015, 08:18:44 AM
is it seen in the Gryffindor Common Room ? 
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 15, 2015, 09:05:15 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
4) Yes, it is in OOP.
5) Well, yes, you could say that it is used ...
6) Yes, it is in OotP before the point that Harry enters Hogwarts castle.
7) Well.... no, if we claim the owner to be specific, see 3), then the owner is not female...  ::)
8 ) Well, yes in a way, I think it is likely to have been at 12 Grimmauld Place at some point...  ::) There are indices for this in the story, but as far as I am aware of, it is never stated as a fact. [Sorry, I wasn't considering these questions ahead of time....]
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle, at least not in all directions.
11) No, the debatable owner is not a member of the Order of the Phoenix in OOP.


( I think that we can agree that someone is the onwer of a thing if it is described as "his" or "her" within a context. )
I think we are in agreement over this? For this particular thing it is still debatable. And why and how I can't explain without giving it away.

OK, this has become so obscure that I think I better give an early hint: This is not a unique thing.

12) Yes, this thing has something written on it.
13) No, the object is not a book.
14) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.

Please revisit Answer 8.
15) Yes, (at least a part of) it is seen in Gryffindor Common Room.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 15, 2015, 04:17:55 PM
Is it a Weasleys’ Wizard Wheezes product?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 15, 2015, 07:24:05 PM
do we see it in the cr before christmas ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 15, 2015, 09:49:31 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
4) Yes, it is in OOP.
5) Well, yes, you could say that it is used ...
6) Yes, it is in OotP before the point that Harry enters Hogwarts castle.
7) Well.... no, if we claim the owner to be specific, see 3), then the owner is not female...  ::)
8 ) Well, yes in a way, I think it is likely to have been at 12 Grimmauld Place at some point...  ::) There are indices for this in the story, but as far as I am aware of, it is never stated as a fact. [Sorry, I wasn't considering these questions ahead of time....]
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle, at least not in all directions.
11) No, the debatable owner is not a member of the Order of the Phoenix in OOP.


( I think that we can agree that someone is the onwer of a thing if it is described as "his" or "her" within a context. )
I think we are in agreement over this? For this particular thing it is still debatable. And why and how I can't explain without giving it away.

OK, this has become so obscure that I think I better give an early hint: This is not a unique thing.

12) Yes, this thing has something written on it.
13) No, the object is not a book.
14) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.

Please revisit Answer 8.
15) Yes, (at least a part of) it is seen in Gryffindor Common Room.
16) No, it is not a WWW product.
17) No, it is not seen in Gryffindor Common Room before Christmas in OOP.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on February 20, 2015, 04:40:10 AM
is it seen in the cr before the easter vacations ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 20, 2015, 10:19:13 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
4) Yes, it is in OOP.
5) Well, yes, you could say that it is used ...
6) Yes, it is in OotP before the point that Harry enters Hogwarts castle.
7) Well.... no, if we claim the owner to be specific, see 3), then the owner is not female...  ::)
8 ) Well, yes in a way, I think it is likely to have been at 12 Grimmauld Place at some point...  ::) There are indices for this in the story, but as far as I am aware of, it is never stated as a fact. [Sorry, I wasn't considering these questions ahead of time....]
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle, at least not in all directions.
11) No, the debatable owner is not a member of the Order of the Phoenix in OOP.


( I think that we can agree that someone is the onwer of a thing if it is described as "his" or "her" within a context. )
I think we are in agreement over this? For this particular thing it is still debatable. And why and how I can't explain without giving it away.

OK, this has become so obscure that I think I better give an early hint: This is not a unique thing.

12) Yes, this thing has something written on it.
13) No, the object is not a book.
14) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.

Please revisit Answer 8.
15) Yes, (at least a part of) it is seen in Gryffindor Common Room.
16) No, it is not a WWW product.
17) No, it is not seen in Gryffindor Common Room before Christmas in OOP.
18) Yes, it is seen in Gryffindor Common Room before Easter in OOP.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 21, 2015, 03:17:37 PM
Is it a newspaper or other publication?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 22, 2015, 12:12:52 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....  :hmm:

1) No, it is not magical.
2) No, it is not in the first four books.
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
4) Yes, it is in OOP.
5) Well, yes, you could say that it is used ...
6) Yes, it is in OotP before the point that Harry enters Hogwarts castle.
7) Well.... no, if we claim the owner to be specific, see 3), then the owner is not female...  ::)
8 ) Well, yes in a way, I think it is likely to have been at 12 Grimmauld Place at some point...  ::) There are indices for this in the story, but as far as I am aware of, it is never stated as a fact. [Sorry, I wasn't considering these questions ahead of time....]
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle, at least not in all directions.
11) No, the debatable owner is not a member of the Order of the Phoenix in OOP.


( I think that we can agree that someone is the onwer of a thing if it is described as "his" or "her" within a context. )
I think we are in agreement over this? For this particular thing it is still debatable. And why and how I can't explain without giving it away.

OK, this has become so obscure that I think I better give an early hint: This is not a unique thing.

12) Yes, this thing has something written on it.
13) No, the object is not a book.
14) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.

Please revisit Answer 8.
15) Yes, (at least a part of) it is seen in Gryffindor Common Room.
16) No, it is not a WWW product.
17) No, it is not seen in Gryffindor Common Room before Christmas in OOP.
18) Yes, it is seen in Gryffindor Common Room before Easter in OOP.
19) YES, it is a newspaper or other publication.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 28, 2015, 12:36:49 PM
Is it The Quibbler?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 01, 2015, 07:04:41 PM
Is it The Quibbler?
YES, it is The Quibbler!  :lunaquibbler: :lunaquibbler: :lunaquibbler: Congratulations!  :stars:


Some explanations...

1) No, it is not magical.
Unlike the films I haven't found any indication that The Quibbler's content or Titles switch around, so it seems completely unmagical to me.
 
3) Well... I guess you can say it belongs to someone specific... but it's debatable.
7) Well.... no, if we claim the owner to be specific, see 3), then the owner is not female...  ::)
11) No, the debatable owner is not a member of the Order of the Phoenix in OOP.
OK, this has become so obscure that I think I better give an early hint: This is not a unique thing.

The newspaper is, strictly speaking, owned by Xenophilius Lovegood. The various paper copies of each issue have all sorts of owners of course, and some issues even change owners (all, if we count the fact that they are sold in the first place). So, for ownership to have any real meaning, I thought we had to speak of it in terms of the owner of the paper itself (as opposed to a copy of it), ie Xeno. When I made this decision it felt like a simple thing, but as it progressed... it became more and more confusing with every owner question. Sorry 'bout tha'.  :hagrid:


5) Well, yes, you could say that it is used ...
Harry and Hermione uses it in a way to get Harry's true story out in OOP. Xeno, of course, uses it all the time to get his POV out...  ;)

6) Yes, it is in OotP before the point that Harry enters Hogwarts castle.
9) Yes, it is seen.
14) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
15) Yes, (at least a part of) it is seen in Gryffindor Common Room.
17) No, it is not seen in Gryffindor Common Room before Christmas in OOP.
18) Yes, it is seen in Gryffindor Common Room before Easter in OOP.

It is seen for the first time in the Ministry of Magic, right before Harry's Hearing is about to start.
Later it is seen in the Great Hall both when Luna is reading in it and when Harry's story comes out. In an aftermath of the article's publication, the Gryffindors post an enlarged front page in the Gryffindor Common Room.


8 ) Well, yes in a way, I think it is likely to have been at 12 Grimmauld Place at some point...  ::) There are indices for this in the story, but as far as I am aware of, it is never stated as a fact.
When Harry comes to the Ministry before his Hearing, Shacklebolt gives Arthur a copy and suggests that Sirius might be amused by it. It is reasonable to assume the paper is taken to 12 GP, but it's not mentioned any further (I think).


10) No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle, at least not in all directions.
I assume it might be larger when unfolded, but only in 2 dimensions, not 3.

 :whew:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 04, 2015, 08:02:40 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 04, 2015, 09:05:24 PM
Does it have any magical abilities?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 05, 2015, 12:13:18 AM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 05, 2015, 07:10:03 PM
Do we see it?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on March 05, 2015, 07:11:58 PM
Does it belong to someone specific?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 06, 2015, 12:22:48 AM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 06, 2015, 08:31:01 PM
Is it in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 06, 2015, 11:45:34 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 07, 2015, 10:38:19 AM
Is it in one of the last three?  :hermioneread:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on March 07, 2015, 03:49:09 PM
Does it belong to a student?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 07, 2015, 04:07:17 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 07, 2015, 10:03:25 PM
Is it in HBP?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 08, 2015, 12:20:47 AM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 08, 2015, 08:44:14 AM
Is it in DH?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 08, 2015, 10:14:48 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
8. Yes, it is in DH.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 09, 2015, 09:13:13 PM
Does it belong to any of the trio?  :trio:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 09, 2015, 11:55:24 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
8. Yes, it is in DH.
9. Yes, it does belong to one of the trio.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on March 10, 2015, 10:37:23 PM
does it belong to Hermione ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 11, 2015, 12:27:52 AM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
8. Yes, it is in DH.
9. Yes, it does belong to one of the trio.
10. Yes, it does belong to Hermione.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 11, 2015, 08:52:44 PM
Is it her rather special bag?  :mcgonagall2:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 11, 2015, 11:48:03 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
8. Yes, it is in DH.
9. Yes, it does belong to one of the trio.
10. Yes, it does belong to Hermione.
11. Yes, it is in Hermione's bag (some or all of the time).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 12, 2015, 09:59:27 PM
Is it one of the Potions?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 13, 2015, 12:39:49 AM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
8. Yes, it is in DH.
9. Yes, it does belong to one of the trio.
10. Yes, it does belong to Hermione.
11. Yes, it is in Hermione's bag (some or all of the time).
12. No, it is not one of the potions.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 13, 2015, 07:09:26 PM
Do we see it before the trio leaves the Burrow?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 14, 2015, 12:06:55 AM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
8. Yes, it is in DH.
9. Yes, it does belong to one of the trio.
10. Yes, it does belong to Hermione.
11. Yes, it is in Hermione's bag (some or all of the time).
12. No, it is not one of the potions.
13. No, we don't see it before the trio leave the Burrow.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 14, 2015, 03:32:20 PM
Is it seen before the camping expedition begins?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 16, 2015, 12:22:30 AM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
8. Yes, it is in DH.
9. Yes, it does belong to one of the trio.
10. Yes, it does belong to Hermione.
11. Yes, it is in Hermione's bag (some or all of the time).
12. No, it is not one of the potions.
13. No, we don't see it before the trio leave the Burrow.
14. Yes, it is seen before the camping expedition begins.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 16, 2015, 06:33:05 PM
Is it seen at Grimmauld Place 12?  :kreacher:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 16, 2015, 09:55:49 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
8. Yes, it is in DH.
9. Yes, it does belong to one of the trio.
10. Yes, it does belong to Hermione.
11. Yes, it is in Hermione's bag (some or all of the time).
12. No, it is not one of the potions.
13. No, we don't see it before the trio leave the Burrow.
14. Yes, it is seen before the camping expedition begins.
15. No, it is not seen at 12 Grimmauld Place.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 17, 2015, 07:35:34 PM
Is it seen or mentioned before the trio reaches Grimmauld Place after leaving the Burrow?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 18, 2015, 08:14:59 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
8. Yes, it is in DH.
9. Yes, it does belong to one of the trio.
10. Yes, it does belong to Hermione.
11. Yes, it is in Hermione's bag (some or all of the time).
12. No, it is not one of the potions.
13. No, we don't see it before the trio leave the Burrow.
14. Yes, it is seen before the camping expedition begins.
15. No, it is not seen at 12 Grimmauld Place.
16. No, it is not or mentioned seen before the trio reaches Grimmauld Place for the first time in DH.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 19, 2015, 08:30:13 PM
Is it one of the flasks that hold Polyjuice Potion and a piece of the person they change into?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 19, 2015, 11:58:13 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
8. Yes, it is in DH.
9. Yes, it does belong to one of the trio.
10. Yes, it does belong to Hermione.
11. Yes, it is in Hermione's bag (some or all of the time).
12. No, it is not one of the potions.
13. No, we don't see it before the trio leave the Burrow.
14. Yes, it is seen before the camping expedition begins.
15. No, it is not seen at 12 Grimmauld Place.
16. No, it is not mentioned or seen before the trio reaches Grimmauld Place for the first time in DH.
17. No, it is not polyjuice, polyjuice flasks, or pieces of people to use in polyjuice.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 20, 2015, 07:06:17 PM
Is it seen while they are inside the Ministry?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 20, 2015, 11:53:02 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
8. Yes, it is in DH.
9. Yes, it does belong to one of the trio.
10. Yes, it does belong to Hermione.
11. Yes, it is in Hermione's bag (some or all of the time).
12. No, it is not one of the potions.
13. No, we don't see it before the trio leave the Burrow.
14. Yes, it is seen before the camping expedition begins.
15. No, it is not seen at 12 Grimmauld Place.
16. No, it is not mentioned or seen before the trio reaches Grimmauld Place for the first time in DH.
17. No, it is not polyjuice, polyjuice flasks, or pieces of people to use in polyjuice.
18. No, it is not seen while they are inside the Ministry.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 21, 2015, 06:50:49 PM
Is it seen between leaving Grimmauld Place 12 and entering the Ministry?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 22, 2015, 11:54:35 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. Yes, it does have magical abilities.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, it does belong to someone specific.
4. No, it is not in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is in one of the last three [books].
6. Yes, it belongs to a student.
7. No, it is not in HBP.
8. Yes, it is in DH.
9. Yes, it does belong to one of the trio.
10. Yes, it does belong to Hermione.
11. Yes, it is in Hermione's bag (some or all of the time).
12. No, it is not one of the potions.
13. No, we don't see it before the trio leave the Burrow.
14. Yes, it is seen before the camping expedition begins.
15. No, it is not seen at 12 Grimmauld Place.
16. No, it is not mentioned or seen before the trio reaches Grimmauld Place for the first time in DH.
17. No, it is not polyjuice, polyjuice flasks, or pieces of people to use in polyjuice.
18. No, it is not seen while they are inside the Ministry.
19. No, it is not seen between leaving Grimmauld Place 12 and entering the Ministry.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on March 23, 2015, 07:26:20 PM
is it used  ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 23, 2015, 08:14:46 PM
Is it dittany, which is first seen when Ron Splinches himself?  :ron:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 24, 2015, 12:01:16 AM
Is it dittany, which is first seen when Ron Splinches himself?  :ron:
Yes, it is Hermione's bottle of dittany. I don't think it counts as a potion, because I see it as a potion ingredient (it is in One Thousand Magical Herbs and Fungi). I also decided the camping expedition started when they decided to stay in the Quidditch World Cup forest and got the tent out as before that they might still have decided to do something else; thus the bottle of dittany is seen just before the start of the camping expedition.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 24, 2015, 07:47:08 PM
Is it dittany, which is first seen when Ron Splinches himself?  :ron:
Yes, it is Hermione's bottle of dittany. I don't think it counts as a potion, because I see it as a potion ingredient (it is in One Thousand Magical Herbs and Fungi). I also decided the camping expedition started when they decided to stay in the Quidditch World Cup forest and got the tent out as before that they might still have decided to do something else; thus the bottle of dittany is seen just before the start of the camping expedition.
I was about to draw the conclusion that something was off, when I realised there was a small, small span of time left open!  :) Fun round!


I'm thinking of a person...
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 25, 2015, 10:15:00 PM
Is the person a muggle?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on March 26, 2015, 01:27:59 PM
Is the person female?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 26, 2015, 08:59:06 PM
I'm thinking of a person...

1) No, the person is not a Muggle.
2) No, the person is not female.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on March 27, 2015, 09:29:55 PM
Is he seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 28, 2015, 04:45:59 PM
Is he in the first 4 books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on March 29, 2015, 12:49:27 AM
is he a student ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 29, 2015, 02:02:24 PM
I'm thinking of a person...

1) No, the person is not a Muggle.
2) No, the person is not female.
3) Yes, he is seen.
4) No, he is not in the first four books.
5) No, he is not a student.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 29, 2015, 07:37:53 PM
Is he in book 5?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on March 29, 2015, 07:55:00 PM
is he seen at Hogwarts ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 30, 2015, 05:32:22 PM
I'm thinking of a person...

1) No, the person is not a Muggle.
2) No, the person is not female.
3) Yes, he is seen.
4) No, he is not in the first four books.
5) No, he is not a student.
6) Yes, he is in book 5.
7) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 31, 2015, 08:53:34 PM
Is he in book 5 before Harry arrives at the Ministry of Magic for his hearing?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 31, 2015, 10:03:13 PM
I'm thinking of a person...

1) No, the person is not a Muggle.
2) No, the person is not female.
3) Yes, he is seen.
4) No, he is not in the first four books.
5) No, he is not a student.
6) Yes, he is in book 5.
7) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
8 ) Yes, he is in OOP before Harry arrives at the Ministry of Magic for his hearing.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on April 03, 2015, 06:50:29 PM
Is he a member of the Order of the Phoenix?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 03, 2015, 09:46:33 PM
I'm thinking of a person...

1) No, the person is not a Muggle.
2) No, the person is not female.
3) Yes, he is seen.
4) No, he is not in the first four books.
5) No, he is not a student.
6) Yes, he is in book 5.
7) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
8 ) Yes, he is in OOP before Harry arrives at the Ministry of Magic for his hearing.
9) No, he is not a member of Order of the Phoenix.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on April 06, 2015, 05:49:44 AM
does Harry speak to him ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 06, 2015, 12:16:19 PM
I'm thinking of a person...

1) No, the person is not a Muggle.
2) No, the person is not female.
3) Yes, he is seen.
4) No, he is not in the first four books.
5) No, he is not a student.
6) Yes, he is in book 5.
7) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
8 ) Yes, he is in OOP before Harry arrives at the Ministry of Magic for his hearing.
9) No, he is not a member of Order of the Phoenix.
10) No, Harry does not speak to him.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on April 06, 2015, 05:43:05 PM
is he seen in person ? 
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 06, 2015, 06:23:25 PM
I'm thinking of a person...

1) No, the person is not a Muggle.
2) No, the person is not female.
3) Yes, he is seen.
4) No, he is not in the first four books.
5) No, he is not a student.
6) Yes, he is in book 5.
7) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
8 ) Yes, he is in OOP before Harry arrives at the Ministry of Magic for his hearing.
9) No, he is not a member of Order of the Phoenix.
10) No, Harry does not speak to him.
11) No, he is not seen in person. (Well you DO see him as a person (as opposed to disguised as something else), but we don't meet him in flesh and blood.)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on April 06, 2015, 11:59:45 PM
is he seen on a picture ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 07, 2015, 08:50:41 PM
I'm thinking of a person...

1) No, the person is not a Muggle.
2) No, the person is not female.
3) Yes, he is seen.
4) No, he is not in the first four books.
5) No, he is not a student.
6) Yes, he is in book 5.
7) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
8 ) Yes, he is in OOP before Harry arrives at the Ministry of Magic for his hearing.
9) No, he is not a member of Order of the Phoenix.
10) No, Harry does not speak to him.
11) No, he is not seen in person. (Well you DO see him as a person (as opposed to disguised as something else), but we don't meet him in flesh and blood.)
12) Yes, he is seen in a picture.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on April 09, 2015, 06:40:30 AM
is he seen in a picture when Harry is inside GP 12 ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 09, 2015, 10:29:32 PM
I'm thinking of a person...

1) No, the person is not a Muggle.
2) No, the person is not female.
3) Yes, he is seen.
4) No, he is not in the first four books.
5) No, he is not a student.
6) Yes, he is in book 5.
7) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
8 ) Yes, he is in OOP before Harry arrives at the Ministry of Magic for his hearing.
9) No, he is not a member of Order of the Phoenix.
10) No, Harry does not speak to him.
11) No, he is not seen in person. (Well you DO see him as a person (as opposed to disguised as something else), but we don't meet him in flesh and blood.)
12) Yes, he is seen in a picture.
13) Yes, he is seen in a picture when Harry is inside GP 12. :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on April 10, 2015, 12:22:41 AM
is this picture seen in the kitchen ?    ( I mean someone looking at it in the kitchen)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 10, 2015, 07:15:08 PM
I'm thinking of a person...

1) No, the person is not a Muggle.
2) No, the person is not female.
3) Yes, he is seen.
4) No, he is not in the first four books.
5) No, he is not a student.
6) Yes, he is in book 5.
7) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
8 ) Yes, he is in OOP before Harry arrives at the Ministry of Magic for his hearing.
9) No, he is not a member of Order of the Phoenix.
10) No, Harry does not speak to him.
11) No, he is not seen in person. (Well you DO see him as a person (as opposed to disguised as something else), but we don't meet him in flesh and blood.)
12) Yes, he is seen in a picture.
13) Yes, he is seen in a picture when Harry is inside GP 12. :)
14) No, the photo is not seen or looked at in the kitchen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on April 11, 2015, 06:52:53 PM
Is he on The Noble and Most Ancient House of Black tapestry?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Armoracia on April 11, 2015, 11:34:58 PM
is he in the bedroom that Ron and Harry share?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on April 12, 2015, 01:26:36 AM
is he only seen once ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 12, 2015, 03:17:00 PM
I'm thinking of a person...

1) No, the person is not a Muggle.
2) No, the person is not female.
3) Yes, he is seen.
4) No, he is not in the first four books.
5) No, he is not a student.
6) Yes, he is in book 5.
7) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
8 ) Yes, he is in OOP before Harry arrives at the Ministry of Magic for his hearing.
9) No, he is not a member of Order of the Phoenix.
10) No, Harry does not speak to him.
11) No, he is not seen in person. (Well you DO see him as a person (as opposed to disguised as something else), but we don't meet him in flesh and blood.)
12) Yes, he is seen in a picture.
13) Yes, he is seen in a picture when Harry is inside GP 12. :)
14) No, the photo is not seen or looked at in the kitchen.
15) Yes, he is on The Noble and Most Ancient House of Black tapestry.
16) No, as far as I remember he is never mentioned or seen in the room in which Harry and Ron sleep in OOP.
17) Yes, I believe that he is only seen once.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on April 13, 2015, 02:28:10 AM
is he Sirius's father ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 13, 2015, 08:35:47 PM
I'm thinking of a person...

1) No, the person is not a Muggle.
2) No, the person is not female.
3) Yes, he is seen.
4) No, he is not in the first four books.
5) No, he is not a student.
6) Yes, he is in book 5.
7) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.
8 ) Yes, he is in OOP before Harry arrives at the Ministry of Magic for his hearing.
9) No, he is not a member of Order of the Phoenix.
10) No, Harry does not speak to him.
11) No, he is not seen in person. (Well you DO see him as a person (as opposed to disguised as something else), but we don't meet him in flesh and blood.)
12) Yes, he is seen in a picture.
13) Yes, he is seen in a picture when Harry is inside GP 12. :)
14) No, the photo is not seen or looked at in the kitchen.
15) Yes, he is on The Noble and Most Ancient House of Black tapestry.
16) No, as far as I remember he is never mentioned or seen in the room in which Harry and Ron sleep in OOP.
17) Yes, I believe that he is only seen once.
18) No, he is not Sirius' father.

Early hint: There is a difference between being "in" a scene, place or book and being seen there...  ;)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on April 21, 2015, 10:05:19 PM
Is it RAB?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 24, 2015, 08:49:13 PM
Is it RAB?
Yes, it's Regulus! :slytherinc:

Congratulation, roonwit!

Some explanations
Regulus is, as far as I know, only seen once, in DH, when Harry is in Regulus old room. There is a photo on the wall, of the quidditch team he played in, while at hogwarts. Harry realises he played Seeker from the position he has in the photo.

6) Yes, he is in book 5.
8 ) Yes, he is in OOP before Harry arrives at the Ministry of Magic for his hearing.

He is mentioned when Harry and Sirius look at the Black Tapestry, which in the book does not seem to show faces, just names.


5) No, he is not a student.
7) No, he is not seen at Hogwarts.

I figured you meant during the time when Harry, roughly, is a student. Otherwise some 95% of the witches and wizards are all students at Hogwarts, at some point in the history or future.

I tried to find all places in which he was mentioned or referred to, but I guess I might have missed some?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on April 27, 2015, 09:57:53 PM
I am thinking of a place.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on April 28, 2015, 05:17:55 PM
is this place in the wizards world ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 28, 2015, 09:26:04 PM
Do we see it?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on April 28, 2015, 10:09:54 PM
1. No, the place is not in the wizards world.
2. Yes, we see it.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 29, 2015, 09:19:00 PM
Has Harry ever been there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on April 29, 2015, 11:44:58 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, the place is not in the wizards world.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, Harry has has been there.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 30, 2015, 08:57:49 PM
Have at least one of Ron and Hermione been there too?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on April 30, 2015, 09:23:18 PM
Is this place seen in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 01, 2015, 12:00:10 AM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, the place is not in the wizards world.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, Harry has has been there.
4. Yes, at least one of Ron and Hermione has been there too.
5. No, this place is not seen in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 01, 2015, 06:13:00 PM
Have both Hermione and Ron been there?  :ronhermionehug:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 01, 2015, 11:40:25 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, the place is not in the wizards world.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, Harry has has been there.
4. Yes, at least one of Ron and Hermione has been there too.
5. No, this place is not seen in more than one book.
6. Yes, both Hermione and Ron have been there.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 02, 2015, 10:15:35 PM
Is it seen in DH?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 02, 2015, 11:35:47 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, the place is not in the wizards world.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, Harry has has been there.
4. Yes, at least one of Ron and Hermione has been there too.
5. No, this place is not seen in more than one book.
6. Yes, both Hermione and Ron have been there.
7. Yes, it is seen in DH.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 03, 2015, 07:48:33 PM
Is it seen before Ron leaves the other two in an outburst of anger?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 04, 2015, 12:11:26 AM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, the place is not in the wizards world.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, Harry has has been there.
4. Yes, at least one of Ron and Hermione has been there too.
5. No, this place is not seen in more than one book.
6. Yes, both Hermione and Ron have been there.
7. Yes, it is seen in DH.
8. No, it is not seen before Ron leaves the other two in an outburst of anger.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 04, 2015, 01:52:43 PM
is this place seen after their visit to Xeno Lovegood ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 04, 2015, 07:38:50 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, the place is not in the wizards world.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, Harry has has been there.
4. Yes, at least one of Ron and Hermione has been there too.
5. No, this place is not seen in more than one book.
6. Yes, both Hermione and Ron have been there.
7. Yes, it is seen in DH.
8. No, it is not seen before Ron leaves the other two in an outburst of anger.
9. No, the place is not seen after their visit to Xeno Lovegood.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 05, 2015, 08:53:29 PM
is this place in London ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 05, 2015, 11:53:28 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, the place is not in the wizards world.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, Harry has has been there.
4. Yes, at least one of Ron and Hermione has been there too.
5. No, this place is not seen in more than one book.
6. Yes, both Hermione and Ron have been there.
7. Yes, it is seen in DH.
8. No, it is not seen before Ron leaves the other two in an outburst of anger.
9. No, the place is not seen after their visit to Xeno Lovegood.
10. No, the place is not in London.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 06, 2015, 08:32:15 AM
do they see this place on the way to Xeno's House ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on May 06, 2015, 08:49:55 PM
Is it the Forest of Dean?  :snape:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 06, 2015, 11:20:45 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, the place is not in the wizards world.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, Harry has has been there.
4. Yes, at least one of Ron and Hermione has been there too.
5. No, this place is not seen in more than one book.
6. Yes, both Hermione and Ron have been there.
7. Yes, it is seen in DH.
8. No, it is not seen before Ron leaves the other two in an outburst of anger.
9. No, the place is not seen after their visit to Xeno Lovegood.
10. No, the place is not in London.
11. No, they don't see this place on the way to Xeno's House.
12. No, it is not in the Forest of Dean.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 07, 2015, 09:51:59 PM
Is it seen before Ron returns?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 07, 2015, 10:06:59 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, the place is not in the wizards world.
2. Yes, we see it.
3. Yes, Harry has has been there.
4. Yes, at least one of Ron and Hermione has been there too.
5. No, this place is not seen in more than one book.
6. Yes, both Hermione and Ron have been there.
7. Yes, it is seen in DH.
8. No, it is not seen before Ron leaves the other two in an outburst of anger.
9. No, the place is not seen after their visit to Xeno Lovegood.
10. No, the place is not in London.
11. No, they don't see this place on the way to Xeno's House.
12. No, it is not in the Forest of Dean.
13. Yes, it is seen before Ron returns.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 08, 2015, 08:52:21 PM
Is it the place Harry and Hermione camp at when Ron first arrives by Deluminator after leaving the Shell Cottage? The place from which Harry and Hermione Disapparates from under the Invisibility Cloak and ends up in the Forest of Dean instead?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 08, 2015, 09:40:05 PM
Yes, it is the place that Harry and Hermione go to after Godric's Hollow. As Hermione doesn't say otherwise, I assume it is a random hillside with no connection to the wizarding world. You could argue that Ron returns while they were there, but Harry and Hermione are there first in any case.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 09, 2015, 10:28:51 AM
Yes, it is the place that Harry and Hermione go to after Godric's Hollow. As Hermione doesn't say otherwise, I assume it is a random hillside with no connection to the wizarding world. You could argue that Ron returns while they were there, but Harry and Hermione are there first in any case.
I'm not going to argue that, I agree Ron returned when they met. :) Thanks for a nice round!

I'm thinking of a thing... 
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 10, 2015, 12:03:59 PM
Is it owned by someone identifiable?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 10, 2015, 02:01:37 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on May 10, 2015, 10:20:14 PM
Is it magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 11, 2015, 12:32:32 AM
Is it in the first 4 books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 11, 2015, 07:42:39 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 14, 2015, 10:33:35 PM
Is it seen at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 15, 2015, 06:09:22 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 15, 2015, 11:02:13 PM
is it owned by a female ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 15, 2015, 11:22:41 PM
Is it in the first two books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 15, 2015, 11:36:12 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5) No, it is not owned by a female.
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 16, 2015, 11:04:22 PM
is it owned by a student ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 17, 2015, 07:56:22 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5) No, it is not owned by a female.
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) Yes, it is owned by a student.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 17, 2015, 08:03:06 PM
does the student belongs to Gryffindor ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 18, 2015, 07:13:50 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5) No, it is not owned by a female.
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) Yes, it is owned by a student.
8 ) Yes, the student does belong to Gryffindor.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 18, 2015, 11:33:11 PM
is the student a Quidditch Player ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 18, 2015, 11:50:55 PM
Is it in the third book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 19, 2015, 08:58:26 AM
is it bigger than a Quaffle ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 19, 2015, 04:58:32 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5) No, it is not owned by a female.
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) Yes, it is owned by a student.
8 ) Yes, the student does belong to Gryffindor.
9) Yes, the student is a Quidditch Player.
10) No, it is not in POA.
11)  No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 19, 2015, 09:43:29 PM
Is it owned by a Weasley?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 19, 2015, 10:59:54 PM
is it seen in the GH ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 20, 2015, 09:09:32 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5) No, it is not owned by a female.
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) Yes, it is owned by a student.
8 ) Yes, the student does belong to Gryffindor.
9) Yes, the student is a Quidditch Player.
10) No, it is not in POA.
11)  No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is owned by a Weasley.


is it seen in the GH ?
GH?  :what: I'm not sure what you mean, please explain!
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 20, 2015, 10:12:09 PM
Is it owned by Ron?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 20, 2015, 10:20:30 PM
sorry don't know why I wrote GH ?    I was thinking of the Great Hall.   :ashamed:

the correct question is: is it seen in the Great Hall ?


my new question is:     Is it seen more then once ?



Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: T-Dane on May 21, 2015, 08:57:55 AM
Is it a badge?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 21, 2015, 12:02:16 PM
is it seen before christmas ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 21, 2015, 06:50:32 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5) No, it is not owned by a female.
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) Yes, it is owned by a student.
8 ) Yes, the student does belong to Gryffindor.
9) Yes, the student is a Quidditch Player.
10) No, it is not in POA.
11)  No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is owned by a Weasley.
13) No, it is not seen in the Great Hall.  - Thanks! :)
14) No, it is not owned by Ron.
15) No, as far as I am aware of it is not seen (properly) more than once.
16) No, it is not a badge.
17) Yes, it is seen before Christmas.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 22, 2015, 12:26:52 AM
is it owned by Percy  ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 24, 2015, 12:52:07 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5) No, it is not owned by a female.
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) Yes, it is owned by a student.
8 ) Yes, the student does belong to Gryffindor.
9) Yes, the student is a Quidditch Player.
10) No, it is not in POA.
11)  No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is owned by a Weasley.
13) No, it is not seen in the Great Hall.  - Thanks! :)
14) No, it is not owned by Ron.
15) No, as far as I am aware of it is not seen (properly) more than once.
16) No, it is not a badge.
17) Yes, it is seen before Christmas.
18) No, it is not owned by Percy.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 24, 2015, 04:05:10 PM
has it something to do with the twins investigations for their products ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 24, 2015, 09:00:06 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5) No, it is not owned by a female.
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) Yes, it is owned by a student.
8 ) Yes, the student does belong to Gryffindor.
9) Yes, the student is a Quidditch Player.
10) No, it is not in POA.
11)  No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is owned by a Weasley.
13) No, it is not seen in the Great Hall.  - Thanks! :)
14) No, it is not owned by Ron.
15) No, as far as I am aware of it is not seen (properly) more than once.
16) No, it is not a badge.
17) Yes, it is seen before Christmas.
18) No, it is not owned by Percy.
19) No, I wouldn't say that it has anything to do with the twins' investigations for their products...  :fredgeorge:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on May 24, 2015, 11:43:22 PM
has it something to do with regular studies at Hogwarts ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 25, 2015, 09:27:14 AM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5) No, it is not owned by a female.
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) Yes, it is owned by a student.
8 ) Yes, the student does belong to Gryffindor.
9) Yes, the student is a Quidditch Player.
10) No, it is not in POA.
11)  No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is owned by a Weasley.
13) No, it is not seen in the Great Hall.  - Thanks! :)
14) No, it is not owned by Ron.
15) No, as far as I am aware of it is not seen (properly) more than once.
16) No, it is not a badge.
17) Yes, it is seen before Christmas.
18) No, it is not owned by Percy.
19) No, I wouldn't say that it has anything to do with the twins' investigations for their products...  :fredgeorge:
20) No, it has nothing to do with regular studies.


Hint: Reconsider 19 ;)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 25, 2015, 09:01:10 PM
Is the thing one of the twins products (or potential products)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 25, 2015, 09:29:40 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
2) Yes, it is magical.
3) Yes, it is in the first four books.
4) Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5) No, it is not owned by a female.
6) No, it is not in the first two books.
7) Yes, it is owned by a student.
8 ) Yes, the student does belong to Gryffindor.
9) Yes, the student is a Quidditch Player.
10) No, it is not in POA.
11)  No, it is not bigger than a Quaffle.
12) Yes, it is owned by a Weasley.
13) No, it is not seen in the Great Hall.  - Thanks! :)
14) No, it is not owned by Ron.
15) No, as far as I am aware of it is not seen (properly) more than once.
16) No, it is not a badge.
17) Yes, it is seen before Christmas.
18) No, it is not owned by Percy.
19) No, I wouldn't say that it has anything to do with the twins' investigations for their products...  :fredgeorge:
20) No, it has nothing to do with regular studies.
21) Yes, this thing is  one of the twins products (or potential products). :fredgeorge:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 31, 2015, 04:28:57 PM
Is it the custard cream that Neville ate?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: T-Dane on May 31, 2015, 06:17:17 PM
Did it accidentally get out of the trunk as the Taxi driver tried to get it onboard his car?

NOW y'all got me reading GoF again!!! A wonderful revisit!  :love:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 31, 2015, 09:42:49 PM
Is it the custard cream that Neville ate?
:stars: :yay: It is the twin's custard cream that Neville ate! Congratulations! Your turn!  :thumbup:


... NOW y'all got me reading GoF again!!! A wonderful revisit!  :love:
Terrific!  :fredgeorge:



I'm thinking of a thing...


1) Yes, it is owned by someone identifiable.
7) Yes, it is owned by a student.
8 ) Yes, the student does belong to Gryffindor.
9) Yes, the student is a Quidditch Player.
Well... we know it belongs to the twins, which I think counts.

2) Yes, it is magical.
Seeing as eating it results in becoming a canary, I think it counts.


15) No, as far as I am aware of it is not seen (properly) more than once.
The Custard creams are mentioned by the narrator, in so far as people were seen turning into birds (or however it is phrased) everywhere over a period of time, and people becomming wary of accepting food from anyone in case it concealed such a thing, so we kind of see its effects. But we don't actually see the custard creams again.


Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 31, 2015, 10:43:22 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 01, 2015, 08:32:28 PM
Does it have any magical abilities?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 01, 2015, 09:30:05 PM
Is it seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 01, 2015, 11:52:47 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 02, 2015, 07:12:00 PM
Is it owned?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 03, 2015, 12:11:05 AM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, I think we can assume it is owned.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 03, 2015, 01:18:06 AM
Is it seen at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 03, 2015, 11:17:10 AM
Can we assume that it is owned by someone magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: T-Dane on June 03, 2015, 03:36:28 PM
Is it seen in Muggle-world only?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on June 03, 2015, 11:41:11 PM
is it bigger than a quaffle ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 04, 2015, 11:58:02 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, I think we can assume it is owned.
4. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, we can assume it is owned by someone magical.
6. Yes, it is seen only in the muggle world.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on June 06, 2015, 11:48:59 AM
is it seen in more than one book ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 06, 2015, 08:21:57 PM
Is it seen in London?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on June 06, 2015, 09:27:27 PM
is it owned by a female ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 07, 2015, 12:02:53 AM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, I think we can assume it is owned.
4. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, we can assume it is owned by someone magical.
6. Yes, it is seen only in the muggle world.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. No, it is not seen in London.
10. No, it is not owned by a female.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on June 07, 2015, 09:20:38 AM
is it seen in or arround Privet drive ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 07, 2015, 08:50:28 PM
Is it seen in (inside or outside of) someone's home?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on June 07, 2015, 11:45:10 PM
is it seen in one of the first three books ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 08, 2015, 12:01:35 AM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, I think we can assume it is owned.
4. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, we can assume it is owned by someone magical.
6. Yes, it is seen only in the muggle world.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. No, it is not seen in London.
10. No, it is not owned by a female.
11. No, it is not seen in or around Privet Drive.
12. No, it is not seen in or near someone's home.
13. No, it is not seen in one of the first three books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on June 08, 2015, 09:13:28 AM
is it seen in one of the last two books ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 08, 2015, 11:55:26 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, I think we can assume it is owned.
4. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, we can assume it is owned by someone magical.
6. Yes, it is seen only in the muggle world.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. No, it is not seen in London.
10. No, it is not owned by a female.
11. No, it is not seen in or around Privet Drive.
12. No, it is not seen in or near someone's home.
13. No, it is not seen in one of the first three books.
14. No, it is not seen in one of the last two books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 09, 2015, 08:14:33 PM
Is it seen in OOP?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 09, 2015, 10:49:37 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, I think we can assume it is owned.
4. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, we can assume it is owned by someone magical.
6. Yes, it is seen only in the muggle world.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. No, it is not seen in London.
10. No, it is not owned by a female.
11. No, it is not seen in or around Privet Drive.
12. No, it is not seen in or near someone's home.
13. No, it is not seen in one of the first three books.
14. No, it is not seen in one of the last two books.
15. No, it is not seen in OotP.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 10, 2015, 07:38:38 PM
Is it seen before the trio returns to the Burrow after the QWC? 
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 10, 2015, 11:39:42 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, I think we can assume it is owned.
4. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, we can assume it is owned by someone magical.
6. Yes, it is seen only in the muggle world.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. No, it is not seen in London.
10. No, it is not owned by a female.
11. No, it is not seen in or around Privet Drive.
12. No, it is not seen in or near someone's home.
13. No, it is not seen in one of the first three books.
14. No, it is not seen in one of the last two books.
15. No, it is not seen in OotP.
16. No, it is not seen before the trio returns to the Burrow after the QWC.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 11, 2015, 09:48:42 PM
Is it seen before Christmas (in GOF)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 11, 2015, 11:58:47 PM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, I think we can assume it is owned.
4. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, we can assume it is owned by someone magical.
6. Yes, it is seen only in the muggle world.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. No, it is not seen in London.
10. No, it is not owned by a female.
11. No, it is not seen in or around Privet Drive.
12. No, it is not seen in or near someone's home.
13. No, it is not seen in one of the first three books.
14. No, it is not seen in one of the last two books.
15. No, it is not seen in OotP.
16. No, it is not seen before the trio returns to the Burrow after the QWC.
17. No, it is not seen before Christmas (in GOF).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 12, 2015, 12:28:57 AM
Is it seen in or near the graveyard?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 12, 2015, 07:11:14 PM
Is it used?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 13, 2015, 12:12:44 AM
I am thinking of a thing.
1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, I think we can assume it is owned.
4. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, we can assume it is owned by someone magical.
6. Yes, it is seen only in the muggle world.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. No, it is not seen in London.
10. No, it is not owned by a female.
11. No, it is not seen in or around Privet Drive.
12. No, it is not seen in or near someone's home.
13. No, it is not seen in one of the first three books.
14. No, it is not seen in one of the last two books.
15. No, it is not seen in OotP.
16. No, it is not seen before the trio returns to the Burrow after the QWC.
17. No, it is not seen before Christmas (in GOF).
18. Yes, it is seen in or near the graveyard.
19. Yes, it is used.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 13, 2015, 06:16:05 PM
Is it the bone from Tom Riddle Sr that help revive his son?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 13, 2015, 06:58:38 PM
Is it the cauldron that Wormtail uses to make the potion for Voldemort's rebirth? :voldemort:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 14, 2015, 12:19:40 PM
Is it the cauldron that Wormtail uses to make the potion for Voldemort's rebirth? :voldemort:
Yes, it is the cauldron used to give Voldemort a body again. In my answers
1. I don't consider cauldrons to be magical unless we are told otherwise (for example if they are self stirring, or hopping pots).
2,5,10. I assume the cauldron is owned by Wormtail or Voldemort now, though it might have been stolen previously, possibly from Crouch Snr. or Madeye Moody.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 15, 2015, 01:43:54 AM
Thank you, roonwit! :)

I am thinking of a creature.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 16, 2015, 06:53:50 PM
Is this creature a Beast (as opposed to a Being)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 17, 2015, 01:52:13 AM
I am thinking of a creature.

Is this creature a Beast (as opposed to a Being)?
Well...this question is a bit difficult to answer, because creatures (as defined for this game) aren't exactly split neatly into beasts or beings.  I'll have to reverse your question in order to give a 'yes/no' answer.

1. No, it's not a being.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 17, 2015, 11:49:36 PM
Is it in the first four books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 18, 2015, 07:56:47 AM
Are we looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on June 18, 2015, 08:50:24 AM
is it owned by someone specific ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 18, 2015, 12:39:56 PM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 20, 2015, 09:40:36 PM
Does it have any magical abilities?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 21, 2015, 07:58:44 AM
Can it fly?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 21, 2015, 08:10:37 PM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 21, 2015, 08:50:56 PM
Is it in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 21, 2015, 09:04:24 PM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 21, 2015, 09:54:36 PM
Is it in GOF?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 21, 2015, 10:48:59 PM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
8. Yes, it is in GoF.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on June 21, 2015, 11:17:59 PM
does it have fur ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 22, 2015, 04:58:07 AM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
8. Yes, it is in GoF.
9. No, it does not have fur.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 22, 2015, 07:47:06 PM
Is it the pet Grindylow tied outside a merperson's house in the lake?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 22, 2015, 11:18:04 PM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
8. Yes, it is in GoF.
9. No, it does not have fur.
10. No, it is not the pet Grindylow tied outside a merperson's house in the lake.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 23, 2015, 05:21:30 AM
Does it live in the lake?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 23, 2015, 01:37:30 PM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
8. Yes, it is in GoF.
9. No, it does not have fur.
10. No, it is not the pet Grindylow tied outside a merperson's house in the lake.
11. No, it does not live in the lake.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 23, 2015, 07:37:29 PM
Is it seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 23, 2015, 07:54:05 PM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
8. Yes, it is in GoF.
9. No, it does not have fur.
10. No, it is not the pet Grindylow tied outside a merperson's house in the lake.
11. No, it does not live in the lake.
12. Yes, it is seen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 24, 2015, 07:58:21 PM
Does it have anything to do with the TWT?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 25, 2015, 03:10:47 PM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
8. Yes, it is in GoF.
9. No, it does not have fur.
10. No, it is not the pet Grindylow tied outside a merperson's house in the lake.
11. No, it does not live in the lake.
12. Yes, it is seen.
13. No, it has nothing to do with the Triwizard Tournament.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 26, 2015, 05:29:11 AM
Do we see it at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 26, 2015, 12:53:33 PM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
8. Yes, it is in GoF.
9. No, it does not have fur.
10. No, it is not the pet Grindylow tied outside a merperson's house in the lake.
11. No, it does not live in the lake.
12. Yes, it is seen.
13. No, it has nothing to do with the Triwizard Tournament.
14. Yes, we do see it at Hogwarts.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 27, 2015, 06:07:18 PM
Is it seen in COMC class?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 28, 2015, 03:08:13 AM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
8. Yes, it is in GoF.
9. No, it does not have fur.
10. No, it is not the pet Grindylow tied outside a merperson's house in the lake.
11. No, it does not live in the lake.
12. Yes, it is seen.
13. No, it has nothing to do with the Triwizard Tournament.
14. Yes, we do see it at Hogwarts.
15. No, we do not see it in a Care of Magical Creatures class.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 29, 2015, 12:28:20 AM
Is it seen in or around Hogwarts (not including Hogsmeade)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 29, 2015, 04:21:35 AM
14. Yes, we do see it at Hogwarts.
Is it seen in or around Hogwarts (not including Hogsmeade)?

I can't tell if you've missed Question #14 or if you are looking for further information.  I'll assume it's the latter...


I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
8. Yes, it is in GoF.
9. No, it does not have fur.
10. No, it is not the pet Grindylow tied outside a merperson's house in the lake.
11. No, it does not live in the lake.
12. Yes, it is seen.
13. No, it has nothing to do with the Triwizard Tournament.
14. Yes, we do see it at Hogwarts.
15. No, we do not see it in a Care of Magical Creatures class.
16. No, it's not seen around Hogwarts (not including Hogsmeade).  (It is seen in Hogwarts though. See #14)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 29, 2015, 08:27:55 PM
Is it seen outdoors?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 30, 2015, 09:07:19 PM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
8. Yes, it is in GoF.
9. No, it does not have fur.
10. No, it is not the pet Grindylow tied outside a merperson's house in the lake.
11. No, it does not live in the lake.
12. Yes, it is seen.
13. No, it has nothing to do with the Triwizard Tournament.
14. Yes, we do see it at Hogwarts.
15. No, we do not see it in a Care of Magical Creatures class.
16. No, it's not seen around Hogwarts (not including Hogsmeade).  (It is seen in Hogwarts though. See #14)
17. No, it's not seen outdoors.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 01, 2015, 05:26:49 PM
Is it one of the spiders that "Moody" used as illustrative examples?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on July 01, 2015, 11:11:53 PM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
8. Yes, it is in GoF.
9. No, it does not have fur.
10. No, it is not the pet Grindylow tied outside a merperson's house in the lake.
11. No, it does not live in the lake.
12. Yes, it is seen.
13. No, it has nothing to do with the Triwizard Tournament.
14. Yes, we do see it at Hogwarts.
15. No, we do not see it in a Care of Magical Creatures class.
16. No, it's not seen around Hogwarts (not including Hogsmeade).  (It is seen in Hogwarts though. See #14)
17. No, it's not seen outdoors.
18. Yes, it is one of the spiders that fake Moody used as illustrative examples.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 02, 2015, 05:59:10 PM
Is it the one that died?  :voldemortak:   :aragog:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on July 02, 2015, 06:23:40 PM
I am thinking of a creature.

1. No, it's not a being.
2. Yes, it is in the first four books.
3. No, we are not looking for a whole species (as opposed to an individual creature).
4. Yes, I would say that it is probably owned by someone specific.
5. No, it doesn't have any magical abilities.
6. No, it cannot fly.
7. No, it's not in more than one book.
8. Yes, it is in GoF.
9. No, it does not have fur.
10. No, it is not the pet Grindylow tied outside a merperson's house in the lake.
11. No, it does not live in the lake.
12. Yes, it is seen.
13. No, it has nothing to do with the Triwizard Tournament.
14. Yes, we do see it at Hogwarts.
15. No, we do not see it in a Care of Magical Creatures class.
16. No, it's not seen around Hogwarts (not including Hogsmeade).  (It is seen in Hogwarts though. See #14)
17. No, it's not seen outdoors.
18. Yes, it is one of the spiders that fake Moody used as illustrative examples.
19. No, it's not the one that died.  :voldemortak:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 02, 2015, 06:35:56 PM
Is it the one that was hit by Crucio?  :aragog:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on July 02, 2015, 06:57:58 PM
Is it the one that was hit by Crucio?  :aragog:
Yes, perfect!  :thumbup: I chose this particular spider out of the three because it has a Snape reference.  Several chapters after we see that spider, Harry was very angry at Snape in Potions class and wished that he knew how to perform Crucio so he could "have Snape flat on his back like that spider, jerking and twitching...."  (And two books later he does attempt to use it on Snape.)  :harry: :snape:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 03, 2015, 06:40:02 PM
Is it the one that was hit by Crucio?  :aragog:
Yes, perfect!  :thumbup: I chose this particular spider out of the three because it has a Snape reference.  Several chapters after we see that spider, Harry was very angry at Snape in Potions class and wished that he knew how to perform Crucio so he could "have Snape flat on his back like that spider, jerking and twitching...."  (And two books later he does attempt to use it on Snape.)  :harry: :snape:
I should have known!  :lol:

Thanks for a really interesting round which had me quite stalled for awhile on possible creatures. And then, suddenly, those spiders popped into my head... :aragog::aragog::aragog:


So... I am thinking of a thing....
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on July 05, 2015, 07:45:00 PM
Is it magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 05, 2015, 09:18:11 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, it is magical.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on July 10, 2015, 09:08:27 AM
Is it owned by a student?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 10, 2015, 07:48:07 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) No, it is not owned by a student.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on July 11, 2015, 12:49:36 AM
Is it seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 11, 2015, 07:30:19 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) No, it is not owned by a student.
3) Yes, it is seen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on July 12, 2015, 07:25:21 PM
Is it seen in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 13, 2015, 09:10:21 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) No, it is not owned by a student.
3) Yes, it is seen.
4) No, it is not seen in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on July 13, 2015, 07:35:06 PM
Is it seen at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 13, 2015, 08:14:13 PM
Is it seen in the first four books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 13, 2015, 09:56:58 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) No, it is not owned by a student.
3) Yes, it is seen.
4) No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5) No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
6) No, it is not seen in the first four books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on July 15, 2015, 04:03:08 AM
Is it seen in DH?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 15, 2015, 07:29:07 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) No, it is not owned by a student.
3) Yes, it is seen.
4) No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5) No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
6) No, it is not seen in the first four books.
7) No, it is not seen in DH.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 15, 2015, 08:06:11 PM
Is it seen in HBP?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 16, 2015, 09:37:16 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) No, it is not owned by a student.
3) Yes, it is seen.
4) No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5) No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
6) No, it is not seen in the first four books.
7) No, it is not seen in DH.
8.) No, it is not seen in HBP. :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 17, 2015, 12:15:31 AM
Is it seen at Grimmauld Place or in or near St. Mungo's?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 17, 2015, 06:00:35 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) No, it is not owned by a student.
3) Yes, it is seen.
4) No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5) No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
6) No, it is not seen in the first four books.
7) No, it is not seen in DH.
8.) No, it is not seen in HBP. :)
9) No, it is not seen at Grimmauld Place or in or near St. Mungo's.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Hermione P on July 18, 2015, 06:11:19 AM
Is it seen at Privet Drive?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 18, 2015, 10:49:40 AM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) No, it is not owned by a student.
3) Yes, it is seen.
4) No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5) No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
6) No, it is not seen in the first four books.
7) No, it is not seen in DH.
8.) No, it is not seen in HBP. :)
9) No, it is not seen at Grimmauld Place or in or near St. Mungo's.
10) Yes, it is seen at Privet Drive.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 20, 2015, 09:31:48 PM
Is it a broomstick?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 24, 2015, 08:13:43 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) No, it is not owned by a student.
3) Yes, it is seen.
4) No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5) No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
6) No, it is not seen in the first four books.
7) No, it is not seen in DH.
8.) No, it is not seen in HBP. :)
9) No, it is not seen at Grimmauld Place or in or near St. Mungo's.
10) Yes, it is seen at Privet Drive.
11) No, it is not a broomstick.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 24, 2015, 08:49:03 PM
Is it a wand?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 25, 2015, 09:19:07 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) No, it is not owned by a student.
3) Yes, it is seen.
4) No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5) No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
6) No, it is not seen in the first four books.
7) No, it is not seen in DH.
8.) No, it is not seen in HBP. :)
9) No, it is not seen at Grimmauld Place or in or near St. Mungo's.
10) Yes, it is seen at Privet Drive.
11) No, it is not a broomstick.
12) No, it is not a wand.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 25, 2015, 10:02:33 PM
Does it have writing or letters on it?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 26, 2015, 05:49:23 PM
I'm thinking of a thing....

1) Yes, it is magical.
2) No, it is not owned by a student.
3) Yes, it is seen.
4) No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5) No, it is not seen at Hogwarts.
6) No, it is not seen in the first four books.
7) No, it is not seen in DH.
8.) No, it is not seen in HBP. :)
9) No, it is not seen at Grimmauld Place or in or near St. Mungo's.
10) Yes, it is seen at Privet Drive.
11) No, it is not a broomstick.
12) No, it is not a wand.
13) Yes, it does have writing and/or letters on it.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 07, 2015, 12:24:01 AM
Is it the howler sent to Petunia?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 08, 2015, 12:26:04 PM
Is it the howler sent to Petunia?
YES it is!  :yay: Well done! Your turn. :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on August 08, 2015, 06:18:55 PM
2) No, it is not owned by a student.

Is it the howler sent to Petunia?
YES it is!  :yay: Well done! Your turn. :)

I had mistakenly eliminated the Howler as a possibility because I misremembered it as having been sent to Harry, thus belonging to Harry.  Well done and congratulations, roonwit!
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 16, 2015, 11:42:09 PM
I am thinking of a thing
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 17, 2015, 06:15:29 PM
Does it have any magical abilities?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 17, 2015, 11:51:57 PM
I am thinking of a thing

1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 18, 2015, 05:22:00 PM
Is it seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 18, 2015, 11:57:14 PM
I am thinking of a thing

1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 20, 2015, 08:19:34 PM
Is it seen in an environment where there are more wizards/witches than Muggles?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 21, 2015, 12:07:56 AM
I am thinking of a thing

1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, it is seen in an environment where there are more wizards/witches than Muggles.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 21, 2015, 07:06:46 PM
Is it seen at Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on August 22, 2015, 02:27:53 AM
Does it belong to someone specific?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 22, 2015, 03:40:19 PM
I am thinking of a thing

1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, it is seen in an environment where there are more wizards/witches than Muggles.
4. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, it belongs to someone specific (though this is somewhat debatable).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 23, 2015, 04:11:43 PM
Does it belong to any from Hogwarts Staff?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 24, 2015, 12:23:35 AM
I am thinking of a thing

1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, it is seen in an environment where there are more wizards/witches than Muggles.
4. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, it belongs to someone specific (though this is somewhat debatable).
6. No, it does not belong to any of the Hogwarts Staff.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on August 24, 2015, 03:17:47 PM
is it bigger than a Quaffle ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 24, 2015, 07:28:13 PM
Is it seen in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 24, 2015, 11:52:23 PM
I am thinking of a thing

1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, it is seen in an environment where there are more wizards/witches than Muggles.
4. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, it belongs to someone specific (though this is somewhat debatable).
6. No, it does not belong to any of the Hogwarts Staff.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 25, 2015, 04:17:31 PM
Does it belong to a Hogwarts student?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 26, 2015, 12:07:24 AM
I am thinking of a thing

1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, it is seen in an environment where there are more wizards/witches than Muggles.
4. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, it belongs to someone specific (though this is somewhat debatable).
6. No, it does not belong to any of the Hogwarts Staff.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. Yes, it belongs to a Hogwarts student.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 28, 2015, 05:30:56 PM
Does it belong to someone that is in Harry's year?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 30, 2015, 11:41:08 PM
I am thinking of a thing

1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, it is seen in an environment where there are more wizards/witches than Muggles.
4. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, it belongs to someone specific (though this is somewhat debatable).
6. No, it does not belong to any of the Hogwarts Staff.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. Yes, it belongs to a Hogwarts student.
10. Yes, it belongs to someone in Harry's year.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 31, 2015, 06:29:00 PM
Does it belong to a Gryffindor?  :gryffindorc:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 01, 2015, 12:25:03 AM
I am thinking of a thing

1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, it is seen in an environment where there are more wizards/witches than Muggles.
4. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, it belongs to someone specific (though this is somewhat debatable).
6. No, it does not belong to any of the Hogwarts Staff.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. Yes, it belongs to a Hogwarts student.
10. Yes, it belongs to someone in Harry's year.
11. No, it does not belong to a Gryffindor.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 01, 2015, 06:38:35 PM
Does it belong to a DA member?  :da:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 01, 2015, 08:20:45 PM
I am thinking of a thing

1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, it is seen in an environment where there are more wizards/witches than Muggles.
4. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, it belongs to someone specific (though this is somewhat debatable).
6. No, it does not belong to any of the Hogwarts Staff.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. Yes, it belongs to a Hogwarts student.
10. Yes, it belongs to someone in Harry's year.
11. No, it does not belong to a Gryffindor.
12. No, it does not belong to a DA member.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 02, 2015, 07:17:00 PM
Does it belong to Draco?  :draco:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 03, 2015, 11:13:50 PM
I am thinking of a thing

1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, it is seen in an environment where there are more wizards/witches than Muggles.
4. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, it belongs to someone specific (though this is somewhat debatable).
6. No, it does not belong to any of the Hogwarts Staff.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. Yes, it belongs to a Hogwarts student.
10. Yes, it belongs to someone in Harry's year.
11. No, it does not belong to a Gryffindor.
12. No, it does not belong to a DA member.
13. No, it does not belong to Draco.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on September 04, 2015, 01:07:11 AM
Is it seen in one of the first four books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 04, 2015, 05:00:26 PM
Does it belong to a Slytherin?  :slytherinc:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 06, 2015, 11:45:52 PM
I am thinking of a thing

1. No, it does not have any magical abilities.
2. Yes, it is seen.
3. Yes, it is seen in an environment where there are more wizards/witches than Muggles.
4. Yes, it is seen at Hogwarts.
5. Yes, it belongs to someone specific (though this is somewhat debatable).
6. No, it does not belong to any of the Hogwarts Staff.
7. Yes, it is bigger than a quaffle.
8. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
9. Yes, it belongs to a Hogwarts student.
10. Yes, it belongs to someone in Harry's year.
11. No, it does not belong to a Gryffindor.
12. No, it does not belong to a DA member.
13. No, it does not belong to Draco.
14. No, it is not seen in the first four books.
15. Yes, it does belong to a Slytherin.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 07, 2015, 08:02:59 PM
Is it the scales that Goyle drops in HBP while disguised as a girl?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 07, 2015, 10:49:56 PM
Is it the scales that Goyle drops in HBP while disguised as a girl?
Yes it is. I decided that Goyle was the effective owner of the scales, and they weren't the set Goyle used in potions in the earlier books because Goyle wasn't doing potions in the HBP year so wouldn't have brought them (though I suppose it is possible he did need them if he was repeating his potions OWLs as well as transfiguration), and the trio might recognize those scales, thus he had a new (possibly stolen) set for his HBP lookout duties.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 08, 2015, 07:10:06 PM
Is it the scales that Goyle drops in HBP while disguised as a girl?
Yes it is. I decided that Goyle was the effective owner of the scales, and they weren't the set Goyle used in potions in the earlier books because Goyle wasn't doing potions in the HBP year so wouldn't have brought them (though I suppose it is possible he did need them if he was repeating his potions OWLs as well as transfiguration), and the trio might recognize those scales, thus he had a new (possibly stolen) set for his HBP lookout duties.
Seems as reasonable assumptions. :)

Good job of thinking of a possession for Goyle! Definitely out of the ordinary. :) Thanks for a fun round.


I'm thinking of a place.....  :hmm:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 09, 2015, 03:48:38 PM
do we see this place ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 09, 2015, 06:02:26 PM
I'm thinking of a place....  :hmm:

1) Yes, we do see this place.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 09, 2015, 11:53:34 PM
Have Harry, Hermione and Ron all visited this place?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 10, 2015, 09:33:15 PM
I'm thinking of a place....  :hmm:

1) Yes, we do see this place.
2) Yes, Harry, Hermione and Ron have all visited this place.   --- Great question by the way! :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 11, 2015, 08:32:52 AM
Is the place seen in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 11, 2015, 09:59:03 PM
I'm thinking of a place....  :hmm:

1) Yes, we do see this place.
2) Yes, Harry, Hermione and Ron have all visited this place.   
3) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on September 12, 2015, 09:39:21 PM
Has Professor Snape been to this place as far as we know?  :snape:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 12, 2015, 09:48:17 PM
I'm thinking of a place....  :hmm:

1) Yes, we do see this place.
2) Yes, Harry, Hermione and Ron have all visited this place.   
3) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
4) Yes, it is likely that Snape has been to this place, but I don't think it is ever confirmed true in the books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on September 17, 2015, 01:34:59 AM
Is it part of Hogwarts (including all the buildings and grounds)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 17, 2015, 08:05:45 PM
I'm thinking of a place....  :hmm:

1) Yes, we do see this place.
2) Yes, Harry, Hermione and Ron have all visited this place.   
3) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
4) Yes, it is likely that Snape has been to this place, but I don't think it is ever confirmed true in the books.
5) No it is not any part of hogwarts (including building, grounds).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 18, 2015, 11:53:31 AM
is this place in the muggle world ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 19, 2015, 07:04:12 PM
Is the place seen in the first three books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 20, 2015, 08:00:02 AM
I'm thinking of a place....  :hmm:

1) Yes, we do see this place.
2) Yes, Harry, Hermione and Ron have all visited this place.   
3) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
4) Yes, it is likely that Snape has been to this place, but I don't think it is ever confirmed true in the books.
5) No it is not any part of Hogwarts (including building, grounds).
6) No, this place is not in the Muggle world.
7) Yes, this place is seen in [one or more of] the first three books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 21, 2015, 10:23:57 PM
Is it seen in book two?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 22, 2015, 06:46:08 PM
I'm thinking of a place....  :hmm:

1) Yes, we do see this place.
2) Yes, Harry, Hermione and Ron have all visited this place.   
3) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
4) Yes, it is likely that Snape has been to this place, but I don't think it is ever confirmed true in the books.
5) No it is not any part of Hogwarts (including building, grounds).
6) No, this place is not in the Muggle world.
7) Yes, this place is seen in [one or more of] the first three books.
8 ) No, it is not seen in COS.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 22, 2015, 11:11:25 PM
Is it in Diagon Alley?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 23, 2015, 08:03:21 PM
I'm thinking of a place....  :hmm:

1) Yes, we do see this place.
2) Yes, Harry, Hermione and Ron have all visited this place.   
3) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
4) Yes, it is likely that Snape has been to this place, but I don't think it is ever confirmed true in the books.
5) No it is not any part of Hogwarts (including building, grounds).
6) No, this place is not in the Muggle world.
7) Yes, this place is seen in [one or more of] the first three books.
8 ) No, it is not seen in COS.
9) No, it is not in Diagon Alley.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 26, 2015, 03:33:27 PM
Is it seen in PoA?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on September 26, 2015, 11:35:13 PM
is this place in any part of London ? 
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 28, 2015, 04:46:38 AM
I'm thinking of a place....  :hmm:

1) Yes, we do see this place.
2) Yes, Harry, Hermione and Ron have all visited this place.   
3) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
4) Yes, it is likely that Snape has been to this place, but I don't think it is ever confirmed true in the books.
5) No it is not any part of Hogwarts (including building, grounds).
6) No, this place is not in the Muggle world.
7) Yes, this place is seen in [one or more of] the first three books.
8 ) No, it is not seen in COS.
9) No, it is not in Diagon Alley.
10) Yes, it is seen in POA.
11) No, it is not in any part of London.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 28, 2015, 07:43:09 PM
Is it in Hogsmeade?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 28, 2015, 07:59:59 PM
I'm thinking of a place....  :hmm:

1) Yes, we do see this place.
2) Yes, Harry, Hermione and Ron have all visited this place.   
3) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
4) Yes, it is likely that Snape has been to this place, but I don't think it is ever confirmed true in the books.
5) No it is not any part of Hogwarts (including building, grounds).
6) No, this place is not in the Muggle world.
7) Yes, this place is seen in [one or more of] the first three books.
8 ) No, it is not seen in COS.
9) No, it is not in Diagon Alley.
10) Yes, it is seen in POA.
11) No, it is not in any part of London.
12) Yes, It is in Hogsmeade.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 29, 2015, 11:32:06 PM
Is Harry in this place during his first visit to Hogsmeade?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 30, 2015, 08:03:12 PM
I'm thinking of a place....  :hmm:

1) Yes, we do see this place.
2) Yes, Harry, Hermione and Ron have all visited this place.   
3) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
4) Yes, it is likely that Snape has been to this place, but I don't think it is ever confirmed true in the books.
5) No it is not any part of Hogwarts (including building, grounds).
6) No, this place is not in the Muggle world.
7) Yes, this place is seen in [one or more of] the first three books.
8 ) No, it is not seen in COS.
9) No, it is not in Diagon Alley.
10) Yes, it is seen in POA.
11) No, it is not in any part of London.
12) Yes, It is in Hogsmeade.
13) Yes, Harry is in this place during his first visit to Hogsmeade.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on October 10, 2015, 05:37:42 PM
Is it the Three Broomsticks?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 11, 2015, 06:49:09 PM
I'm thinking of a place....  :hmm:

1) Yes, we do see this place.
2) Yes, Harry, Hermione and Ron have all visited this place.   
3) Yes, it is seen in more than one book.
4) Yes, it is likely that Snape has been to this place, but I don't think it is ever confirmed true in the books.
5) No it is not any part of Hogwarts (including building, grounds).
6) No, this place is not in the Muggle world.
7) Yes, this place is seen in [one or more of] the first three books.
8 ) No, it is not seen in COS.
9) No, it is not in Diagon Alley.
10) Yes, it is seen in POA.
11) No, it is not in any part of London.
12) Yes, It is in Hogsmeade.
13) Yes, Harry is in this place during his first visit to Hogsmeade.
14) No, it's not The Three Broomsticks.  :fredgeorgequidditch: :harryquidditch: :shake:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on October 17, 2015, 10:04:30 PM
Is it Honeydukes or part of Honeydukes?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 17, 2015, 10:31:52 PM
YES! It is Honeydukes!  :stars: Congratulation!

Your turn...  :crookshanks:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on October 31, 2015, 02:07:32 PM
I am thinking of a place.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 31, 2015, 08:54:43 PM
Is it seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 01, 2015, 06:18:17 AM
is it in the wizards world ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 01, 2015, 09:10:28 PM
I am thinking of a place.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, it is in the wizards' world.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 03, 2015, 06:41:14 PM
Is it seen in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 06, 2015, 12:01:11 AM
I am thinking of a place.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, it is in the wizards' world.
3. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 06, 2015, 04:42:02 AM
Is it seen in any of the last three?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 06, 2015, 11:42:02 PM
I am thinking of a place.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, it is in the wizards' world.
3. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
4. Yes, it is seen in one of the last three books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Hermione P on November 07, 2015, 03:51:36 AM
Has Hermione been there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 07, 2015, 02:27:00 PM
Is it seen in DH?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 07, 2015, 11:20:32 PM
I am thinking of a place.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, it is in the wizards' world.
3. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
4. Yes, it is seen in one of the last three books.
5. Yes, Hermione has been there.
6. No, it is not seen in DH.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Hermione P on November 08, 2015, 03:04:56 AM
Is it seen in Order of the Phoenix?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 08, 2015, 06:54:39 AM
Is it outdoors?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 11, 2015, 12:07:14 AM
I am thinking of a place.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, it is in the wizards' world.
3. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
4. Yes, it is seen in one of the last three books.
5. Yes, Hermione has been there.
6. No, it is not seen in DH.
7. Yes, it is seen in the Order of the Phoenix.
8. No, it is not outdoors.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Hermione P on November 11, 2015, 01:19:56 PM
Is it St Mungo's?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 11, 2015, 06:30:55 PM
Is it somewhere in scotland?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 11, 2015, 07:53:12 PM
I am thinking of a place.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, it is in the wizards' world.
3. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
4. Yes, it is seen in one of the last three books.
5. Yes, Hermione has been there.
6. No, it is not seen in DH.
7. Yes, it is seen in the Order of the Phoenix.
8. No, it is not outdoors.
9. No, it is not St. Mungo's (though you may want to rephrase the question).
10. No, it is not somewhere in Scotland.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Hermione P on November 12, 2015, 11:19:56 AM
Is this place in St. Mungo's?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 12, 2015, 06:50:11 PM
Is it the ward where Lockhart and the Longbottoms are?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 12, 2015, 10:06:42 PM
Is it the ward where Lockhart and the Longbottoms are?
Yes, it is the Janus Thickey Ward in St. Mungo's.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 15, 2015, 09:54:28 AM
 :stars: Thanks, roonwit!

I'm thinking of a person....
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on November 17, 2015, 07:38:46 AM
is this person seen ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 17, 2015, 08:40:01 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are seen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 23, 2015, 09:15:35 PM
Is the person known to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 23, 2015, 09:31:44 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are seen.
2) No, this person is not known to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 28, 2015, 04:50:11 PM
Is the person seen in the first 4 books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 28, 2015, 10:07:44 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are seen.
2) No, this person is not known to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, this person is seen in one or more of the first 4 books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 30, 2015, 09:27:09 PM
Is the person seen in one or more of the first two books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 30, 2015, 09:49:45 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are seen.
2) No, this person is not known to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, this person is seen in one or more of the first 4 books.
4) No, this person is not seen in PS/SS or COS.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 07, 2015, 05:05:26 PM
Is this person seen in book 3?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 07, 2015, 09:06:30 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are seen.
2) No, this person is not known to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, this person is seen in one or more of the first 4 books.
4) No, this person is not seen in PS/SS or COS.
5) No, this person is not seen in POA.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 09, 2015, 07:05:45 PM
Is the person seen at Hogwarts in the 4th book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 10, 2015, 03:02:35 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are seen.
2) No, this person is not known to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, this person is seen in one or more of the first 4 books.
4) No, this person is not seen in PS/SS or COS.
5) No, this person is not seen in POA.
6) Yes, this person is seen at Hogwarts in GOF.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 11, 2015, 09:28:10 PM
Is the person from Durmstrang or Beauxbatons (including parents and sister of the champions)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 11, 2015, 10:00:37 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are seen.
2) No, this person is not known to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, this person is seen in one or more of the first 4 books.
4) No, this person is not seen in PS/SS or COS.
5) No, this person is not seen in POA.
6) Yes, this person is seen at Hogwarts in GOF.
7) Yes, this person is from either Durmstrang or Beauxbatons (including parents and sister of the champions).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 16, 2015, 02:24:23 AM
is this person from Beauxbatons ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 16, 2015, 04:25:20 AM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are seen.
2) No, this person is not known to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, this person is seen in one or more of the first 4 books.
4) No, this person is not seen in PS/SS or COS.
5) No, this person is not seen in POA.
6) Yes, this person is seen at Hogwarts in GOF.
7) Yes, this person is from either Durmstrang or Beauxbatons (including parents and sister of the champions).
8 ) No, they are not from Beauxbatons.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 16, 2015, 06:07:18 AM
does Harry speak to this person ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 16, 2015, 09:50:29 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are seen.
2) No, this person is not known to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, this person is seen in one or more of the first 4 books.
4) No, this person is not seen in PS/SS or COS.
5) No, this person is not seen in POA.
6) Yes, this person is seen at Hogwarts in GOF.
7) Yes, this person is from either Durmstrang or Beauxbatons (including parents and sister of the champions).
8 ) No, they are not from Beauxbatons.
9) Yes, Harry does speak to this person.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on December 18, 2015, 05:25:35 PM
is this person Victor Krum ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 21, 2015, 10:24:07 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are seen.
2) No, this person is not known to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, this person is seen in one or more of the first 4 books.
4) No, this person is not seen in PS/SS or COS.
5) No, this person is not seen in POA.
6) Yes, this person is seen at Hogwarts in GOF.
7) Yes, this person is from either Durmstrang or Beauxbatons (including parents and sister of the champions).
8 ) No, they are not from Beauxbatons.
9) Yes, Harry does speak to this person.
10) No, it's not Viktor Krum.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on December 24, 2015, 11:20:34 AM
Is it one of the other Durmstrang students?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 27, 2015, 11:12:36 PM
I'm thinking of a person....

1) Yes, they are seen.
2) No, this person is not known to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, this person is seen in one or more of the first 4 books.
4) No, this person is not seen in PS/SS or COS.
5) No, this person is not seen in POA.
6) Yes, this person is seen at Hogwarts in GOF.
7) Yes, this person is from either Durmstrang or Beauxbatons (including parents and sister of the champions).
8 ) No, they are not from Beauxbatons.
9) Yes, Harry does speak to this person.
10) No, it's not Viktor Krum.
11) No, it is not any of the other students from Durmstrang...
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 16, 2016, 01:16:21 AM
Igor Karkaroff?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 16, 2016, 09:44:41 PM
Igor Karkaroff?
Perfect!  :thumbup: We've got a winner! :) Your turn.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 16, 2016, 11:30:42 PM
Thanks, Evreka :)

I'm thinking of a thing.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 17, 2016, 07:26:39 PM
Is it seen?  :madeye:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 17, 2016, 09:00:27 PM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 18, 2016, 09:55:22 PM
Is it owned?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 18, 2016, 09:56:43 PM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 19, 2016, 08:14:54 PM
Is it seen at Hogwarts? (Anywhere within the outer limits of Hogwarts Grounds as well as either inside or outside.)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 19, 2016, 11:10:36 PM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 20, 2016, 08:26:55 PM
Is it seen in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 20, 2016, 09:01:36 PM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 22, 2016, 08:45:12 PM
Is it seen in any of the first three?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 22, 2016, 09:59:38 PM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on January 22, 2016, 11:55:39 PM
Is it seen in PoA?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 23, 2016, 12:27:43 AM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on January 23, 2016, 01:37:25 AM
Is it magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 23, 2016, 01:46:30 AM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on January 23, 2016, 02:05:46 AM
Does it belong to a Muggle?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 23, 2016, 02:07:28 AM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
8. No, it does not belong to a Muggle.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on January 23, 2016, 02:14:19 AM
Is it seen before Harry goes back to Howgarts for the new school year?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 23, 2016, 02:20:58 AM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
8. No, it does not belong to a Muggle.
9. Yes, it is seen before Harry goes back to Hogwarts for the new school year.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 23, 2016, 07:58:10 PM
Is it seen in Diagon Alley? (Including the Leaky Cauldron)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 24, 2016, 01:40:02 AM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
8. No, it does not belong to a Muggle.
9. Yes, it is seen before Harry goes back to Hogwarts for the new school year.
10. No, it is not seen in Diagon Alley (including the Leaky Cauldron).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 24, 2016, 10:14:36 AM
Is it seen at the Dursleys?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on January 24, 2016, 08:28:01 PM
Is it bigger than a Quaffle?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 25, 2016, 02:50:21 AM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
8. No, it does not belong to a Muggle.
9. Yes, it is seen before Harry goes back to Hogwarts for the new school year.
10. No, it is not seen in Diagon Alley (including the Leaky Cauldron).
11. Yes, it is seen at the Dursleys.
12. Yes, maybe, I think in one dimension at least it's bigger than a Quaffle.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 25, 2016, 06:51:38 PM
Is it something written?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 25, 2016, 10:40:27 PM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
8. No, it does not belong to a Muggle.
9. Yes, it is seen before Harry goes back to Hogwarts for the new school year.
10. No, it is not seen in Diagon Alley (including the Leaky Cauldron).
11. Yes, it is seen at the Dursleys.
12. Yes, maybe, I think in one dimension at least it's bigger than a Quaffle.
13. Yes, it is something written.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 26, 2016, 05:37:00 PM
Is it Harry's homework on witch burnings?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 26, 2016, 11:45:12 PM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
8. No, it does not belong to a Muggle.
9. Yes, it is seen before Harry goes back to Hogwarts for the new school year.
10. No, it is not seen in Diagon Alley (including the Leaky Cauldron).
11. Yes, it is seen at the Dursleys.
12. Yes, maybe, I think in one dimension at least it's bigger than a Quaffle.
13. Yes, it is something written.
14. No, it is not Harry's homework on witch burnings.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 27, 2016, 09:34:58 PM
Does it have to do with Harry's school work?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 27, 2016, 09:39:47 PM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
8. No, it does not belong to a Muggle.
9. Yes, it is seen before Harry goes back to Hogwarts for the new school year.
10. No, it is not seen in Diagon Alley (including the Leaky Cauldron).
11. Yes, it is seen at the Dursleys.
12. Yes, maybe, I think in one dimension at least it's bigger than a Quaffle.
13. Yes, it is something written.
14. No, it is not Harry's homework on witch burnings.
15. No, it does not have to do with Harry's school work.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 28, 2016, 08:06:44 PM
Is it Harry's letter to Sirius?  :harry: :hedwig: :siriusbike:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 28, 2016, 11:46:11 PM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
8. No, it does not belong to a Muggle.
9. Yes, it is seen before Harry goes back to Hogwarts for the new school year.
10. No, it is not seen in Diagon Alley (including the Leaky Cauldron).
11. Yes, it is seen at the Dursleys.
12. Yes, maybe, I think in one dimension at least it's bigger than a Quaffle.
13. Yes, it is something written.
14. No, it is not Harry's homework on witch burnings.
15. No, it does not have to do with Harry's school work.
16. No, it is not Harry's letter to Sirius. (Check out answers to #4, #6 and #9)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on January 30, 2016, 01:52:30 AM
Is it one of the letters Harry received from his friends on his birthday?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 30, 2016, 01:58:41 AM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
8. No, it does not belong to a Muggle.
9. Yes, it is seen before Harry goes back to Hogwarts for the new school year.
10. No, it is not seen in Diagon Alley (including the Leaky Cauldron).
11. Yes, it is seen at the Dursleys.
12. Yes, maybe, I think in one dimension at least it's bigger than a Quaffle.
13. Yes, it is something written.
14. No, it is not Harry's homework on witch burnings.
15. No, it does not have to do with Harry's school work.
16. No, it is not Harry's letter to Sirius.
17. No, it is not one of the letters Harry received from his friends on his birthday.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 30, 2016, 12:04:53 PM
Is it something related to Harry's birthday?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 30, 2016, 10:11:39 PM
'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
8. No, it does not belong to a Muggle.
9. Yes, it is seen before Harry goes back to Hogwarts for the new school year.
10. No, it is not seen in Diagon Alley (including the Leaky Cauldron).
11. Yes, it is seen at the Dursleys.
12. Yes, maybe, I think in one dimension at least it's bigger than a Quaffle.
13. Yes, it is something written.
14. No, it is not Harry's homework on witch burnings.
15. No, it does not have to do with Harry's school work.
16. No, it is not Harry's letter to Sirius.
17. No, it is not one of the letters Harry received from his friends on his birthday.
18. No, it is not something related to Harry's birthday.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on January 31, 2016, 05:25:01 PM
Do we see it before the owls sore in through Harry's window at the start of the book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 31, 2016, 06:52:10 PM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
8. No, it does not belong to a Muggle.
9. Yes, it is seen before Harry goes back to Hogwarts for the new school year.
10. No, it is not seen in Diagon Alley (including the Leaky Cauldron).
11. Yes, it is seen at the Dursleys.
12. Yes, maybe, I think in one dimension at least it's bigger than a Quaffle.
13. Yes, it is something written.
14. No, it is not Harry's homework on witch burnings.
15. No, it does not have to do with Harry's school work.
16. No, it is not Harry's letter to Sirius.
17. No, it is not one of the letters Harry received from his friends on his birthday.
18. No, it is not something related to Harry's birthday.
19. No, we do not see it before the owls soar in through Harry's window at the start of the book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on January 31, 2016, 07:17:42 PM
Is it Harry's Hogsmeade permissions form?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on January 31, 2016, 07:47:41 PM
I'm thinking of a thing.

1. Yes, it is seen.
2. Yes, I would say it is owned.
3. No, it is not seen at Hogwarts, either castle or the grounds etc (I think).
4. No, it is not seen in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is seen in one of the first three books.
6. Yes, it is seen in PoA.
7. No, it is not magical.
8. No, it does not belong to a Muggle.
9. Yes, it is seen before Harry goes back to Hogwarts for the new school year.
10. No, it is not seen in Diagon Alley (including the Leaky Cauldron).
11. Yes, it is seen at the Dursleys.
12. Yes, maybe, I think in one dimension at least it's bigger than a Quaffle.
13. Yes, it is something written.
14. No, it is not Harry's homework on witch burnings.
15. No, it does not have to do with Harry's school work.
16. No, it is not Harry's letter to Sirius.
17. No, it is not one of the letters Harry received from his friends on his birthday.
18. No, it is not something related to Harry's birthday.
19. No, we do not see it before the owls soar in through Harry's window at the start of the book.

Is it Harry's Hogsmeade permissions form?
Yes! It is Harry's permission form for Hogsmeade. Congratulations, roonwit!  :stars: :clap:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 14, 2016, 10:47:58 PM
I am thinking of a place.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 16, 2016, 07:45:23 PM
Is it somebody's home?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: nellythemarrow on February 21, 2016, 04:29:20 AM
Is it in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 21, 2016, 10:20:10 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 22, 2016, 07:38:04 PM
Is it in one of the last two?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 22, 2016, 11:58:17 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 23, 2016, 05:22:13 PM
Is it in DH?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 23, 2016, 11:36:27 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 24, 2016, 07:55:13 PM
Has one or more of the trio ever been there?  :ron:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 25, 2016, 11:51:07 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 26, 2016, 08:54:46 PM
Is it a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on February 28, 2016, 06:47:42 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on February 28, 2016, 08:30:06 PM
Has Harry been there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 02, 2016, 10:28:37 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 03, 2016, 08:32:15 PM
Is it Budleigh Badderton?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 05, 2016, 09:12:53 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 06, 2016, 01:54:58 PM
Has Ron or Hermione (or both) been there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 08, 2016, 12:33:02 AM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
9. Yes, at least one of Ron or Hermione has been there.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 08, 2016, 08:19:07 PM
Is it in Hogsmead?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on March 09, 2016, 05:29:14 PM
Has Professor Snape been there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 11, 2016, 09:35:41 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
9. Yes, at least one of Ron or Hermione has been there.
10. No, it is not in Hogsmeade.
11. Yes, Professor Snape has been there.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 11, 2016, 10:13:21 PM
Is it somewhere inside Grimmauld Place 12?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 12, 2016, 07:53:15 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
9. Yes, at least one of Ron or Hermione has been there.
10. No, it is not in Hogsmeade.
11. Yes, Professor Snape has been there.
12. No, it is not somewhere inside 12 Grimmauld Place (I don't think we went there in HBP).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 12, 2016, 08:15:18 PM
Does Harry go there before returning to Hogwarts in September?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 13, 2016, 10:29:11 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
9. Yes, at least one of Ron or Hermione has been there.
10. No, it is not in Hogsmeade.
11. Yes, Professor Snape has been there.
12. No, it is not somewhere inside 12 Grimmauld Place (I don't think we went there in HBP).
13. No, Harry doesn't go there in HBP before returning to Hogwarts in September.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 14, 2016, 09:06:37 PM
Do we see it before term/semester ends for Christmas?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 15, 2016, 11:54:02 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
9. Yes, at least one of Ron or Hermione has been there.
10. No, it is not in Hogsmeade.
11. Yes, Professor Snape has been there.
12. No, it is not somewhere inside 12 Grimmauld Place (I don't think we went there in HBP).
13. No, Harry doesn't go there in HBP before returning to Hogwarts in September.
14. No, We don't see it before the term ends for Christmas in HBP.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 16, 2016, 06:49:25 PM
Do we see it during the Christmas holiday?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 16, 2016, 11:48:37 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
9. Yes, at least one of Ron or Hermione has been there.
10. No, it is not in Hogsmeade.
11. Yes, Professor Snape has been there.
12. No, it is not somewhere inside 12 Grimmauld Place (I don't think we went there in HBP).
13. No, Harry doesn't go there in HBP before returning to Hogwarts in September.
14. No, We don't see it before the term ends for Christmas in HBP.
15. No, we don't see it in the Christmas holiday in HBP.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on March 18, 2016, 06:54:17 PM
Is it part of Hogwarts, including the grounds?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 18, 2016, 09:42:29 PM
Do we see it before Easter?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 19, 2016, 12:24:37 AM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
9. Yes, at least one of Ron or Hermione has been there.
10. No, it is not in Hogsmeade.
11. Yes, Professor Snape has been there.
12. No, it is not somewhere inside 12 Grimmauld Place (I don't think we went there in HBP).
13. No, Harry doesn't go there in HBP before returning to Hogwarts in September.
14. No, We don't see it before the term ends for Christmas in HBP.
15. No, we don't see it in the Christmas holiday in HBP.
16. Yes, it is part of Hogwarts, including the grounds.
I don't think it is clear in HBP when Easter occurs, so I am going to ignore that question.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 20, 2016, 12:42:37 PM
Fair enough :)

Is it the place where Albus' funeral is done?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 20, 2016, 11:49:30 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
9. Yes, at least one of Ron or Hermione has been there.
10. No, it is not in Hogsmeade.
11. Yes, Professor Snape has been there.
12. No, it is not somewhere inside 12 Grimmauld Place (I don't think we went there in HBP).
13. No, Harry doesn't go there in HBP before returning to Hogwarts in September.
14. No, We don't see it before the term ends for Christmas in HBP.
15. No, we don't see it in the Christmas holiday in HBP.
16. Yes, it is part of Hogwarts, including the grounds.
I don't think it is clear in HBP when Easter occurs, so I am going to ignore that question.
17. No, it is not the place where Albus' funeral is held.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 21, 2016, 06:34:03 AM
Is it Slughorn's office?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 21, 2016, 11:45:50 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
9. Yes, at least one of Ron or Hermione has been there.
10. No, it is not in Hogsmeade.
11. Yes, Professor Snape has been there.
12. No, it is not somewhere inside 12 Grimmauld Place (I don't think we went there in HBP).
13. No, Harry doesn't go there in HBP before returning to Hogwarts in September.
14. No, We don't see it before the term ends for Christmas in HBP.
15. No, we don't see it in the Christmas holiday in HBP.
16. Yes, it is part of Hogwarts, including the grounds.
I don't think it is clear in HBP when Easter occurs, so I am going to ignore that question.
17. No, it is not the place where Albus' funeral is held.
18. No, it is not Slughorn's office (that was where Slughorn's party was so we see it before Christmas).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 23, 2016, 08:10:29 PM
Do we see it before Ron gets the life-saving bezoar?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 25, 2016, 05:04:59 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
9. Yes, at least one of Ron or Hermione has been there.
10. No, it is not in Hogsmeade.
11. Yes, Professor Snape has been there.
12. No, it is not somewhere inside 12 Grimmauld Place (I don't think we went there in HBP).
13. No, Harry doesn't go there in HBP before returning to Hogwarts in September.
14. No, We don't see it before the term ends for Christmas in HBP.
15. No, we don't see it in the Christmas holiday in HBP.
16. Yes, it is part of Hogwarts, including the grounds.
I don't think it is clear in HBP when Easter occurs, so I am going to ignore that question.
17. No, it is not the place where Albus' funeral is held.
18. No, it is not Slughorn's office (that was where Slughorn's party was so we see it before Christmas).
19. No, we don't see it before Ron gets the life-saving bezoar.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 25, 2016, 05:10:46 PM
Do we see it before Harry and Albus leaves Hogwarts for the Cave?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 29, 2016, 12:19:39 AM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
9. Yes, at least one of Ron or Hermione has been there.
10. No, it is not in Hogsmeade.
11. Yes, Professor Snape has been there.
12. No, it is not somewhere inside 12 Grimmauld Place (I don't think we went there in HBP).
13. No, Harry doesn't go there in HBP before returning to Hogwarts in September.
14. No, We don't see it before the term ends for Christmas in HBP.
15. No, we don't see it in the Christmas holiday in HBP.
16. Yes, it is part of Hogwarts, including the grounds.
I don't think it is clear in HBP when Easter occurs, so I am going to ignore that question.
17. No, it is not the place where Albus' funeral is held.
18. No, it is not Slughorn's office (that was where Slughorn's party was so we see it before Christmas).
19. No, we don't see it before Ron gets the life-saving bezoar.
20. Yes, We see it before Harry and Albus leaves Hogwarts for the Cave.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 29, 2016, 08:30:46 PM
Is it inside the castle?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on March 30, 2016, 11:58:10 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. No, it is not someone's home.
2. No, it is not in more than one book (as far as I can tell).
3. Yes, it is in one of the last two books.
4. No, it is not in DH.
5. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
6. No, it is not a place Harry "visits" in his private classes with Albus.
7. Yes, Harry has been there.
8. No, it is not Budleigh Badderton (or anywhere in it).
9. Yes, at least one of Ron or Hermione has been there.
10. No, it is not in Hogsmeade.
11. Yes, Professor Snape has been there.
12. No, it is not somewhere inside 12 Grimmauld Place (I don't think we went there in HBP).
13. No, Harry doesn't go there in HBP before returning to Hogwarts in September.
14. No, We don't see it before the term ends for Christmas in HBP.
15. No, we don't see it in the Christmas holiday in HBP.
16. Yes, it is part of Hogwarts, including the grounds.
I don't think it is clear in HBP when Easter occurs, so I am going to ignore that question.
17. No, it is not the place where Albus' funeral is held.
18. No, it is not Slughorn's office (that was where Slughorn's party was so we see it before Christmas).
19. No, we don't see it before Ron gets the life-saving bezoar.
20. Yes, We see it before Harry and Albus leaves Hogwarts for the Cave.
21. Yes, it is inside the castle.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on March 31, 2016, 11:24:29 PM
Is it the boys bathroom where Harry and Ron encounters Myrtle? (If not, a hint would be nice.)

Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on April 01, 2016, 06:32:51 PM
Is it the boys bathroom where Harry and Ron encounters Myrtle? (If not, a hint would be nice.)
Yes, it is the bathroom where Ron and Harry meet Myrtle (and where presumably Harry and Draco later duel).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 01, 2016, 07:54:07 PM
 :yay: Finally tracked the place down! I must admit that I had to refer to the book though, rather than memory. Thanks for a fun round, roonwit!

I'm thinking of a thing....
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on April 09, 2016, 06:21:30 PM
Does it belong to someone?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 11, 2016, 09:47:34 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on April 19, 2016, 08:49:49 PM
Does it belong to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 19, 2016, 09:22:17 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there. :)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on April 24, 2016, 11:54:15 PM
Is the owner in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Eva Hedwig on April 26, 2016, 04:58:25 AM
is it magical ?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on April 30, 2016, 01:08:57 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there. :)
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 01, 2016, 05:41:18 PM
Is the owner in Ravenclaw?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 02, 2016, 07:55:38 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there. :)
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in  :ravenclawc:.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 02, 2016, 09:45:48 PM
Is the owner in the same school year as Harry?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 03, 2016, 06:42:35 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in Ravenclaw.
6) Yes, the owner is in the same school year as Harry.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 14, 2016, 10:08:35 PM
Is the owner female?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 15, 2016, 03:32:38 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in Ravenclaw.
6) Yes, the owner is in the same school year as Harry.
7) Yes, the owner is female.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 22, 2016, 05:02:46 PM
Is the owner Hermione?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 26, 2016, 10:01:26 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in Ravenclaw.
6) Yes, the owner is in the same school year as Harry.
7) Yes, the owner is female.
8 ) Yes the owner is Hermione.  :hermioneread:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on May 28, 2016, 03:02:50 AM
Is it seen?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on May 29, 2016, 08:04:45 PM
is it in the first four books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on May 31, 2016, 08:49:04 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in Ravenclaw.
6) Yes, the owner is in the same school year as Harry.
7) Yes, the owner is female.
8 ) Yes the owner is Hermione.  :hermioneread:
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) Yes, it is in the first four books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 04, 2016, 04:44:53 PM
Is it in the first two books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 05, 2016, 10:08:25 AM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in Ravenclaw.
6) Yes, the owner is in the same school year as Harry.
7) Yes, the owner is female.
8 ) Yes the owner is Hermione.  :hermioneread:
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) Yes, it is in the first four books.
11) No, it is not in the first two books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 05, 2016, 01:21:13 PM
Is it in the third book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 08, 2016, 09:44:33 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in Ravenclaw.
6) Yes, the owner is in the same school year as Harry.
7) Yes, the owner is female.
8 ) Yes the owner is Hermione.  :hermioneread:
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) Yes, it is in the first four books.
11) No, it is not in the first two books.
12) Yes, it is in POA.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 18, 2016, 09:41:39 PM
Do we see it on or before Christmas day in PoA?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 19, 2016, 12:11:08 AM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in Ravenclaw.
6) Yes, the owner is in the same school year as Harry.
7) Yes, the owner is female.
8 ) Yes the owner is Hermione.  :hermioneread:
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) Yes, it is in the first four books.
11) No, it is not in the first two books.
12) Yes, it is in POA.
13) Yes, I would say that we see it on or before Christmas day in PoA.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 25, 2016, 10:18:40 PM
Is it a book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on June 28, 2016, 03:27:07 AM
Do we see Hermione using this thing?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on June 28, 2016, 07:24:49 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in Ravenclaw.
6) Yes, the owner is in the same school year as Harry.
7) Yes, the owner is female.
8 ) Yes the owner is Hermione.  :hermioneread:
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) Yes, it is in the first four books.
11) No, it is not in the first two books.
12) Yes, it is in POA.
13) Yes, I would say that we see it on or before Christmas day in PoA.
14) Yes, it is a book.   :)
15) Yes, I would say that we see Hermione use it.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on June 30, 2016, 11:03:03 PM
Is it a text book for an optional subject introduced in the third year?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 01, 2016, 06:37:27 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in Ravenclaw.
6) Yes, the owner is in the same school year as Harry.
7) Yes, the owner is female.
8 ) Yes the owner is Hermione.  :hermioneread:
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) Yes, it is in the first four books.
11) No, it is not in the first two books.
12) Yes, it is in POA.
13) Yes, I would say that we see it on or before Christmas day in PoA.
14) Yes, it is a book.   :)
15) Yes, I would say that we see Hermione use it.
16) Yes, it is a text book for an optional subject introduced in the third year.  :nod:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 02, 2016, 04:10:41 PM
Is it a text book for a subject Ron and Harry are also taking?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 05, 2016, 07:57:18 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in Ravenclaw.
6) Yes, the owner is in the same school year as Harry.
7) Yes, the owner is female.
8 ) Yes the owner is Hermione.  :hermioneread:
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) Yes, it is in the first four books.
11) No, it is not in the first two books.
12) Yes, it is in POA.
13) Yes, I would say that we see it on or before Christmas day in PoA.
14) Yes, it is a book.   :)
15) Yes, I would say that we see Hermione use it.
16) Yes, it is a text book for an optional subject introduced in the third year. 
17) No, it is not a text book for a subject that Ron and Harry are also taking.  :shake: :harryronbb:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 10, 2016, 07:55:50 PM
Is it a muggle studies book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 11, 2016, 01:08:36 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in Ravenclaw.
6) Yes, the owner is in the same school year as Harry.
7) Yes, the owner is female.
8 ) Yes the owner is Hermione.  :hermioneread:
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) Yes, it is in the first four books.
11) No, it is not in the first two books.
12) Yes, it is in POA.
13) Yes, I would say that we see it on or before Christmas day in PoA.
14) Yes, it is a book.   :)
15) Yes, I would say that we see Hermione use it.
16) Yes, it is a text book for an optional subject introduced in the third year. 
17) No, it is not a text book for a subject that Ron and Harry are also taking. 
18) No, it is not a Muggle Studies book. :shake:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 17, 2016, 08:24:08 PM
Is it an Arithmancy book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 18, 2016, 10:01:22 PM
I'm thinking of a thing...

1) Yes, it belongs to someone.
2) Yes, it belongs to someone seen to be a student at Hogwarts while Harry is there.
3) Yes, the owner is in Gyffindor or Ravenclaw.
4) No, as far as I remember, we have no indication that it would be magical...
5) No, the owner is not in Ravenclaw.
6) Yes, the owner is in the same school year as Harry.
7) Yes, the owner is female.
8 ) Yes the owner is Hermione.  :hermioneread:
9) Yes, it is seen.
10) Yes, it is in the first four books.
11) No, it is not in the first two books.
12) Yes, it is in POA.
13) Yes, I would say that we see it on or before Christmas day in PoA.
14) Yes, it is a book.   :)
15) Yes, I would say that we see Hermione use it.
16) Yes, it is a text book for an optional subject introduced in the third year. 
17) No, it is not a text book for a subject that Ron and Harry are also taking. 
18) No, it is not a Muggle Studies book.
19) Yes, it is an Arithmancy book.  :) (I do have a specific one in mind, hence the "would say"s.)
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 20, 2016, 09:59:09 PM
Is it Numerology and Grammatica?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 21, 2016, 08:37:57 AM
Is it Numerology and Grammatica?
YES! It is! Well done!  :flower: :clap: Congratulations!

9) Yes, it is seen.
10) Yes, it is in the first four books.
12) Yes, it is in POA.
13) Yes, I would say that we see it on or before Christmas day in PoA.
15) Yes, I would say that we see Hermione use it.
The way the text is written, I deduce that Hermione has just one textbook for Arithmancy. On the other hand this is not stated explicitly. So answers including "would say" refers to a seen, unnamed Arithmancy book in POA which is read on occasion and also once used by Hermione as a pillow!
 
Numerology and Grammatica is mentioned twice and definitely seen once. In DH, as Hermione shifts through all books and decides which to pack or not, we definitely see it. When it is mentioned in POA (after Christmas) she is looking for her missing book, and I don't think either we readers or the trio sees it at the time...

You're turn, roonwit!
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 24, 2016, 12:15:21 PM
I am thinking of a place.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 25, 2016, 02:58:42 PM
Has one or more of the trio ever been there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 25, 2016, 11:57:12 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. One or more of the trio has been there.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 29, 2016, 08:56:11 PM
Has Harry been there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on July 30, 2016, 03:16:54 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
2. Yes, Harry has been there.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on July 31, 2016, 08:20:59 PM
Has Ron and/or Hermione been there too?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 01, 2016, 12:10:31 AM
I am thinking of a place.
1. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
2. Yes, Harry has been there.
3. Yes, one or both of Ron and Hermione have also been there.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 01, 2016, 08:49:37 AM
Is it seen and/or mentioned in more than one book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 06, 2016, 08:59:47 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
2. Yes, Harry has been there.
3. Yes, one or both of Ron and Hermione have also been there.
4. Yes, it is seen or mentioned or both seen and mentioned in more than one book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 07, 2016, 07:00:33 AM
Is it at Hogwarts (including castle and grounds)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 07, 2016, 05:00:32 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
2. Yes, Harry has been there.
3. Yes, one or both of Ron and Hermione have also been there.
4. Yes, it is seen or mentioned or both seen and mentioned in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is at Hogwarts (including castle and grounds).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 16, 2016, 09:02:42 PM
Is it indoors?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 17, 2016, 09:07:19 PM
I am thinking of a place.
1. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
2. Yes, Harry has been there.
3. Yes, one or both of Ron and Hermione have also been there.
4. Yes, it is seen or mentioned or both seen and mentioned in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is at Hogwarts (including castle and grounds).
6. No, it is not indoors.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 17, 2016, 09:29:57 PM
Has the entire trio been there?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 18, 2016, 12:33:10 AM
I am thinking of a place.
1. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
2. Yes, Harry has been there.
3. Yes, one or both of Ron and Hermione have also been there.
4. Yes, it is seen or mentioned or both seen and mentioned in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is at Hogwarts (including castle and grounds).
6. No, it is not indoors.
7. No, the entire trio have not been there.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 18, 2016, 07:18:23 PM
Is it in the Forbidden Forest?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 19, 2016, 12:19:07 AM
I am thinking of a place.
1. Yes, one or more of the trio has been there.
2. Yes, Harry has been there.
3. Yes, one or both of Ron and Hermione have also been there.
4. Yes, it is seen or mentioned or both seen and mentioned in more than one book.
5. Yes, it is at Hogwarts (including castle and grounds).
6. No, it is not indoors.
7. No, the entire trio have not been there.
8. Yes, it is in the Forbidden Forest.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 19, 2016, 09:27:41 PM
Is it Aragog's lair?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on August 25, 2016, 07:50:51 PM
Is it Aragog's lair?
Yes it is the clearing where Aragog and the spiders were in CoS and where Harry sacrificed himself in DH.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on August 25, 2016, 08:36:54 PM
Yay! Thanks for the round, roonwit!  :thumbup:

I'm thinking of a person...
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 01, 2016, 07:25:29 PM
Is the person female?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 02, 2016, 04:01:54 PM
I'm thinking of a person...
1) Yes, she is female.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 04, 2016, 07:55:00 PM
Is she in the first four books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 06, 2016, 09:29:29 PM
I'm thinking of a person...
1) Yes, she is female.
2) Yes, she is in one or more of the first four books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 10, 2016, 10:31:57 PM
Is she in one or more of the first two books?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 11, 2016, 09:07:38 AM
I'm thinking of a person...
1) Yes, she is female.
2) Yes, she is in one or more of the first four books.
3) Yes, she is in one or more of the first two books.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on September 25, 2016, 07:32:02 PM
Is she in the first book?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on September 26, 2016, 09:19:40 PM
I'm thinking of a person...
1) Yes, she is female.
2) Yes, she is in one or more of the first four books.
3) Yes, she is in one or more of the first two books.
4) Yes, she is in the first book.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on October 02, 2016, 04:47:42 PM
Is she a student at Hogwarts in Book 1?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 02, 2016, 07:25:18 PM
I'm thinking of a person...
1) Yes, she is female.
2) Yes, she is in one or more of the first four books.
3) Yes, she is in one or more of the first two books.
4) Yes, she is in the first book.
5) No, she is not a student in PS/SS.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on October 03, 2016, 07:17:35 PM
Is she seen in the Leaky Cauldron or Diagon Alley (in the street or shops)?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 04, 2016, 09:19:10 PM
I'm thinking of a person...
1) Yes, she is female.
2) Yes, she is in one or more of the first four books.
3) Yes, she is in one or more of the first two books.
4) Yes, she is in the first book.
5) No, she is not a student in PS/SS.
6) No, she is not seen in the Leaky Cauldron or Diagon Alley (either the street or shops).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on October 17, 2016, 04:22:31 PM
Is she in Book 1 before the point where Dumbledore and Harry first discuss the Mirror of Erised?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 18, 2016, 08:21:16 PM
I'm thinking of a person...
1) Yes, she is female.
2) Yes, she is in one or more of the first four books.
3) Yes, she is in one or more of the first two books.
4) Yes, she is in the first book.
5) No, she is not a student in PS/SS.
6) No, she is not seen in the Leaky Cauldron or Diagon Alley (either the street or shops).
7) Yes, she is in book one prior to Albus and Harry discussing the Mirror of Erised.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on October 21, 2016, 12:24:17 AM
Is she in Hogwarts or on the Hogwarts Express in Book 1?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 22, 2016, 09:03:31 AM
I'm thinking of a person...
1) Yes, she is female.
2) Yes, she is in one or more of the first four books.
3) Yes, she is in one or more of the first two books.
4) Yes, she is in the first book.
5) No, she is not a student in PS/SS.
6) No, she is not seen in the Leaky Cauldron or Diagon Alley (either the street or shops).
7) Yes, she is in book one prior to Albus and Harry discussing the Mirror of Erised.
8 ) Yes, she is in Hogwarts or on the Hogwarts Express in PS/SS.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on October 22, 2016, 09:52:03 PM
Is it the witch who pushes the trolley on the Hogwarts Express?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on October 29, 2016, 09:04:32 PM
Is it the witch who pushes the trolley on the Hogwarts Express?
Right you are!  :madeye: Congrats! Your turn!  :pawprint:
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 20, 2016, 11:12:03 PM
I am thinking of a person.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: ss19 on November 21, 2016, 12:59:32 AM
Is this person magical?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 22, 2016, 07:56:52 PM
Is this person female?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 22, 2016, 10:11:37 PM
I am thinking of a person.
1. Yes, the person is magical.
2. Yes, she is female.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: RiverSpirit on November 23, 2016, 07:53:00 AM
Did the person attend Hogwarts?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 23, 2016, 04:58:51 PM
I am thinking of a person.
1. Yes, the person is magical.
2. Yes, she is female.
3. Yes, the person has attended Hogwarts.
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on November 25, 2016, 09:45:50 PM
Did she attend Hogwarts during any of the years Harry did, including 1997/98?
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: roonwit on November 30, 2016, 11:14:42 PM
I am thinking of a person.
1. Yes, the person is magical.
2. Yes, she is female.
3. Yes, the person has attended Hogwarts.
4. Yes, she attended Hogwarts in at least one of the years that Harry did (including the year Harry only went there to find a horcrux).
Title: Re: 20 Questions Harry Potter Edition II
Post by: Evreka on December 01, 2016, 08:51:24 PM
Is she in Harry's school year or above [as opposed to the years below]?